Reply

Explore Power, Politics, and the Art of War: Unraveling Power Plays and Political Warfare

G Bangladesh Defense Forum

Saif

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2024
Messages
6,401
Reaction score
2,407
Origin

Residence

Axis Group

Plunged into darkness
Hundreds lost vision partially or completely

1724023454513.png


"Help me! I cannot see anything …!" Al Amin Howlader cried moments before he lost consciousness and fell to the ground as police opened fire on quota reform protesters indiscriminately.

The seventh grader of a school in Barishal was rushed to a local health facility and then transferred to Dhaka, where the hospitals received hundreds of patients like him – blinded completely or partially by pellet wounds during the weeks of protests from mid-July to early August.

The National Institute of Ophthalmology and Hospital (NIOH) alone treated more than 700 patients who were shot in their eyes during the protests, according to its Director Professor Golam Mostafa.

Of them, 366 lost vision in one eye, and 17 in both.

Al Amin from Barishal said like the days before, the student of Hatem Ali Boys and Girls High School in the southern city joined his peers and seniors in the protests on Nathullabad Road on July 17, with unforeseeable peril awaiting him that afternoon.

"I had gone to support my seniors and fellows who were being attacked indiscriminately. However, I never expected them [police] to fire bullets and pellets at us," said the 14-year-old.

At least 22 pellets entered different parts of the schoolboy's body that day, including one into his right eye. Following the incident, he was rushed to Sher-e-Bangla Medical College Hospital in the city.

More shocks were waiting for the family there. Doctors asked them to take him home despite multiple pellets still inside his body, including in the eye, as the authorities ordered the removal of all patients injured in the protests by that night, said Al Amin's mother Sharmin Jahan.

With whatever cash she could manage, she left home with her wounded son the next day and visited multiple health facilities for treatment.

"The hospitals were flooded with patients, which caused delays. After several tests and a thorough examination at Grameen GC Eye Hospital, they recommended immediate surgery and referred him [Al Amin] to Ispahani Islamia Eye Hospital in Dhaka," Sharmin said.

Like Al Amin, around 1,300 others were admitted to the hospitals in Dhaka, including the NIOH, Lions Eye Institute, Bangladesh Eye Hospital, and Dhaka Medical College Hospital's eye department, according to Dr Syeed Mehbub Ul Kadir of Bangladesh Eye Hospital.

Of them, 630 underwent surgeries -- more than 90 percent of whom have lost vision in one or both eyes, he added.

Most were admitted with pellet wounds causing retinal haemorrhage that led to loss of vision, said Dr Kadir.

In just 10 days from July 17, as many as 445 patients were rushed to the NIOH's emergency care. At least 305 of them had surgery.

Another 261 patients were brought between August 4 and 10, and 181 of them underwent surgery, the hospital said in a bulletin on August 11.

The patients have either become visually impaired or are at risk of losing sight. Their rehabilitation is important and urgent, added the bulletin.

Similar cases were reported from around the country, although a concrete figure is not available yet.

In Al Amin's case, the pellet had penetrated his retina, said his doctor vitreo-retinal surgeon Dr Farhana Yasmin of Ispahani Islamia Eye Institute and Hospital.

The boy had the surgery on August 13. However, the doctors could not get the pellet out as it was deeply stuck in his optic nerve, making it nearly impossible for surgeons to remove it.

The pellet would not further harm Al Amin's eye, but the incident has led to a loss of vision in the injured eye, Dr Farhana said. "He would require follow-ups, and perhaps, another surgery," she said.

The doctor attended to at least five similar patients in the past two days.

"My friends have returned to school while all I do these days is sit indoors or lie on the bed," said Al Amin, currently at home after being discharged on August 14.

"I don't know how long it will take for me to return to my old life – enjoying chase with my school friends in the playfield."

Restaurant worker Kazi Faruk, however, still lies in his bed at the NIOH, wearing sunglasses.

An unseeable barrier now stands between him and a world he can no longer see after losing vision in both eyes.

Once filled with hope, Faruk's life took a tragic turn on August 5, the day Dhaka's streets erupted in celebration following Sheikh Hasina's fall and departure from the country.

It began as a regular day in his small room at his mess in Merul Badda. The Capital, the restaurant where he had worked for the past four years, was closed due to the unrest and curfew.

When the news of Hasina's exit spread, Faruk, like lakhs of others, joined the jubilant crowds.

As an active protester who had been demonstrating with Brac University students since July 16, he joined them on this day of victory as well.

As the protesters neared Badda Police Station, the celebration turned into horror.

Without any warning, police opened fire, and in the ensuing chaos, Faruk was struck by shotgun pellets, including in his eyes.

He was rushed to the NIOH immediately, but the irreparable damage was already done.

"We're still trying to regain his vision," said the hospital's Director Prof Mostafa.

