[🇧🇩] Ship Recycling Industry in Bangladesh

Quick Reply ✓ Posted!
Quick Reply ✓ Posted!
[🇧🇩] Ship Recycling Industry in Bangladesh
22
3K
More threads by Bilal9

G Bangladesh Defense

The global injustice behind Bangladesh’s shipbreaking industry

Dr Mohammad Zulfikar Ali

The shipbreaking industry needs an industry-specific civil liability framework: one that compensates workers who are killed, injured or made ill by their work, while also changing current industry practices by putting an effective civil remedy system in place. The recent deaths of workers at a shipbreaking yard owned by Ferdous Steel demonstrate how urgently such a remedy is needed in a country like Bangladesh, where compensation based on negligence is all but unknown.

The Shipbreaking Liability Certificate (SLC) scheme I propose in my book, Worker Injustices in the South Asian Shipbreaking Industry: Developing a Framework for International Legal Accountability, is designed to meet that objective. It could also be applied regionally or globally, wherever practices common in Bangladesh, India and Pakistan—beaching ships and relying heavily on manual labour—are followed. Under the SLC, a shipowner would be required to maintain shipbreaking insurance until a ship was completely demolished, covering claims by any worker who suffered a minor or serious injury, developed a work-related illness or died as a result of the work. Workers and their families should not have to go from door to door seeking compensation; compensation is their right. The scheme would supplement compensation available under labour law, which is far too low given the profits generated by the global industry.

1789255849297.webp

A worker dismantles a ship on the banks of the Karnaphuli River in Chattogram’s Bakalia area, outside the designated shipbreaking zones of Sitakunda and Mirsarai. Concerns have been raised over hazardous working conditions, environmental pollution and inadequate safeguards for workers. The photo was taken on May 7, 2023. Photo: Rajib Raihan

One of the underlying problems is that existing domestic and international legal frameworks provide no effective mechanism for addressing shipowners' financial responsibility. Because of this legal gap, every major party in the business chain—the shipping industry, cash buyers and open-registry countries—can benefit financially from the industry, while none bears adequate legal responsibility for the deaths, injuries and diseases that shipbreaking workers routinely suffer.

The theory of rectificatory justice, which seeks to address wrongs by correcting unjust losses and gains, provides an important framework for regulating the shipbreaking industry. Its emphasis on remedying injustice offers a way of thinking through how the wrongs suffered by shipbreaking workers might be put right: namely, by addressing the lack of adequate and prompt compensation for those who suffer work-related deaths, injuries and diseases. Since it is unrealistic to expect casualties in the yards to be eliminated altogether in the near future, an SLC built on the principles of rectificatory justice would at least introduce an effective system of remedy and deliver some measure of justice to workers and their families.

Seen through the lens of rectificatory justice, one of the most relevant factors is the profit earned by the dominant actors in the shipbreaking industry, particularly those in the global maritime business. Those profits highlight an underlying injustice: the economic benefits generated by the industry are not matched by adequate recognition of, or responsibility for, the harms suffered by workers. This is where postcolonial theory becomes relevant, as it raises the question of whether the existing legal order has granted significant power and economic advantage without corresponding responsibility to dominant entities based largely in developed nations.

Postcolonial theory is relevant to shipbreaking law for two main reasons. First, these laws were adopted long after the formal end of colonialism. Yet they can still serve the interests of international shipowners based predominantly in developed nations, paying greater attention to facilitating maritime commerce than to the working conditions and human consequences in shipbreaking yards. Second, in practical terms, the existing legal frameworks do not adequately acknowledge that developing countries often have limited financial, institutional and technical resources with which to raise standards across their shipbreaking industries.

Postcolonial analysis also draws attention to the proposition that global institutions and regulatory structures can be biased in favour of developed nations. That imbalance can be seen in the design of the Hong Kong International Convention for the Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships (Hong Kong Convention). Although it is the principal international instrument specifically governing ship recycling, the Convention permits a business model under which companies from major shipping countries can sell end-of-life ships containing hazardous materials to ship-recycling companies in South Asia, subject to the Convention's regulatory requirements. Yet it does not impose direct financial liability on those shipowners for compensating workers who suffer work-related deaths, injuries and diseases in the yards, nor does it create the comprehensive liability regime necessary to ensure that the costs associated with those harms follow the commercial actors that benefited from the vessels.

