| Global Defense, OSINT & Geopolitics Wire

[đŸ‡§đŸ‡©] BNP Jamaat On A Collision Course

[đŸ‡§đŸ‡©] BNP Jamaat On A Collision Course
52
3K
More threads by Saif

G Bangladesh Defense

Come to parliament for talks instead of long marches: Shahe Alam

1792797753867.webp




Local Government, Rural Development and Cooperatives (LGRD) State Minister Mir Shahe Alam on Friday urged opposition parties to abandon long marches and protest programmes and join parliamentary discussions, saying five seats had been kept vacant for them on the constitutional amendment committee.

“Leave aside long marches and protest programmes and come to parliament. Five seats have been kept vacant for the opposition on the constitutional amendment committee. You can nominate five representatives at any time and play a responsible role,” he said.

The state minister made the remarks at a press briefing at the Shibganj Upazila Parishad building in Bogura around 10am.

He criticised opposition leaders for not attending the inauguration of a memorial built in memory of those killed during the July-August uprising, despite being invited, saying they had offered lame excuses for their absence.

“Those who want to engage in politics over July-August throughout the day showed their deceptive attitude by staying away from the inauguration ceremony,” he said.

Mir Shahe Alam said Prime Minister Tarique Rahman attended the inauguration of the July Memorial, built by the government at Osmani Udyan, on October 19 as the chief guest.

He said the Dhaka South City Corporation had invited the presidents and general secretaries of like-minded, allied and coalition political parties to the event.

The prime minister inaugurated the memorial and reopened Osmani Udyan after 10 years in the presence of four families of those killed during the uprising, including the fathers of Mir Mughdho, Abu Sayeed and Anas, as well as the mother of another victim, the state minister said.

He said the names of 834 officially recognised martyrs had been inscribed on the memorial, describing it as the only such memorial in Bangladesh.

Referring to the opposition's explanation that they had skipped the event because the opposition leader's name was not included on the invitation card, Mir Shahe Alam said the argument was not valid.

Had opposition leaders attended, the prime minister would have invited their representatives onto the stage, he added.

Later, the state minister attended a prize-giving ceremony for talented teachers and students at the Shibganj Upazila Parishad auditorium as the chief guest.​
 

Can old enemies unite for the sake of power
The merger of ''dictatorship'' and ''secret forces'' - Prime Minister Tarique Rahman's concern about this is a significant factor in national politics. Examining the political calculations behind this, as well as the deep observations of the post-July political tug-of-war between the BNP-Jamaat, has become a topic of public interest. Mohammad Jalal Uddin Sikder has made this analysis.

Mohammad Jalal Uddin Sikder


1794268019248.webp

Unity of the 2024 uprising depicted in graffiti Photo: Prothom Alo

In a meeting of the BNP parliamentary party on 11 October, Prime Minister Tarique Rahman stated that the ''dictatorship'' and the ''secret forces'' may soon unite (Prothom Alo, 11 October 2026). Previously, he made similar comments in Feni on 1 October and Rajshahi on 20 October (Prothom Alo, 1 and 20 October 2026).

While the term ''dictatorship'' implicitly refers to the Awami League, the exact identity of the ''secret forces'' is unclear, though indications point towards Jamaat. Jamaat-e-Islami Amir Dr Shafiqur Rahman once also said, “Of course, I was underground. I remained underground in the country; I did not go abroad.” (Bangla Tribune, 3 June 2026). Therefore, examining the Prime Minister's concern in the context of history and today's politics is necessary.

Could old enemies unite once more?

In 1971, the Awami League led the Liberation War, whereas Jamaat opposed independence. Nevertheless, at various times, they have found themselves on similar paths. Though the BNP boycotted Ershad’s elections in 1986, the Awami League and Jamaat participated. Writer and researcher Mohiuddin Ahmad also noted Jamaat as an ally of the Awami League in that election (Prothom Alo, 4 August 2024).

In 1991, BNP formed a government with Jamaat’s support. The following year, under the leadership of Shaheed Janani Jahanara Imam, a movement to bring war criminals to justice began. On 26 March 1992, a mock trial of Jamaat's Ameer Ghulam Azam was conducted at Suhrawardy Udyan. The Awami League stood beside this movement as well (BBC Bangla, 30 March, 2022).

Again, following allegations of rigging in the 1994 Magura by-elections, Awami League, Jamaat, and Jatiya Party jointly campaigned for a caretaker government. Opposition MPs resigned, and they boycotted the 15 February 1996, election. Eventually, the caretaker government system was established, and new elections were held on 12 June (BBC Bangla, 15 February 2021).

Similar suspicions arose regarding the 2008 elections. Though Khaleda Zia was hesitant, Jamaat was keen to participate (The Daily Star, 5 November 2008). Later, Khaleda Zia claimed that Jamaat’s old friendship with Awami League still existed at that time, arguing that it was due to Jamaat’s pressure that the BNP participated in those elections (Dhaka Times, 10 April 2017).

