[🇧🇩] Ousted PM Hasina sentenced to death

Quick Reply âś“ Posted!
Quick Reply âś“ Posted!
[🇧🇩] Ousted PM Hasina sentenced to death
35
2K
More threads by Saif

G Bangladesh Defense

Crimes against humanity: Sheikh Hasina’s sentence and her political demise

Given the UN’s and international organisations’ opposition to capital punishment, it will be nearly impossible to mount pressure on India through them to return Sheikh Hasina. Nevertheless, the Bangladesh government should still exert direct diplomatic pressure on India for her extradition.

Updated: 18 Nov 2025, 11: 41

1763515302901.webp


As a nation, it is profoundly tragic and deeply shameful that crimes against humanity have been committed in this state in contemporary times. Yet it is also a matter of immense pride that through a genuine mass uprising, we succeeded in toppling those responsible and compelling them to flee the country. Following their fall, the responsibility of ensuring justice for those crimes has rested upon us as a nation.

Every act of justice serves as a deterrent against the repetition of similar crimes in the future. And because Sheikh Hasina’s crimes and trial have drawn international attention, the verdict is likely to have global implications as a deterrent as well.

The allegations against Sheikh Hasina went far beyond mere killings or acts of torture; they constituted crimes against humanity. Not only during the July mass uprising, but throughout her tenure, enforced disappearances and extrajudicial killings were carried out systematically.

Beyond that, the planned torture of BNP (Bangladesh Nationalist Party) activists, and for a time, custodial torture, filing fabricated cases, and various forms of persecution of Jamaat-e-Islami activists also fall within the ambit of crimes against humanity.

In the verdict of the first case filed against Sheikh Hasina, she received, as widely expected, the maximum penalty, death for three of the five charges. She was sentenced to life imprisonment for the remaining two charges.

The mass uprising against Sheikh Hasina will remain an extraordinary example in world history. Unarmed civilians, relying on nothing but moral force, confronted state forces and endured unimaginable brutality. There are records of mobile phone conversations that reveal that Sheikh Hasina is coolly instructing the use of lethal force in suppressing the protests. News media such as Al Jazeera and the BBC independently carried out forensic analyses for their documentaries and confirmed that the recordings were authentic and not technologically fabricated.

The possibility that Sheikh Hasina will be brought back to Bangladesh during her lifetime to face execution currently appears remote. The way the Indian government is providing refuge and security to her, makes it almost certain that she will not be handed back.

Those who were involved in resisting Sheikh Hasina’s mafia-like system, especially the bereaved families of the dead, those who were blinded or maimed, and the injured, were naturally keeping a close watch on this trial. But we must also remember that the verdict held significance for countless political activists and apolitical citizens, who suffered repression for opposing the Awami League’s prolonged rule over 15 years (including 10 and a half years in power unlawfully), and, also for the millions whose democratic rights were eroded and who were reduced to mere subjects in their own land.

This verdict has unquestionably delivered justice. Yet one may ask: will the verdict ultimately remain merely symbolic?

The possibility that Sheikh Hasina will be brought back to Bangladesh during her lifetime to face execution currently appears remote. The way the Indian government is providing refuge and security to her, makes it almost certain that she will not be handed back. Evidence of India’s mindset may be found in the fact that despite repeated objections from Bangladesh, including from the chief adviser himself, India has not prevented Sheikh Hasina from persistently making provocative statements against Bangladesh. Even on the day before the verdict, she issued grave threats against the forces behind the uprising.

Given the UN’s and international organisations’ opposition to capital punishment, it will be nearly impossible to mount pressure on India through them to return Sheikh Hasina. Nevertheless, the Bangladesh government should still exert direct diplomatic pressure on India for her extradition. The Indian government must consider that if it seeks to develop a sustainable bilateral relationship not merely with an individual or a single party, as in the Hasina era, but with the people of Bangladesh, then it must reconsider its position on Sheikh Hasina.

Under the Rome Statute, a confirmation-of-charges hearing may in special circumstances be held in absentia, but neither the main trial nor the subsequent hearings can take place without the presence of the accused.

Some questions may arise internationally regarding Sheikh Hasina’s trial. The UN and the Western countries oppose the death penalty. Additionally, the trial of an accused in absentia for crimes such as crimes against humanity is regarded as inconsistent with international standards.