The global injustice argument, grounded in postcolonial theory, therefore provides a distinctive basis for legal reform. Shipbreaking is an integral and profitable component of the global maritime industry. Yet the existing international framework imposes no comprehensive civil liability on international shipowners for work-related deaths, injuries and diseases suffered by shipbreaking workers, or for the wider environmental damage associated with the industry. This provides the basis for arguing for a new liability framework. Applying a rectificatory global justice approach, the proposed SLC would establish a civil liability mechanism that makes shipowners financially responsible for specified harms and requires adequate compensation to be available to affected workers and their families.

Before such a framework can be established, however, it is important to examine human rights abuses in the industry through the lenses of global injustice and postcolonial theory, while asking more directly whether shipowners should bear financial and legal responsibility for the harms associated with the end-of-life disposal of their vessels. Drawing on several international reports and case studies from the EU, international oil transport and the wider shipping industry, my research argues that a global regulatory framework would represent an important step forward. Its effectiveness would depend on its capacity to require every relevant party involved in the shipbreaking chain to assume an appropriate share of responsibility for deaths, injuries and work-related diseases suffered by workers in South Asian yards.

1789255905619.webp

In Bangladesh, end-of-life ships are dismantled using the beaching method, in which vessels are driven onto tidal shores and broken apart largely through manual labour, often without the infrastructure and safeguards found in purpose-built recycling facilities. Photo: Rajib Raihan

Raising standards, however, must not make shipbreaking in South Asia commercially uncompetitive. If South Asian countries improve their environmental and workplace standards, costs will inevitably rise, and shipowners may consequently stop selling their vessels to yards in the region. Competition from newly established yards elsewhere, operating at lower costs and under weaker standards, could then pull the industry away from South Asia altogether.

Against this background, the central challenge for the South Asian shipbreaking industry is to reconcile the high prices paid to shipowners with better labour and environmental practices. The region has retained its global competitiveness partly by offering shipowners high prices for end-of-life vessels, and yards are able to sustain those prices in part by minimising expenditure on labour, occupational health and safety, and environmental protection—at considerable cost to workers and the environment. One estimate suggests that South Asian shipbreaking companies spend 82 per cent of their total shipbreaking costs on purchasing the ship, leaving very little for maintaining adequate environmental and workplace safety standards. This business model contributes to a ‘race to the bottom’ in the shipbreaking industry. The industry remains heavily dependent on cheap but unsafe practices—beaching, importing ships without adequate pre-cleaning and dismantling vessels largely through manual labour—to maintain the high purchase prices offered to shipowners.

This business model contributes to recurring deaths, injuries and work-related diseases among workers, as well as pollution with long-term consequences for coastal and estuarine communities. Yet affected workers often lack the legal means and financial resources necessary to pursue adequate compensation, while environmental harms are similarly difficult to remedy through existing mechanisms. Many shipbreaking workers lack formal employment contracts, identity cards or effective registration. This context prompted the first major question of my research:

What legal and liability framework is required to make the international maritime industry accountable for harms to human life and health—including workers’ deaths, physical injuries and work-related diseases—in shipbreaking countries?

An examination of national and international legal frameworks reveals a persistent failure to balance the substantial economic benefits enjoyed by the global shipping industry against the human costs borne by workers in the shipbreaking industry.

An examination of national and international legal frameworks reveals a persistent failure to balance the substantial economic benefits enjoyed by the global shipping industry against the human costs borne by workers in the shipbreaking industry.

The regulatory frameworks adopted by India, Bangladesh and Pakistan are strongly influenced by each country’s demand for steel recovered from dismantled ships and by the local employment the industry generates. These economic needs create powerful incentives for each country to retain a significant share of the global shipbreaking market. The three countries may therefore be reluctant to impose stronger regulatory requirements for fear of losing business to competitors elsewhere. Such policies may help retain the industry, but they are insufficient to create safe workplaces or ensure adequate compensation for workers who suffer work-related deaths, injuries and diseases.