The trial for war crimes subsequently increased the rift between the Awami League and Jamaat. In 2013, following Abdul Quader Mollah's life sentence, the Shahbag protests began. At that time, suspicions about a compromise with the government arose (The Daily Star, 5 February 2013). Later, the death penalties for Quader Mollah and several high-ranking Jamaat leaders were implemented.

However, instances of unification despite political differences have been seen in other countries. In 2015, in India’s Jammu and Kashmir, BJP and the People's Democratic Party (PDP) formed a government despite major disagreements on Kashmir's special status. Ultimately, the coalition collapsed in 2018 (The Indian Express, 25 February 2015; NDTV, 19 June 2018).

Political Scientist William Riker offered an explanation for such coalitions in his book The Theory of Political Coalitions, reflecting how political alliances can be formed due to the need for power despite ideological differences.
However, forming and sustaining a coalition are different matters.

Economist Douglass North and political scientist Barry Weingast emphasised the importance of credible commitment in their research "Constitutions and Commitment". Simply put, for a compromise to last, parties must trust each other's words. In this context, considering the antagonism from 1971, the trial for war criminals, and divergent stances during the 2024 mass uprising, can trust easily return between the Awami League and Jamaat?

Can India bring the two parties closer?

The Awami League shares a longstanding relationship with India due to the Liberation War, border security, and safety issues. However, now that the Awami League is out of power, there are questions about how far India will go to bring them back into politics.

Reflecting on 2008, when a military-backed government attempted to oust Sheikh Hasina and Khaleda Zia from politics, former Indian President Pranab Mukherjee mentioned in his book The Coalition Years (2017) that when Army Chief Moeen U Ahmed visited India, he expressed concerns about his safety if Sheikh Hasina returned to power, to which Pranab assured him (India Today, 13 October 2017). This illustrates India’s attempt to reassure relevant parties during Bangladesh’s political transitions.

However, political calculations do not remain constant. Changes in internal situations bring changes in external relations. Political Scientist James Rosenau's book Linkage Politics elaborates on such relationships. In that regard, India may seek a new approach considering Bangladesh's current situation.

Prime Minister Tarique Rahman at the ground of Fulgazi Pilot High School in Feni.

Prime Minister Tarique Rahman at the ground of Fulgazi Pilot High School in Feni.Photo: Courtesy of BNP Media Cell
There have been recent reports of India's contact with Jamaat as well. Jamaat Amir Dr. Shafiqur Rahman claimed that Indian diplomats met him and requested secrecy (Reuters, 31 December 2025). India described it as a regular diplomatic interaction (The Daily Star, 17 January 2026).

So, can India attempt to facilitate an understanding between the two parties? If bringing Awami League back into politics aligns with India’s interests, and Jamaat desires assurances for its leaders and activists' safety, could any compromise be impossible? However, given the anger over the trial for war crimes, to what extent Jamaat’s leaders and activists would accept it is also a question.

Of course, present situations differ from 2008. Just India’s desire is not enough. What matters is whether there’s an opportunity within Bangladesh for the two parties to find common ground.

Did the distrust of July lead to seeking new partners?
Before 5 August 2024, the aim of BNP, Jamaat, and the student protesters was the fall of the Awami League government. But once the government was removed, new calculations began. Did former unity fracture over who will gain power, when elections will be held, and how much influence each will have?

Accusations arose that student groups associated with Jamaat increased their influence covertly in various universities while sidelining the student wing of BNP. Another slogan “The boat and the sheaf of paddy, both snakes have the same venom” also emerged. Did the BNP regard these as typical student politics or attempts to push them out? Did suspicion surround the use of the term ''secret forces''?

During the interim government, various attacks against the BNP and Tarique Rahman circulated on social media. Questions arose about the roles of people connected to the government. Later, several former advisors spoke of a ''kitchen cabinet'' or small influential group within the government (The Daily Star, 26 May 2026). Did BNP suspect that even within the government, some wanted to prevent them from gaining power?

From 5 August Tarique Rahman sought swift elections, advocating for forming a government through elections and running the country inclusively. However, delays over the election and disagreements over reform conditions continued. He accused an attempt to delay the election (BDNews24. com, 29 May 2025). Did BNP's fear of the ‘Minus Two’ formula from 2007-08, where Sheikh Hasina and Khaleda Zia were threatened to be removed from politics, return? Did they fear that Tarique Rahman, after Sheikh Hasina, might also be pushed out?

Disputes over the July Charter further intensified. Although BNP signed the Charter, they raised objections over implementation issues. Professor Ali Riaz criticized the gap between BNP’s previous commitments and later positions (Prothom Alo, 11 October 2026). His questions hold importance. But was BNP’s objection only about reform? Or did they feel compelled to adhere to decisions imposed by those they suspected intended to push them aside?