Under the Rome Statute, a confirmation-of-charges hearing may in special circumstances be held in absentia, but neither the main trial nor the subsequent hearings can take place without the presence of the accused.

We can hope that the government, particularly the chief adviser, will be able to use his international stature to manage such pressure. Commissioning a full investigation by the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights will be considered as an extraordinary decision by the interim government. In its report, the OHCHR stated that crimes against humanity were committed on a large scale in Bangladesh during the July uprising, and that Sheikh Hasina was the principal decision-maker in the planning, leadership, direction, and coordination of those crimes.

Time will tell whether Sheikh Hasina can ever be brought back to face the verdict. But even if that proves impossible, the verdict has definitively sealed the end of her political future.

Discussions are ongoing regarding the possibility of trial of the Awami League as an organisation at the international court. Even if, for the sake of argument, such a tribunal were to conclude that the Awami League as an organisation is not guilty of crimes against humanity and thus is not banned, the fact remains that age does not favour Sheikh Hasina.

And even if the political context somehow permitted her return, it is virtually inconceivable that she could regain control of the party or resume leadership. At most, she may continue issuing incitements through occasional audio statements (she may avoid video messages to prevent showing her defeated appearance), which is likely to have only negative consequences for her party.

Given how well-known Sheikh Hasina and those at the centre of her power structure are, it is unsurprising that neither she nor those complicit in crimes against humanity will come close to acknowledging their guilt. But it is disheartening that a large section of the party’s supporters still have not grasped the scale and severity of the crimes committed by her and her associates. We want to hope that this verdict will prompt some of them to rethink.

People founded the state to establish a system within which all would live under a set of rules, and where breaches of those rules would be addressed through justice, thereby setting precedents for state and society. When a state fails to deliver justice, especially in cases involving crimes against humanity, it undermines its own legitimacy to administer justice in any matter. We must remember Martin Luther King’s famous dictum: “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.”

* Zahed Ur Rahman is a teacher and political analyst​
 

A historic verdict that carries weight even in absentia
Sheikh Hasina verdict

1763515834518.webp

PHOTO:STAR

There is a curious weight in witnessing a moment that feels like the culmination of years of waiting, even if the full consequence of that moment may never be realised. The verdict on Sheikh Hasina carries precisely that weight as a symbolic punctuation to a decade of fear, suffering, and quiet endurance. In a country where power so often felt untouchable, where law could be bent to protect those with influence and destroy those without, the decision to hold Hasina accountable is not merely judicial but also personal.

To speak of justice in abstract terms is simple. Scholars debate procedure, diplomats discuss optics, international media deliberate fairness, and foreign governments weigh consequences. But those frameworks rarely capture the intimate, almost physical relief that comes from seeing a powerful figure confronted with accountability. There is a long history of people waiting in court corridors that seemed endless, of families pressing photographs into the hands of reluctant officials, of citizens carrying memories of disappeared friends, neighbours, and colleagues, and of loved ones killed in protests. Justice has often been absent, delayed, or warped to suit politics.

There is a reason why this verdict feels like a personal win. It is because we have had to live under the shadow of her choices and watch the erosion of the everyday sense of safety, the subtle conditioning of our minds, the quiet fear in public spaces, the erosion of civic confidence. Accountability, even if delayed, restores a sense of moral order. It confirms that cruelty leaves traces that the world cannot ignore indefinitely.

This is why the debates framed in diplomatic language feel insufficient. When discussions revolve around whether a death sentence complicates her extradition, whether India will cooperate, or how the United Nations will respond, they obscure the emotional reality for citizens who have spent years negotiating life under fear. For these citizens, this sentence is neither a matter of politics nor of optics; it is a matter of recognition. A recognition that public accountability is possible, even if partially. So, while the world debates the technicalities, the symbolism of the verdict cannot be overstated. For the families of the disappeared, the survivors of forced disappearances and institutionalised cruelty, the families of the around 1,400 people killed in the uprising, and thousands more injured for life, its significance is immeasurable.