International regulatory frameworks present an even broader set of problems. Many global industries operate with both preventive regulation and mechanisms for liability and compensation. The international legal framework governing shipbreaking, by contrast, focuses primarily on prevention, while providing no dedicated international compensation scheme for workers who are killed, injured or made ill in shipbreaking yards. In practice, the preventive framework has also struggled to deliver adequate occupational health and safety protections across South Asian yards.


1789255970048.webp

Vessels are dismantled near the Bangladesh-China Friendship Bridge-1 in Dhaka’s Postagola, despite designated shipbreaking yards in the city. Such unauthorised dismantling raises concerns over environmental pollution and inadequate regulatory oversight. The photo was taken in 2023. Photo: Anisur Rahman

These weaknesses in the existing legal framework amount to a form of global injustice for two further reasons. First, the Hong Kong Convention places primary responsibility on ship-recycling states to ensure that facilities operating within their jurisdictions meet occupational health, safety and environmental requirements. Yet developing countries may lack the financial, technical and institutional resources needed to implement these standards effectively. As other authors have argued, this allocation of responsibility can leave developing countries bearing much of the cost of workplace safety and worker protection, while international shipowners continue to benefit from the comparatively low cost of recycling their vessels in South Asia. The result is an unequal distribution of benefits and burdens between the global shipping industry and developing shipbreaking countries, their environments and their workers. Second, although shipbreaking imposes substantial human costs on workers in developing countries, the Convention does not establish a dedicated civil liability and compensation regime for work-related injuries, deaths or diseases.

A critical examination of the existing regulatory options, therefore, reinforces the need for a more equitable balance between the benefits that the South Asian shipbreaking industry provides to the global maritime industry and the losses borne by workers further down the business chain. That balance is what the proposed SLC is designed to achieve, while also changing industry practices. The central claim is that the industry requires a global civil liability mechanism not only to compensate shipbreaking workers who suffer work-related deaths, injuries or diseases, but also to reshape industry practices by strengthening accountability throughout the transfer of ownership and responsibility for every ship, from cradle to grave. Such a mechanism would distribute responsibility among relevant parties across the business chain while seeking to preserve the industry's commercial viability.

Dr Mohammad Zulfikar Ali is a lecturer at Curtin Law School, Curtin University, Perth, Western Australia.​
 

Concessions for shipbreaking put environment and workers at risk

Mostafa Yousuf


1792885777887.webp

Shipbreaking Jewel Shill

The shipbreaking industry is considered one of the most polluting industries for the environment. Therefore, businesses must obtain approval at several stages, including conducting an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), before setting up a yard.

However, the government has decided to downgrade the industry from the red category to the orange category, meeting a long-standing demand from shipbreaking yard owners. This decision could remove the requirement to conduct an EIA before establishing a yard.

Entrepreneurs in the shipbreaking industry say that, because the industry falls under the red category, it takes around 90 days to obtain approval to set up a yard. They claim that this delay causes them financial losses.

Environmentalists, however, fear that the government’s decision will put both workers and the environment at risk. They say shipbreaking is a high-risk and highly polluting industry.

The International Labour Organization (ILO) has described it as one of the most dangerous industries. Marine ecosystems, soil and air along the coastlines of Chattogram and other South Asian areas where shipbreaking takes place are suffering severe pollution.

According to sources, the committee responsible for the matter decided on 29 September to reclassify the industry from the red category to the orange category.

The Prime Minister’s Office formed the committee in August to review existing laws, regulations, policies and related matters concerning the ship recycling industry.

Environment, Forest and Climate Change Minister Abdul Awal Mintoo chairs the committee. The industry minister, the state minister for shipping, the Cabinet Secretary, the Finance Division Secretary, and the Law and Parliamentary Affairs Secretary are its members. However, the committee includes no representatives from environmental organisations or environmental experts.

Asked about the decision, Environment Minister Abdul Awal Mintoo told Prothom Alo, “We have 15 to 20 green yards under the Hong Kong Convention.”

According to business owners, they have invested around Tk 1.5 billion (150 crore) in each yard. As the shipbreaking industry falls under the red category, they have to wait three months to obtain permission to establish a yard. This delay is causing financial losses for businesses.