BNP also had its own 31 points for state reform. Were they opposing reforms, or had the July experience merely made them more cautious? Did resentment build regarding Jamaat’s behaviour? Conversely, did Jamaat feel their demands post-movement weren’t being met?

In politics, words alone do not convey the whole picture. Fear, resentment, distrust, and calculations of gain and loss also occur behind the scenes. If the calculations change, can old allies seek new avenues? And could the interests of Awami League and Jamaat align at any point?

Fear of conspiracy, or a political narrative?

Is conspiracy new in power politics? There were betrayals behind Nawab Sirajuddaula’s downfall. Even today, there are power struggles; adversaries will look for opportunities. Then, is Prime Minister Tarique Rahman’s concern about a merger of ‘dictatorship’ and ‘secret forces’ unusual? Or by saying this, is he aiming to keep his party members alert and unified while keeping the opposition under pressure? American researcher Robert Entman showed in his research on ‘framing’ that how an event is presented affects people’s perceptions. However, even if there is a fear of conspiracy, does it lessen the government’s responsibility?

Nonetheless, Bangladesh is not a utopia devoid of murder, discord, or tension. In such a densely populated country, deprivation, inequality, and conflict of interest will exist. Do people desire guarantees against all crimes, or do they want to see the government preventing wrongdoings, catching criminals, and ensuring justice?

If party members engage in land grabbing, extortion, or abuse of power, what will the government do then? When party affiliation becomes predominant for recruitment, transfers, government privileges, or fertilizer distribution, what was the point of so many sacrifices in July? Did families who lost their children yearn to see a return to the old system?

BNP might have political grievances, but would that impede necessary reforms from the July Charter? What about judicial independence, administrative accountability, citizens’ rights, or control over freedom of expression under the guise of cyber security—what will the government do about these? If the new government takes steps like the previous ones while denouncing them, where lies the change?

Hence, the question isn’t just about whether ''dictatorship'' and ''secret forces'' will unite. Can the Prime Minister keep his party intact? To what extent can he ensure people’s safety, justice, and governance? Ultimately, do people want to hear about conspiracies, or do they aspire to see the outcomes of changes for which they sacrificed in July?

#Mohammad Jalal Uddin Sikder is a teacher and researcher in the Department of Political Science and Sociology at North South University.​
 

Jamaat blames BNP for anti-AL front collapse

Mamunur Rashid

1795224797656.webp


Jamaat blames the BNP’s “departure from efforts to fulfil the aspirations of the July uprising” and the government’s failure to implement the July charter for the opposition’s reluctance to take to the streets against the Awami League.

During the interim government, the BNP and Jamaat largely shared a common position on preventing activities and violence by AL, whose political activities remain banned.

However, the two parties are no longer seen protesting side by side, despite recurring incidents of arson and vandalism allegedly involving AL supporters.

Such incidents have included attacks on police stations, MPs’ homes, business establishments and vehicles in different parts of the country, particularly in Gopalganj, the home district of ousted prime minister Sheikh Hasina.

“The interim government was on the side of July, while the BNP was against July. That is where the difference lies,” Jamaat Assistant Secretary General Hamidur Rahman Azad told The Daily Star.

The Jamaat leader said the BNP spoke of national unity in the spirit of the July uprising but had taken no formal initiative to implement its aspirations.

“If the BNP itself helps bring back fascism, how can we stand by the BNP? They have encouraged these people all along. They have been emboldened by the BNP.”

Azad said the main aspiration of the July uprising was state reform, and the interim government drafted the July charter to fulfil that goal. The BNP had also supported reforms and sought votes in favour of the charter at the time but moved away from that position after coming to power, he alleged.

Azad accused the BNP of encouraging the resurgence of the AL, saying that preventing a return of fascism was one of the key objectives of the 11-party alliance.

“If the BNP itself helps bring back fascism, how can we stand by the BNP? They have encouraged these people all along. They have been emboldened because of the BNP,” he said.

He said Jamaat’s priority was to protect the people, not the government. “Our responsibility is to work for the people and ensure the safety of their lives and property. That is why we have taken to the streets with programmes,” he added.

After a meeting between Prime Minister Tarique Rahman and opposition leader Shafiqur Rahman on Thursday, the Jamaat-led 11-party alliance finally announced plans to take to the streets.

Jamaat Assistant Secretary General and central publicity department chief Ehsanul Mahbub Zubair said the party would take street programmes with the people to counter AL activities and violence.

He said that the party’s central executive council had held a special meeting on the current situation, followed by discussions among leaders of the 11-party alliance.

Jamaat Ameer Shafiqur had given directions on the issue in his concluding speech at the fourth session of parliament, he said.

“We will make our position clear through street protests and programmes... ,” Zubair said.

On Thursday, Jamaat Secretary General Mia Golam Porwar announced programmes from November 21 to December 31, including four days of rallies and processions, to protest government failures to act against the AL’s activities.​