There is a certain inevitability in our emotional reaction. Those of us who carried the burden of witnessing injustice or suffered directly at its hands feel a sense of vindication. It is as if, at last, the moral ledger has been balanced, even if the numbers can never fully account for the enormity of our losses. Justice, in this sense, is an echo of recognition; an affirmation that what was endured matters, that those who once felt powerless are not entirely unheard. This is historic precisely because it exists in tension with what came before. For too long, the apparatus of the state allowed selective justice to define the rules. Decisions were guided by proximity to power, by allegiance, and by fear. Ordinary citizens—the witnesses, the silent sufferers—were forced to inhabit a parallel reality: a world in which laws existed, but rarely for them. The sentence against Hasina disrupts that parallel.

Of course, there is no guarantee that this moment will translate into lasting systemic change. The procedural aftermath, the international commentary, and the political manoeuvres that follow will test the depth of this symbolic victory. However, this moment affirms that ordinary citizens, who watched power move like a tidal wave over their lives, have a stake in the moral universe that the law is meant to inhabit. Hasina's sentence does not erase any of their sufferings, but it places them in a moral context where they are no longer invisible. That alone, in a country where invisibility has often been the default condition for those outside power, is transformative.

Perhaps the most profound aspect of this moment is the way it reframes the imagination of possibility. To see accountability reach a figure perceived for so long as untouchable opens a conceptual space. It allows us to imagine a society in which systems, though flawed, are not entirely devoid of redress. It allows a generation to measure possibility not by fear alone, but by the courage and persistence of those who upheld principle until the moment of recognition arrived. The debate over fairness and proportionality is not insignificant. Legal scholars, diplomats, and international observers will continue to dissect, question, and deliberate over the technical merits of the sentence. That discourse matters in its own domain. Yet for citizens who have experienced the consequences of unchecked authority, those considerations are secondary to the emotional and symbolic resonance of accountability.

History will judge the verdict in its own way, but for those who lived under the shadow of Hasina's regime, the personal significance precedes history. In the end, the importance of the sentence rendered on Hasina is not confined to law or politics. It is a moment that will enter collective memory as proof that justice, even when deferred, can arrive—and when it does, it feels like a personal triumph for all who lived under its absence.

Maisha Islam Monamee is a graduate from the Institute of Business Administration (IBA), University of Dhaka.​
 

India responds after Bangladesh's ICT issues verdict on Hasina
New Delhi stays silent on Dhaka’s call for ousted PM's extradition

1763516809674.webp


India today said it has noted the verdict announced by the International Crimes Tribunal of Bangladesh concerning former prime minister Sheikh Hasina and said New Delhi remains committed to "the best interests of the people of Bangladesh".

India's Ministry of External Affairs issued a statement hours after the ICT sentenced Hasina to death for crimes against humanity during the student-led protests during the July uprising last year.

"As a close neighbour, India remains committed to the best interests of the people of Bangladesh, including in peace, democracy, inclusion and stability in that country," read the statement.

"We will always engage constructively with all stakeholders to that end," it added.

India has not made any mention of Hasina's extradition to Bangladesh, which has called upon India to do so last December.​
 

Before Hasina lost in the court of law, she had lost in the court of the people

1763689401327.webp

VISUAL: ANWAR SOHEL

Let legal experts discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the ICT trial and verdict. Our focus will be on the fact that Sheikh Hasina's political demise had already occurred, and the "guilty verdict" was pronounced by the people, especially the younger generation, much earlier, during the tumultuous days of July-August 2024.

The future is always unpredictable, but as of now, her reputation lies in ruins and her political career buried under a mountain of debris of self-righteous arrogance, misgovernance, and impunity. Whatever may be Awami League's narrative about the national or international conspiracy behind Sheikh Hasina's fall, the fact is that the "death sentence" by the ICT was brought on by her own cruel suppression of political dissent, abuse of the law, corruption, partisan administration, bank looting, money laundering, suppression of independent media houses and corruption of the compliant ones, and finally, the killing of 1,400 citizens including children to stay in power during the last few weeks of her rule. Over the years, enforced disappearance and extra-judicial killings became the hallmark of her regime. Yes, there were some vital infrastructural developments, increase in per capita income, and growth in many social indicators, but the credit for them was swept aside by her destruction of democracy and overwhelming dictatorial rule.