"It's tragic for me to be shot on the day of celebration after our successful mission. The doctors are trying their best. I would be happy if I could regain vision in at least one eye," Faruk said, his voice tinged with sadness.

While the hospital is providing necessary care, Faruk's worries go beyond his immediate treatment.

"The hospital is giving me the supplies I need, but I have to buy the medicines that aren't available here. People are checking on me now, but I fear that if they stop, I'll be left alone," he added.

Faruk's family is also grappling with the uncertainty hanging over his future. Having lost his parents long ago, Faruk had faced many challenges in life, but nothing as devastating as this.​
 

Army pledges support to injured students: ISPR

1724024203953.png


The Bangladesh Army has taken steps to provide urgent and advanced medical care to students injured in the anti-discrimination movement led by students.

In a press release issued today (18 August), the Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR) Directorate requested that the students who need emergency treatment contact the following numbers: 01769051652, 01769051653, 01769051654, 1769051657 and 01769051658.

The army wishes for a swift recovery of the students injured in the movement, reads the release.

Bangladesh Army is committed to providing the highest level of support to the affected students by ensuring the necessary emergency medical care that they need, it added.​
 

Shot six times, Amir lives to tell his tale
Man seen hanging from ledge of Rampura building while being shot by police in viral video miraculously escapes death


1724108745299.png

Photo: Collected

After broadband internet was restored in selected areas on July 23, a video began circulating on social media showing a boy hanging from the ledge of an under-construction building.

Two cops are then seen arriving at the scene and several rounds of gunshots are heard. The video shows police pointing their guns at the boy, who is desperately hanging on his fingertips for his life.

The footage led many to believe that the person in the video had been killed on the spot.

This correspondent spoke to eyewitnesses and verified the authenticity of the video through geolocation tracking on July 24.

It was confirmed that the footage was taken from a building near Meradia Bazar in Rampura.

Visiting the under-construction building, this correspondent saw bloodstains on the third and fourth floors.

However, without tracing the body, The Daily Star could not confirm the death.

Recently, The Daily Star got information that Amir, the subject in the video who everyone believed to be dead, is alive.

He is now recovering at his Dhaka residence in a slum in Noapara, Meradia.

Speaking with The Daily Star yesterday, Amir told us how he survived.

After attending Friday prayers, he was on his way home when BGB and police opened fire on protesters. Fearing for his life, he ran and took refuge on the fourth floor of the under-construction building.

He said at one stage of the clash, many cops entered the building. In fear, Amir tried to hide by hanging from a ledge on the fourth floor.

After a while, two policemen found him hiding there.

The officers allegedly threatened him and said, "Jump from the building, or we will shoot you."

While he was hanging on for his life, a police officer from the third floor fired six shots, all of them hitting him, three on each leg.

Despite bleeding heavily from his injuries, Amir clung to the rod until the police left.

He then collapsed onto the third floor.

"I tried to get up but had no strength. I shouted, but sounds of gunfire muffled my pleas for help," Amir recounted referring to the clash that was going on nearby.

"At one point, I almost gave up hope. I thought I would die. My vision was blurred, but a part of me didn't want to give up. I kept thinking, 'I can't die like this'. Thoughts of my elderly father and my sister, whose marriage I had been saving money for, kept me going. This wasn't how I would die," he added.

Nearly three hours later, after the clash subsided, a student rushed into the building and found Amir lying in a pool of blood.

Two doctors from a nearby hospital, who were in the area, quickly joined the rescue. They worked desperately to stop the bleeding.

"They kept telling me, 'Don't close your eyes. We won't let you die. Please, don't close your eyes'," Amir recalled.

They took him to Famous Hospital, where he received initial treatment that night, before being referred to Dhaka Medical College and Hospital.

Amir experienced so much blood loss that he required three bags of blood at the hospital. After three days, he was discharged from DMCH.

"He needed further treatment, but DMCH was flooded with people who had life-threatening injuries. Since Amir's condition was stable, doctors prescribed him medication for three months and sent him home," said Nasima Begum, Amir's aunt.

"After the video went viral, we heard police were searching for us. There were stories of raids where police were picking up people with bullet injuries, so we stayed quiet. Journalists were looking for him, but we only could speak out after hearing about Sheikh Hasina's fall on August 5," she added.

Amir showed this correspondent all of the bullet wounds he had to mark the horrific day.

In his right leg, a bullet struck the sole of his foot and pierced through his ankle, another hit his shin and exited through his calf, and a third struck his thigh, passing through his hip.

In his left leg, one bullet struck just below his knee and exited the other side, another hit the top of his thigh and exited through the opposite end. The last one was lodged below his thigh and exited through the other side.

We took photos of his medical reports, including the X-rays, and consulted physicians from Famous Hospital and Farazy Hospital, where Amir had a follow-up after being discharged from DMCH.

At Famous Hospital, doctors confirmed that Amir would have likely died from excessive bleeding if he had been brought in just 5-10 minutes later. Both hospitals noted that Amir's speedy recovery was due to the fact that none of the six bullets struck his bones; if they had, it might have been fatal.

