🌏 Hoax? If Mars and other space missions were real, why is India unable to create lesser products?

[Bagheera0084]

Was it a hoax? If Mangalyaan and Chandrayaan missions were real, why is India unable to create lesser products?

USA faked the moon-landing in 1969. Did India do the same about Mars and Lunar space missions?

How would you explain that while India claims to travel such enormous distance in outer space but is unable to create products requiring much less ingenuity like military arms and equipments, mobile phones, computers, better trains, nuclear power plants, online social network, medicines, softwares etc?

How would you explain why India is still dependent on crap Russian technology for military items and nuclear power plant? The agreement for Kudankulam nuclear power plant was signed in early 1990s. But then came the dismantling of Soviet Union and the project was suspended for at least a decade. Why couldn’t Indians finish it on their own?

All these give rise to suspicion. Indians didn’t produce these little above said things. Just how did they achieve Mangalyaan and Chandrayaan?

 

[Lulldapull]

Was it a hoax? If Mangalyaan and Chandrayaan missions were real, why is India unable to create lesser products?

USA faked the moon-landing in 1969. Did India do the same about Mars and Lunar space missions?

How would you explain that while India claims to travel such enormous distance in outer space but is unable to create products requiring much less ingenuity like military arms and equipments, mobile phones, computers, better trains, nuclear power plants, online social network, medicines, softwares etc?

How would you explain why India is still dependent on crap Russian technology for military items and nuclear power plant? The agreement for Kudankulam nuclear power plant was signed in early 1990s. But then came the dismantling of Soviet Union and the project was suspended for at least a decade. Why couldn’t Indians finish it on their own?

All these give rise to suspicion. Indians didn’t produce these little above said things. Just how did they achieve Mangalyaan and Chandrayaan?

Its called specialization in a critical/ prestige sector. India concentrated on its space program and spent billions, whilst neglecting to carry out say produce cars. In doing so, India got its SLV's satellites and ICBM's.

Likewise, 25 years ago the Iranians concentrated on developing ballistic missiles and drones and understood the obsolescence of military aviation. Iran turned the tables on purchasing weaponry from the West and destroyed its dependency on foreign arms manufacturers.

 

[Bagheera0084]

Reverse engineering and then claiming the technology as indigenous:- India’s shameful secret revealed!

India did not master any rocket technology. India just copied it and reverse engineered soviet missile technology.

There are only a few countries in the world that have truly designed and deployed modern ballistic missiles from scratch. US and Soviet Union are pioneers. India is not one of them and never was.

During the late 1980's, India started off what it called the Project Devil (yes, that's a real name they gave to it) to develop missiles and rockets. A lot of technology from soviet union was reversed engineered or simply copied to produce Indian current missiles.

India has never produced any defence product on its own from scratch, so such questions should be asked with care. Indian missiles are copies or reverse engineered copies of Soviet missiles. Indian jet fighters are designed and developed by either Russian, American, or European companies. Likewise, the rockets used to probe space are Russian technology, painted with Indian colors (it costs money too).

The failure of Kaveri engine is a proof that India alone cannot design any modern defence article. Probably no western or European country or Russia was willing to extend help on this program, which is why the DRDO could not copy anything to make it working.

--------------------------

"During the first phase (1958-1970), India's missile ambitions were confined to building a first-generation anti-tank missile (ATGM) and developing a three-ton thrust, liquid-fueled rocket engine most likely based on the Soviet SA-2. In Phase II (1971-1979), India's missile program focused on two significant projects: the first, Project Devil, was an attempt to "reverse-engineer" the Soviet SA-2 surface-to-air missile (SAM), while the objective of the second, Project Valiant, was the development of a 1,500 km-range ballistic missile."

 

[Lulldapull]

Reverse engineering and then claiming the technology as indigenous:- India’s shameful secret revealed!

India did not master any rocket technology. India just copied it and reverse engineered soviet missile technology.

There are only a few countries in the world that have truly designed and deployed modern ballistic missiles from scratch. US and Soviet Union are pioneers. India is not one of them and never was.

During the late 1980's, India started off what it called the Project Devil (yes, that's a real name they gave to it) to develop missiles and rockets. A lot of technology from soviet union was reversed engineered or simply copied to produce Indian current missiles.

India has never produced any defence product on its own from scratch, so such questions should be asked with care. Indian missiles are copies or reverse engineered copies of Soviet missiles. Indian jet fighters are designed and developed by either Russian, American, or European companies. Likewise, the rockets used to probe space are Russian technology, painted with Indian colors (it costs money too).