Google News LinkFor all latest news, follow The Daily Star's Google News channel.
Eventually, Hasina's public acceptance totally collapsed, and hatred for her skyrocketed and the "death sentence" in the people's court was passed due to the killings on the streets, as mentioned above. What distinguishes her rule from that of many dictators and autocrats is that very few of them killed so many unarmed protesters in so short a time.

It is to Sheikh Hasina's credit that she was able to revive, reorganise, rejuvenate, and re-inspire Awami League (AL) to win elections in 1996 after 21 years out of power. Her first stint in office, especially the signing of the Chittagong Hill Tracts Accord (which she herself did not implement) and the Ganges Water Sharing Treaty, marked a new beginning for AL. But over the years, she effectively demolished her own party as she destroyed the police, the bureaucracy, the judiciary, etc—transforming it from a political powerhouse into an apparatus of extortion, corruption, and violence, and replacing ideology with sycophancy, principles with praise for the leader, and service to the people with service to themselves. Every nomination was for sale, most promotions within the party ranks came for a bribe, and every development project was treated as their plaything. BUET student Abrar Fahad's torture and murder by Chhatra League was testimony to how the AL's student body was turned into a murderous gang.

She did not take well either of her electoral defeats in 1991 and 2001. Her view that AL could never be defeated in a free and fair election, but only through rigged ones, partly made her reject these results, inventing the term "subtle-rigging." This marked the beginning of the arrogance and myopia that led her towards ignoring the truth and making massive blunders. A miraculous escape from a near-fatal attempt on her life in August 2004, in which 24 AL workers and leaders were killed, with no credible attempt by the then BNP government to investigate the grenade attack and punish the perpetrators, probably convinced Hasina that she would always be vulnerable as an opposition politician, and thus she may have decided never to give up power if and when she regained it. This, in our view, killed the prospect of democracy in Bangladesh.

Hasina regained power in a free and fair election in 2008, abolished the caretaker system in 2011, and then manipulated all the following elections held in 2014, 2018 and 2024. As her manipulations succeeded, she grew over-confident and felt that all her political allies were her pawns, all opponents manipulatable, and all dissenting voices easily suppressed. She became entrapped in the mindset of never admitting any mistakes, which resulted in her becoming supremely arrogant. During a meeting with editors in 2013, I heard her say: "In spite of so many attempts on my life, Allah has kept me alive for the purpose of carrying out His will. So, you all may write anything you like. I don't care." She felt she was divinely guided and, as such, had nothing to worry about. Thus, she plunged deeper into isolation on the one hand and became further intolerant on the other, both of which distanced her from the people and her party.

Changing the constitution to do away with the caretaker government system to oversee elections gave the first clear signal of Hasina's intention to take over the process of holding national elections. It was crystal clear that the 2014 election was openly and shamelessly manipulated. We have written before—but it deserves to be repeated—that out of 300 seats in parliament, 153 had only one contestant as others withdrew "voluntarily." The Election Commission, therefore, declared "elected" the only contestant there was, who happened to belong to the AL. Thus, in the 2014 election, before a single vote was cast, AL gained the majority in parliament to form a government. It was the most blatant, undemocratic, and immoral tinkering with elections ever. Could that have happened without the sitting prime minister (PM) and the party chief's direct involvement?

The fact that Sheikh Hasina's government was able to get away with such electoral frauds—marking a failure on the part of the BNP to make an effective protest—gave her and her sycophants a dangerous but ultimately illusory confidence that led them to repeat this manipulation in the 2018 and 2024 elections, thereby digging its own grave, into which it fell in July-August 2024.

The Covid pandemic during 2020-2022 isolated her from her party and the people. The day-to-day functioning of the administration became an unthinking ritual. This was followed by the ostentatious observance of Bangabandhu's birth centenary, which greatly offended the conscientious section of civil society and the public in general. It became clear that people's urgent needs had no place in the PM's mind; instead, creating an infallible personality cult was where her government placed all its attention and resources.