However, Amir still can't stand on his own and needs assistance to use the washroom. The doctors noted that he lost a significant amount of blood and it would take time for him to fully recover.​
 
ঝুলে থাকা সেই গুলিবিদ্ধ তরুণ জানালো সেদিনের ভয়াবহ অভিজ্ঞতা, কেন গুলি করেছিল পুলিশ?


 

We are not doing enough for the injured
Those maimed in July-August need more than free treatment

1726704334043.png

VISUAL: STAR

The price that citizens had to pay to oust Sheikh Hasina's autocratic regime, not just in terms of the lives lost but also the sheer number of injuries, is stupefying. According to a recent report, more than 500 people, mostly in their prime age, have been fully or partially blinded by pellets of shotguns that law enforcers used on protesters during the July-August uprising. Despite repeated surgeries, many of the injured reportedly have no hope of regaining their eyesight. In some cases, the pellets penetrated so deep that removing those would require the removal of the eye altogether.

All this has meant extended hospital stays for many victims, taking a toll not just on their mental health but also on the financial and emotional state of their families. We appreciate the interim government's announcement yesterday to provide cash assistance to families of the victims, including the injured within a week. While hospital fee waivers have been helpful, patients need money to buy certain medicine and have tests done in private clinics. Plus, lengthy hospital stay means rising costs of food and accommodation for the attendants, especially those travelling from different districts.

Many of the wounded come from impoverished backgrounds. For them to bear treatment and attendance related expenses over a long period is not just difficult; it is literally putting them into debt. We have written about this issue before, and urge the government to prioritise and expedite the cash disbursement, if necessary, in phases.

The government should also start putting in motion its rehabilitation plans for the injured, who will need assistance to rebuild their lives. An overall change is also required to integrate these individuals back into a society where persons with disabilities are often looked down upon and have little infrastructural support. Also, laws related to the use of less-lethal weapons such as pellet shotguns in policing must be reviewed, keeping in mind an Amnesty International finding that these so-called less-lethal weapons injure not only protesters but also bystanders causing permanent impairment, which explains the high number of wounded in the July-August uprising.​
 

Chinese doctors visit injured protesters
Staff Correspondent 23 September, 2024, 23:53

1727139086063.png


The members of the Chinese National Emergency Medical Team on Monday visited the patients who suffered severe injuries during the student-led mass uprising and assured them of better treatment if needed even in China.

The team, comprising 10 medical experts from West China Hospital, one of China’s premier healthcare institutions, visited the injured patients at the National Institute of Ophthalmology and Hospital and the National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopaedic Rehabilitation in the morning.

Li Shaopeng, cultural counselor of the China embassy to Bangladesh, told reporters at NIO that the team of doctors observed the types of causalities and improvement of the patients admitted to the hospital.

Directorate General of Health Services director Abu Hussain Md Moinul Ahsan said that the doctors observed patients and the hospital facilities. They would provide healthcare if possible here, otherwise, take the injured to China for better treatment.

NIO officials said that a total of 42 injured patients were undergoing treatment in the hospital who sustained severe eye injuries during the student protest.

Moinul said that Chinese doctors in first phase would provide healthcare to 20 patients and gradually to others who need it.

The medical team also will visit the patients admitted to Dhaka Medical College Hospital and the National Burn and Plastic Surgery Institute today.

On Sunday, the team of physicians arrived in Dhaka to provide advanced medical care to the victims.

Chinese Ambassador to Bangladesh Yao Wen, among others, welcome the doctors and said that the Chinese government has decided to send the National Emergency Medical Team to Bangladesh in response to the invitation of the interim government led by Professor Muhammad Yunus.​
 

Treatment for injured: Negligence and delays not acceptable
Editorial Desk
Published: 24 Sep 2024, 12: 22

The state has a moral duty and responsibility to rehabilitate the families of those who lost their lives in the recent anti-autocracy uprising and to provide medical care for the injured. When the coordinators of the anti-discrimination student movement made this announcement, the affected families felt some relief.

The Students against Discrimination movement has declared the deceased individuals to be national heroes. They did not participate in the movement for personal gain. They fought for the liberation of democracy. It is important to note that a significant number of the deceased and injured individuals come from poor families. In many cases, the sole earner has either died or been severely injured, leaving the future of these families uncertain. Under these circumstances, it is impossible for the families to cover the medical expenses for the injured.

According to reports of Prothom Alo, over 21,800 individuals were injured during the uprising, with 525 suffering severe injuries or at risk of losing limbs. While some have received medical care and returned home, more than three hundred have been undergoing treatment at the hospitals.

Prothom Alo's special correspondent visited several hospitals and found that the injured did not have to pay for their medical expenses out of their own pocket. The costs are being covered by the government. However, there are concerns among the patients about their family members’ expenses and how to manage their households once they return home.