Asked whether the government’s decision would increase the risk of environmental pollution, he said, “We must protect both the environment and the industry.”

Under the Environment Conservation Rules 2023, both shipbreaking activities and shipbreaking yards fall under the red category. The rules state that factories or establishments in the red category have severe impacts on the environment and human health. Significant measures are therefore necessary to address these impacts.

What do the existing rules say and what is set to change?
Under the existing rules, anyone seeking to establish a shipbreaking yard must first conduct an environmental impact assessment (EIA). The requirement also applies to the shipbreaking industries of India and Pakistan.

Currently, a yard must submit detailed terms of reference (ToR), outlining the measures it will take to prevent pollution, to the Department of Environment’s headquarters and obtain approval before beginning the EIA process.

As part of the process, a representative of the Department of Environment leads a public consultation in the relevant area. The representative then sends a report containing the feedback received to the department’s district office. The department’s headquarters reviews the report once again before issuing a site clearance certificate for the proposed yard.

The next step is obtaining an environmental clearance certificate. The department issues this certificate after inspecting the measures taken by the yard to prevent pollution from harming the environment and human health. The entire process takes 90 days.

If the government reclassifies the shipbreaking industry under the orange category, these requirements will no longer apply in the same way. Under the Environment Conservation Rules 2023, industries in the orange category must submit an initial environmental examination report to the divisional office of the Department of Environment.

If the divisional office considers an EIA necessary, it may recommend one. However, the yard will not be obliged to follow that recommendation. Applicants will no longer need to approach the department’s headquarters for final approval to establish a yard; the divisional office will issue the approval.

Several officials at the Department of Environment told Prothom Alo on condition of anonymity that the changes to the rules would prevent the authorities from assessing how much pollution a yard might cause and the extent of its environmental impact. They warned that the monitoring system for the industry would become weaker.

Abdun Naser Khan, secretary of the Ministry of Industries, told Prothom Alo, “This is a highly promising industry. By 2030, around 6,500 ships worldwide will be ready for scrapping. If we can increase the number of green yards, we will secure a substantial share of the shipbreaking business.”

According to sources at the Department of Environment, shipbreaking yards in Sitakunda, Chattogram, currently dismantle 150 to 200 ships every year. It takes six months to dismantle a single ship. Between 30,000 and 35,000 workers are employed at these yards.

Environmental experts say that shipbreaking must comply with the Basel Convention, under which each party must take responsibility for its own waste. If ships carrying waste from developed countries arrive in Bangladesh, the developed countries must remain responsible for that waste.

They argue that dry docks — specialised facilities designed for ship repair and dismantling — are the only viable option for shipbreaking in Bangladesh.

The industry cannot become environmentally friendly simply by laying concrete on open sea beaches. They stress that strict compliance with all relevant national and international laws are essential to make the industry safe.

Syeda Rizwana Hasan, chief executive of the Bangladesh Environmental Lawyers Association (BELA), told Prothom Alo that relaxing the rules contradicted ongoing litigation concerning shipbreaking pollution, as well as court judgments and orders. She added that the government had not informed the court before making the decision.

“Ten workers died from gas emissions as recently as August. This kind of decision will put workers’ lives at even greater risk,” she said.

Rizwana Hasan added, “During the fascist regime, we saw industries being permitted to set up inside the Ecologically Critical Area of the Sundarbans with a single stroke of the pen. It is unacceptable for the elected government to make decisions in this manner.”

She questioned why the government had not invited any environmental experts or activists before making such a major decision on shipbreaking, when it had consulted environmentalists while making decisions concerning Saint Martin’s Island.​
 

Bangladesh to withdraw from global treaty on shipbreaking waste management
The government has decided to move away from the Basel Convention and adhere to the Hong Kong Convention in the case of shipbreaking.
1794785847038.webp

This photograph taken on 18 February 2025 shows a worker standing at a shipbreaking yard in Bangladesh's southern port city of Chittagong.AFP​
 

PKDefense Forums: Country-by-Country Military Discussions

Log In Register Forums
Back