Hasina totally misread the national psyche, which is fundamentally averse to individual cultism. Dubious authors wrote thousands of books that the government bought at exorbitant prices, which, in fact, became a way of siphoning off public money to corrupt bureaucrats, teachers and so-called professionals, all of whom were in an undeclared competition to curry favour with the AL leadership and, of course, make some money in the process. The birth centenary celebration did not produce a single well-researched or intellectually honest account of the leader of our independence movement, but instead flooded schools, colleges, universities and all institutions linked with education with substandard publications not worth even the paper they were written on. The hundreds of statues built—a culture previously almost non-existent in Bangladesh—greatly damaged Bangabandhu's reputation instead of increasing authentic learning about him, eventually becoming targets when the anti-government rebellion started. The first time I saw his statue near the PMO in Dhaka, the image of Saddam Hussein's being demolished and dragged through the street flashed through my mind, and I intuitively felt that our people would reject it at the first opportunity they would get.

This was followed by the 50th anniversary celebration of Bangladesh's liberation in 2021. Hasina celebrated this crucial occasion as a continuation of Bangabandhu's birth centenary. Freedom fighters were horrified to see how little tribute was paid to them and how their stories of sacrifice, bravery, and patriotism remained untold. The members of the armed forces who rebelled against the Pakistani rulers in 1971 and played the most crucial role in galvanising young freedom fighters into an effective fighting force hardly received any focus. The crucial role of declaring independence played by Major Ziaur Rahman was not even remotely mentioned, as was the role of Colonel M.A.G. Osmani (the chief of the Liberation War army) and other sector commanders. The significance and central role of the government-in-exile led by Tajuddin Ahmad did not receive much attention. Once again, everything converged on one man. Freedom fighters still alive, and the family members of those killed during the war, felt insulted.

Just to cite another example of arrogance and lack of foresight, Hasina forced every government office, every semi-government institution, universities both public and private, NGOs, banks, airports, etc, to open what was called a "Mujib corner" to display photos and books—mostly substandard ones—on him. If instead she had set up "Muktijoddha corners"—which would have been most appropriate at that moment—and filled them with books on the Liberation War, our people in general, and the younger generation in particular, would have been far better informed about that glorious moment in our history. The truth is that Hasina's government was in power for 15 consecutive years and did virtually nothing to raise public awareness about our freedom struggle; she turned it into Mujib worship that only served to create a sense of disgust and alienation.

By 2022, Hasina had reached the height of arrogance. "I know everything," "Every critic is an enemy," "Whatever I do is best for Bangladesh," and similar statements dominated the political discourse. The sycophancy reached such absurd levels that her party leaders and workers started to believe that there were no problems their leader could not solve and no challenges she could not tackle. This allowed conniving party henchmen to try to outdo one another with ever cruder assertions of the leader's infallibility, creating a bubble of absurdities in which Hasina and her courtiers lived.

Hasina and her government's handling of the students' stance against the government quota system for jobs clearly showed the dysfunctionality to which her party and her government had descended. At one stage, she suddenly declared all quotas abolished, which went against constitutional guarantees for quotas for the physically and mentally challenged and ethnic minorities. So, the higher court threw it out. Thus, the demand lingered. At this stage, she could have held a dialogue with the demonstrators and resolved it. In July 2024, things turned violent, and since July 16, killings on the streets in large numbers began. The Daily Star's reporters counted bodies in government and private hospitals. By August 1, 2024, they tallied 201 dead bodies and spoke to hundreds of families who lost their loved ones. We headlined death counts every day that we could verify.

Hasina denies that she gave orders to fire lethal weapons on demonstrators—despite a plethora of proof—but then why did she not stop it once it began occurring? Each day's newspapers showed how many were killed the day before. If she is speaking the truth about not giving orders to kill, then why didn't she issue an instant order to stop the carnage? There is no way one can believe that firing on the streets would occur day after day for several weeks, and the PM would not know. She knew, and she had given the order. So, her direct involvement—and the doctrine of "command responsibility"—brings these cruel crimes to the doorstep of the PM, who ran her government with an iron hand.

Legalities aside, those who lived through those crucial days, witnessed the tragic incidents, reported on them, wrote on them, or warned and alerted the government about them, feel convinced that as the head of government, Sheikh Hasina is guilty of crimes against her own people.

Mahfuz Anam is the editor and publisher of The Daily Star.​
 
Proved why BD is a rogue nation. Replication of what Pakistan did with Bhutto. Kangaroo court can deliver capital punishment without listening to the person who happened to be their PM.
 

PKDefense Forums: Country-by-Country Military Discussions

Log In Register Forums