The government has announced compensation of Tk 500,000 for the families of those who died during the July-August uprising and Tk 100,000 for the medical treatment of the injured. Many consider this amount insufficient, especially for those severely injured who have lost eyes, limbs, or have undergone multiple surgeries. In such cases, providing Tk 100,000 per severely injured individual is far below what is necessary.

More reports of Prothom Alo said that on 19 September twelve injured individuals gathered at Gate No 1 of the secretariat to demand proper medical treatment from the government. On 21 September, 50 to 60 individuals gathered at the official residence of chief advisor Muhammad Yunus, with a five-member team meeting him. It is hoped that the government will arrange medical care not only for those who managed to reach the chief advisor's residence but for all who are in need.

Good news is that a ten-member team of specialist physicians has arrived in Dhaka to provide medical care for the injured. This team will assess the condition of patients at several hospitals, including the National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopaedic Rehabilitation (NITOR). There is also a possibility of a larger team of specialists coming from China in the future. Additionally, efforts are being made to bring in a specialised team to treat eye injuries through the initiative of a service foundation from the United States.

These initiatives by the government are laudable. However, it is crucial that medical care for the severely injured is provided promptly to prevent further complications. We expect the government to take all necessary measures for the advanced treatment of every injured patient from the uprising. If necessary, individuals should be sent abroad for treatment. Any negligence or delays in providing medical care to the injured is unacceptable.​
 

Treatment for injured: Govt forms advisory committee
1728520723591.png


The interim government yesterday formed a three-member advisory committee to oversee and ensure medical services for individuals injured during the anti-discrimination student movement.

According to a gazette notification signed by Cabinet Secretary Mahbub Hossain, Health Adviser Nurjahan Begum is the convener of the committee. Information Adviser Nahid Islam and Youth and Sports Adviser Asif Mahmud Sajib Bhuiyan are the members.​
 

We shouldn't use July-August victims for our own political interests: Nahid
BSS
Updated: 13 Oct 2024, 23: 06

1728867774233.png


Posts, telecommunications and information technology adviser Md Nahid Islam handed over the cheques of the financial assistances from the foundation to the wounded persons at the Dhaka Medical College Hospital (DMCH)BSS

July Shaheed Smriti Foundation today distributed financial assistances among the persons who were injured during the students-people mass uprising.

Posts, telecommunications and information technology adviser Md Nahid Islam handed over the cheques of the financial assistances from the foundation to the wounded persons at the Dhaka Medical College Hospital (DMCH), said a ministry press release.

Nahid Islam, also the adviser of the ministry of information and broadcasting, said financial assistances are being given to the victims of the movement from the July Shaheed Smriti Foundation and it is ongoing.

About the treatment of the injured in abroad, he said that necessary measures will be taken as per the advice of the concerned doctors. He also said that they will bear the expenses for those who have received treatment in different places before coming to the DMCH.

Replying to a query regarding the case filed against the journalists, the adviser, however, said that those who were directly associated with the fascist government, as well as worked as instigators and supported the genocide will be brought under trial.

"Apart from this, a committee has been formed under the ministry of information and broadcasting to look into the matter if any case is filed against someone unfairly," he said.

He added, "If any journalist or his/her family feel that they are suffering due to the case, they can contact with us, we will help them."

On the cases of injured and victims, the adviser said a legal team is working in this regard, adding, "We will hold trial in the Special Tribunal".

Mentioning the martyred and injured during the mass-uprising as the heroes of the country, he said, "Let’s (we) recognize their sacrifice . . . we're requesting that we don't divide the martyrs and the wounded persons into any party or banner. We shouldn't use them for our own political interests."

During his visit at the DMCH, injured Jamal Hussain requested the adviser to arrange monthly allowance for the elderly persons and employment for the youths.

Answering to a query about the cases are being filed against the agitators in different places, youth and sports adviser Asif Mahmud Shojib Bhuyain said that the ministry of home affairs will soon taken necessary measures to this regard. Any police personnel, involved in killing of agitators, wouldn't be spared, he added.

Both the advisers inquired about the current condition of the injured persons who are taking treatment in the hospital and assured them of giving their support.

July Shaheed Smriti Foundation secretary Mir Mahbubur Rahman Snigdha presented to the journalists the details of the financial assistances given to the injured from the Foundation.

Today, a total of Taka 1,22,64,400 has been distributed to 122 persons. Among them, 23 out of 30 people, receiving treatment at DMCH, have been given a cheque of Taka 100,000 each, while remaining seven persons have been given the money through bKash wallet due to incompletion of their names.

Besides, cash assistance has also been sent to the bKash wallet of 33 people receiving treatment at the National Institute of Ophthalmology, while 59 people at the National Orthopeadic Hospital and Rehabilitation Institute.