The failure of Kaveri engine is a proof that India alone cannot design any modern defence article. Probably no western or European country or Russia was willing to extend help on this program, which is why the DRDO could not copy anything to make it working.

--------------------------

"During the first phase (1958-1970), India's missile ambitions were confined to building a first-generation anti-tank missile (ATGM) and developing a three-ton thrust, liquid-fueled rocket engine most likely based on the Soviet SA-2. In Phase II (1971-1979), India's missile program focused on two significant projects: the first, Project Devil, was an attempt to "reverse-engineer" the Soviet SA-2 surface-to-air missile (SAM), while the objective of the second, Project Valiant, was the development of a 1,500 km-range ballistic missile."

Correct. However, you gotta remember that China was in a similar position 40 odd years ago. Desperately reverse engineering and copying western equipment and weaponry, but now China is an innovator and we could say the same for Iran too, as they have substantial industrial output and are showing evidence of innovation and technology. Irans drones and missiles are world class and highly competitive on the global market. India has progressed on its SLV/ Space program and now can boast a huge manufacturing sector. India is probably number one in IT and its dozens of huge corporations are doing business globally.

You gotta start somewhere bhai. Work your way up gradually. Indians are not chutiya people because you don’t become a $5 trillion economy if you are stupid. Indias issue is population and I understand it is an insurmountable problem.

China, India and also Iran have successfully employed this reverse engineering/ copying model and all three are now sovereign powers. All three are innovators today.

Wish my country was as smart, but no! Pakistan lacked proper leadership in the last full generation and is now in trouble.

 

[Bagheera0084]

Was it a hoax? If Mangalyaan and Chandrayaan missions were real, why is India unable to create lesser products?

USA faked the moon-landing in 1969. Did India do the same about Mars and Lunar space missions?

How would you explain that while India claims to travel such enormous distance in outer space but is unable to create products requiring much less ingenuity like military arms and equipments, mobile phones, computers, better trains, nuclear power plants, online social network, medicines, softwares etc?

How would you explain why India is still dependent on crap Russian technology for military items and nuclear power plant? The agreement for Kudankulam nuclear power plant was signed in early 1990s. But then came the dismantling of Soviet Union and the project was suspended for at least a decade. Why couldn’t Indians finish it on their own?

All these give rise to suspicion. Indians didn’t produce these little above said things. Just how did they achieve Mangalyaan and Chandrayaan?

Reverse engineering and then claiming the technology as indigenous:- India’s shameful secret revealed!

India did not master any rocket technology. India just copied it and reverse engineered soviet missile technology.

There are only a few countries in the world that have truly designed and deployed modern ballistic missiles from scratch. US and Soviet Union are pioneers. India is not one of them and never was.

During the late 1980's, India started off what it called the Project Devil (yes, that's a real name they gave to it) to develop missiles and rockets. A lot of technology from soviet union was reversed engineered or simply copied to produce Indian current missiles.

India has never produced any defence product on its own from scratch, so such questions should be asked with care. Indian missiles are copies or reverse engineered copies of Soviet missiles. Indian jet fighters are designed and developed by either Russian, American, or European companies. Likewise, the rockets used to probe space are Russian technology, painted with Indian colors (it costs money too).

The failure of Kaveri engine is a proof that India alone cannot design any modern defence article. Probably no western or European country or Russia was willing to extend help on this program, which is why the DRDO could not copy anything to make it working.

--------------------------

"During the first phase (1958-1970), India's missile ambitions were confined to building a first-generation anti-tank missile (ATGM) and developing a three-ton thrust, liquid-fueled rocket engine most likely based on the Soviet SA-2. In Phase II (1971-1979), India's missile program focused on two significant projects: the first, Project Devil, was an attempt to "reverse-engineer" the Soviet SA-2 surface-to-air missile (SAM), while the objective of the second, Project Valiant, was the development of a 1,500 km-range ballistic missile."

@Lulldapull

 

[Lulldapull]

@Lulldapull

oh bhai, read this. India is in the top 5 in many things, but its also in the bottom 5 in many things. Its a developing country:

ISRO - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[Azad Kashmir]

soviet union did alot of engineering but guess wat they got technology transfer from usa. just type in major jordan diary on youtube he was responsible for transfer. his book is on amazon but priced 300 pound minimum. most technology is originally usa.