So far, a total of Take 1,71,42,050 has been given to 176 injured people from the July Shaheed Smriti Foundation.​
 

Treatment of protesters' injured eyes
Published :
Oct 14, 2024 21:59
Updated :
Oct 14, 2024 21:59

1728953303665.png


Although the number of deaths during the quota-reform movement is yet to be finalised, it has been put at around 800 so far. The number of the injured is many times more. Some of those receiving treatment in hospitals are dying now. This is because not all of them have sustained the same degree of injuries. Many of them may survive the bullet wounds but are fated to get maimed for life. Their legs or hands had to be amputated to save their lives. The interim government has announced that it would take the responsibility of the cost of their medical treatment. Then why the newspapers have to carry reports of helplessness facing families of those injured during the movement for the latter's medical care is really incomprehensible. It appears that a comprehensive plan and coordination are lacking in this regard despite the fact that monetary support is being extended from the Shahid Smriti Foundation to both martyred and injured.

However, the protesters who sustained injuries to their eyes have received better attention courtesy of China. A 10-member team of eye specialists from China arrived in Bangladesh on September 22. They visited the National Ophthalmology Institute and Hospital the next day to check with all 42 protesters with eye injury admitted there. A highly positive development is that an arrangement was made for all protesters injured in the eyes to see both local and Chinese eye specialists between October 5 and October 7. Before this, the Chinese eye consultants duly checked with the types of eye injury, the treatment the patients had received and the progress of their recovery, if any. They have made it clear that those among the injured requiring particularly specialised treatment would be taken abroad for the required medical care.

This is more than just a gesture of goodwill. It is not clear if the patients will be taken to China or any other country for better treatment. Neither is it reported if China wants to treat the patients free of cost. A Google search reveals that China does not rank among the six nations at the forefront of ophthalmology. But its system should be more advanced than that of Bangladesh. Whatever may be the case, the prompt response to this health crisis here from the Chinese eye specialists comes out of a sense of humanitarian emergency not many nations have been very particular about.

Let the protesters facing the threat of losing their eyesight be given the best of care available in the world. If China can accomplish the job, the victims of police firing and members of their families will ever remain grateful to that country. It will prove the old adage 'a friend in need is a friend indeed'. But in case, restoring eyesight calls for still more sophisticated and advanced eye care, the best option is the United States of America, frontrunner in eye care. Next come Germany, South Korea and India, Thailand and Japan in order. Options for treatment in those countries can as well be explored. After all it is a humanitarian cause and no country should prioritise its commercial interests over the service to the humanity. Here is a special issue of courage, dedication and sacrifice that prompted the young protesters to fight for a just cause and they deserve national and international support and help for getting their eyesight back.​
 

Govt to stand by those injured in mass uprising: health adviser

1729466813257.png

Photo: Collected

Health Adviser Nurjahan Begum today said the government will stand by the injured in the anti-discrimination student movement to ensure their treatment and rehabilitation.

The adviser said this while addressing a press briefing after the cornea transplant surgery of Israfil and Anik, two injured in the anti-discrimination student movement at the National Institute of Ophthalmology and Hospital.

During the visit, Nurjahan inquired about the treatment of the injured at the eye hospital and visited different wards.

She also talked with the families of Israfil and Anik.

Highly sensitive corneal tissue was brought to Bangladesh by the Sheba Foundation from the US, and Nepal for cornea transplantation in the eyes of two patients injured in the anti-discrimination student movement.

Earlier, the Sheba Foundation assured to provide 40 corneas. In continuation of this, for the first time, the cornea of the eyes of two people injured in the movement was transplanted.

The health adviser said, "We have to try to treat the injured in the anti-discrimination movement and lift them from the trauma they are going through.

"The director of the National Institute of Ophthalmology and Hospital Prof Dr Khair Ahmed Chowdhury, and other doctors of the hospital were present, among others.​
 

Thai medical team arrives in Dhaka to treat injured victims of July uprising
FE ONLINE REPORT
Published :
Oct 30, 2024 20:23
Updated :
Oct 30, 2024 20:34

1730340951903.png


A medical team from Thailand arrived in Dhaka on Wednesday to provide treatment to individuals injured during the July uprising. The visit comes weeks after a Chinese medical team assisted severely injured patients in major government hospitals. Many of those injured in July are still receiving care at various hospitals.

Earlier, Vejthani Hospital of Bangkok expressed interest in providing free medical consultations to the seriously injured patients. In line with this, a team of six, including three doctors from the hospital, visited patients at the National Orthopedic Hospital and Rehabilitation Institute (NITOR) and the National Institute of Neurosciences and Hospital (NINS) in Dhaka.

Dr Kazi Shamim Uzzaman, Director of NITOR, said that the Thai medical team examined all 57 patients admitted there, focusing on 15 individuals with severe nerve and joint injuries.

The team's plan for nerve injury patients involves a wait-and-observe approach with regular check-ups and further surgery to be determined based on subsequent evaluations. For the remaining patients, the Thai team concurred with the ongoing treatment protocol.

At NINS, joint director Dr Md Badrul Alam said that the team examined seven seriously injured patients there.

The medical team is expected to provide a detailed report on each patient's condition on Thursday. Additionally, they expressed satisfaction with the overall treatment being provided at the hospitals.​
 

Rehabilitation of injured in mass uprising stressed
Staff Correspondent 09 November, 2024, 01:29


1731200734968.png


Architect Mubasshar Hussain Foundation holds an event titled Introduction Ceremony of Volunteers Helping the Injured at the SEL Centre in the capital’s Panthapath on Friday. | New Age photo

People from different professional groups on Friday called for an immediate beginning of a long-term rehabilitation process for the people injured during the July-August mass uprising, which arose from student protests demanding quota reform in government jobs.

They, in the event titled ‘Introduction Ceremony of Volunteers Helping the Injured’, also urged the creation of a central database to ensure the proper rehabilitation of around 30,000 injured individuals.

The event was organised by the Architect Mubasshar Hussain Foundation with the help of The Structural Engineers Limited at SEL Center in the capital’s Panthapath area.

Saiduddin Mohammad Emdad, an organiser of Raktim July Chabbish—an organisation led by several individuals injured in the July-August mass uprising—emphasised the need for genuine rehabilitation efforts for the injured people, rather than simply offering donations.

Saiduddin, who was shot at on August 4 during the movement, said, ‘The state is not doing enough for the injured people, who are facing numerous challenges including depression and financial hardships.’

The speakers observed that the interim government is not giving sufficient priority to the injured individuals.

Barrister Sara Hossain, honorary executive director of Bangladesh Legal Aid and Services Trust, emphasised the importance of documenting the experiences of the injured ones, noting that these accounts would serve as valuable testimony.

She also stressed the need to address human rights violations that occurred during the movement while the Awami League was in power.

Thirteen volunteer organisations that supported the people injured in the July-August mass uprising were awarded with honorary certificates as a token of appreciation.

Bishwa Sahitya Kendra founder and chairman Abdullah Abu Sayeed was, among others, also present at the event.​
 

Long-term rehab plan needed for injured protesters
10 November, 2024, 00:00

THE government has expressed its commitment to medical and socio-economic support for protesters wounded in the July-August uprising. It has also taken some steps in this direction. A number of platforms of volunteers working with the injured at an event in Dhaka on November 8, however, expressed their concern about the delay in treatment and financial support for protesters. While the government is busy examining the list of injured, at least 587 had to go through amputation and 685 people have been fully or partially blinded by shotgun pellets that law enforcers used to quell the uprising. An injured victim, also a member of Raktim July Chabbish, a platform of the victims of the July uprising, reports having faced major mismanagement in accessing health care. He also notes that the government support is not accessible to all, especially those living outside Dhaka, who do not have the digital literacy to access information circulated on social network. The government should, therefore, devise a long-term treatment and rehabilitation plan for the injured protesters at the earliest.

Volunteers, injured protesters and the families have, therefore, put forth the demands. The committee under the health ministry that coordinates the treatment and enlistment process has recently announced a hotline number that the injured can use to access related information. Many injured victims, especially with working class backgrounds, report that they have to wait too long on the phone or call a number of times to access the telephone service. Many, who returned home after their initial treatment, talked about their economic struggle for follow-up treatment in Dhaka. Without a publicly supported shelter for the injured seeking treatment in public hospitals, some have reported spending nights at bus stands or on hospital verandas. A large number of the injured are rickshaw-pullers, restaurant workers, industrial workers or roadside vendors and in their cases, their concern is not limited to medical treatment. Their family’s economic survival is also at stake. They have talked about their struggle to keep a roof over their head or pay for their children’s tuition as they have not earned for more than three months. Some injured protesters have already manifested post-traumatic stress disorder, which is left unattended.


It is high time that the government drew up a thorough plan on how to support and acknowledge people’s contribution to the uprising and make it public. The priority task for the government is to make a list of all deceased and injured in the protests under the Awami League regime and ensure emergency and long-term economic support for them. The government should also ensure equal access to treatment for all injured protesters. The government should consider forming a task force involving national and international experts with experience dealing with similar violent situations to ensure the best possible health care.​
 

July uprising injured vow to continue protest at NITOR
Better treatment, quick release of funds demanded

1731544531695.png

Photo: Rashed Sumon A group of protesters, injured during the July uprising, stage a sit in at the National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopaedic Rehabilitation (NITOR), where they are currently being treated.

A group of protesters who were injured during the July mass uprising and are now undergoing treatment, were blocking the road in front of the National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopaedic Rehabilitation (NITOR) till midnight, demanding proper treatment.

They also demanded quick release of funds from the July Smriti Foundation for all the victims.

The protests began after Health Adviser Nurjahan Begum went to the hospital to visit them. She had to leave NITOR in a different vehicle after her car was blocked.

Accompanied by British High Commissioner to Bangladesh Sarah Cooke, she went there around 11:30am.

When the two were leaving the hospital after talking to a few patients, the other injured victims gathered outside and blocked the adviser's car on the hospital premises, witnesses said.

Some lay in front of the vehicle, while others climbed onto it.

The protocol officers pushed them away during the protests, they alleged.

In response to the situation, the health adviser left in another vehicle. The UK high commissioner also had to leave the hospital in a different car.

The injured protesters – some with bandages on their hands, legs or eyes and others in wheelchairs or with crutches – then left the hospital and blocked the adjacent road.

They declared they would not clear the road until the health adviser met everyone.

They also expressed frustration over not receiving the promised compensation of Tk 100,000 each.

Confirming the incident, Ziaul Haque, additional deputy commissioner of Tejgaon Division Police, said the adviser had left safely and her car was not damaged.

As of filing this report around 1:00am today, the protesters were still on the road.

Around 10:30pm, Hasnat Abdullah, convenor of the Anti-Discrimination Students' Movement, which spearheaded the July uprising, and Mir Mahbubur Rahman Snigdho, general secretary of the July Smriti Foundation and brother of slain student protester Mir Mahfuzur Rahman Mugdho, went to the spot to talk to the protesters.

They said they found many of the injured were not protesters of the movement and were Awami League supporters, adding that the foundation was working to verify and crosscheck the list properly and this was why many of the victims did not yet receive their compensation.

Hasnat mentioned that the health adviser is a cancer patient, and her newly appointed assistant Prof Sayedur Rahman, former BSMMU vice chancellor, may be able to visit instead.

However, the protesters said they will remain on the street, whether they lose another limb or not, until the advisers come back and talk to them all, and ensure proper treatment and the disbursement of funds.

One protester said he wants the resignation of the health adviser.

Meanwhile, the hospital authorities said those injured in the July uprising were being given the highest priority. Special wards and food have been designated for them.

Shahidul Islam, 19, a protester who was wounded by bullets and is now being treated on the second floor of the hospital, said the adviser and others arrived at the hospital and went to the third floor, where they talked to only a few of the injured.

"There are at least 42 of us receiving treatment on the second floor but the adviser was leaving the hospital without visiting us."

Upon hearing the news, the other injured July protesters, who are being treated at nearby hospitals, joined the protests as well.

At one stage, military personnel stationed near the hospital requested them to return to the hospital.

However, Md Masum, seated in a wheelchair, said they would not leave until the health adviser returned to meet them. "After three long months, she finally comes here but chooses to neglect us."

Expressing his grievances, Masum said, "She became an adviser over our blood. Many of us are yet to receive the promised compensation from the July Foundation."

Al Miraj, an MBA student of IUBAT, was injured in both eyes while protesting in Kakrail on the afternoon of July 19.

He has since been receiving treatment at the National Institute of Ophthalmology & Hospital. "Doctors have said the treatment for my right eye is not available in the country. We took to the street to demand better treatment."

Currently, 84 injured protesters from the uprising are undergoing treatment at NITOR. Two separate wards are dedicated for the them -- one in level-2 and another in level-3, according to hospital officials.

Till date, 21 people have had their hands and legs amputated, while six patients have died.

Shahin Alam, a ninth-grader who was injured on August 5, and receiving treatment at NITOR, was also protesting yesterday.

"I was shot in the left leg and underwent four surgeries in NITOR. The doctor told me to come back after nine months. I don't think I'm getting proper treatment here."

Md Badiuzzaman, deputy director of NITOR, said, medical teams from China and Thailand visited them, and there is a team from the UK who are working to assess their treatment. Until yesterday, 15 people have undergone surgeries.

"Moreover, the foreign medical teams have expressed a great deal of satisfaction with our medical procedures. But it will take a long time for the patients' condition to improve, especially those with nerve injuries … Any claims of us not giving proper treatment are false."

Regarding those who did not receive compensation from July Foundation, he said, "As far as we know, there were some problems with papers of some of the patients, which is why they haven't received the money yet."​
 

Ensure swift disbursement of funds for July victims
Why would the injured need to demand what should be readily given?

1731631484583.png

VISUAL: STAR

We are quite troubled to see that a street protest—that too for about 14 hours—had to occur for those injured in the July-August uprising to put the spotlight on their grievances surrounding treatment, promised compensation, and rehabilitation. This is an issue that should not have arisen in the first place. Those who suffered injuries or lost their loved ones during the movement to bring down a fascist regime deserve our gratitude and sincere cooperation, not the frustration of having to fight once more to receive basic support.

Reportedly, a group of injured protesters staged a sit-in in front of the National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopaedic Rehabilitation (NITOR) after Health Adviser Nurjahan Begum visited the hospital but apparently met only a few of the injured, triggering angry reactions among others. This led to a prolonged road blockade that stretched into early Thursday. The protesters, later joined by patients from the nearby National Institute of Opthalmology & Hospital (NIOH), were still bearing the scars of the uprising, many with bandages or using crutches or wheelchairs. As well as expressing their grievances, they also called for the resignation of the health adviser. It was only after the intervention of four government advisers late at night that they agreed to return to their hospitals.

It may be recalled that at least 873 individuals lost their lives, and 19,931 were injured, during the uprising. So far, the health authorities have taken various measures to assist the affected and their families. Government hospitals have been providing free treatment, and doctors from abroad have been brought in to address complex injuries. Meanwhile, according to an estimate given by the July Shaheed Smriti Foundation, the families of 200 deceased, and over 500 injured individuals, have received compensation so far.

That means a large number of the victims are still waiting for compensation, even after over three months, while some require advanced treatment which is not possible in local hospitals. These issues coupled with concerns over their rehabilitation have deepened frustrations. The delayed release of funds is apparently due to verification issues as many claimants still needed further documentation. However, Sarjis Alam, general secretary of the foundation, stressed that once the verification process is completed, funds can be released to 500 people every day, and that everyone would get their compensation by December. The government, after Wednesday's protests, also promised to devise a framework for the treatment and rehabilitation of the injured, in consultation with the latter, and implement it by December.

We are encouraged to hear that, but we must urge the authorities to ensure nothing comes in the way of fulfilling these promises. The July victims and their families have already endured unimaginable hardships; it is our duty to ensure they are given the dignity, care, and support they deserve. To meet the deadlines set by the government, it is also vital to streamline these processes to reduce the chances of bureaucratic delays or obstacles.​
 

Injured of uprising to get lifetime healthcare
Staff Correspondent 15 November, 2024, 00:15

1731632502775.png

One of the injured victims in the student-led mass uprising gets on a car to attend the meeting with the interim government advisers at the secretariat in Dhaka on Thursday. | New Age photo

The interim government on Thursday announced that the people injured in July-August student-led mass uprising will get a lifetime free medical services at all government hospitals.

The decision was made in a meeting between the interim government’s six advisers and around a hundred representatives from the injured at the secretariat following the overnight street protests by the injured.

Md Sayedur Rahman, newly appointed special assistant to the health and family welfare adviser, told the media that the injured people will have a unique ID card, through which all benefits for the injured will be ensured.

‘A written draft outline will be presented to everyone within the next five working days, and by reviewing this written outline alongside the timeline, you will be able to understand whether we are progressing on the commitments we have made,’ he told the protesters.

‘We hope that all of these will be visible by December,’ he added.

The injured will get services free of charge also in private hospitals with which the government has an agreement, said a press release from the health ministry.

The government will establish a support centre by November 17 to address all complaints from the injured, reimburse them the treatment expenses upon submission of appropriate documentation, and integrate all specialised hospitals, including private hospital, into a unified support network for the best treatment, said the press release.

The government also committed to provide dedicated beds for the injured at all hospitals, bring the victims with mental trauma under the telemedicine network, arranging appropriate training and employment opportunity based on education and abilities for individuals who lost their eyesight, and ensuring necessary machines, medical services, and equipment for those with physical disabilities.

‘We aim to quickly implement the short-term plans and bring the long-term plans to a visible stage as soon as possible,’ said the information and broadcasting adviser Nahid Islam.

Livestock adviser Farida Akhter, local government adviser Asif Mahmud, adviser Mahfuj Alam, Social Welfare Advisor Sharmin S Murshid, the Anti-Discrimination Student Movement convener Hasnat Abdullah and July Shaheed Smriti Foundation general secretary Sarjis Alam were present at the meeting.

The meeting was held after protesters blocked the road in front of the National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopaedic Rehabilitation from 2:00pm on Wednesday to around 2:30am on Thursday over negligence in treatment and rehabilitation of them.

The protesters, undergoing treatment at hospitals, including the National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopaedic Rehabilitation and the National Institute of Ophthalmology and Hospital, took to the street after health adviser Nurjahan Begum, who had visited NITOR at 11:30am, left without meeting all of them.

As the aggrieved protesters cordoned off the health adviser’s vehicle, the health adviser Nurjahan and British high commissioner Sarah Cook were forced to leave NITOR in another vehicle.

Later at night, they lifted the blockade following assurances from law adviser Asif Nazrul, adviser Mahfuj Alam, fisheries and livestock adviser Farida Akhter, local government adviser Asif Mahmud, and special assistant for health Md Sayedur Rahman to address their demands.

During the blockade, the protesters expressed their frustration over negligence in treatment and rehabilitation, as well as delays in the disbursement of funds from the July Shaheed Smriti Foundation.​
 

Injured protesters place 7-point demand

1731718520708.png

Photo: Star

A delegation of those injured during the July-August uprising presented their seven-point demand in a meeting with government advisers at the Secretariat that started at 4:40pm.

One of the demands is that the state must ensure the same standard of medical treatment for those injured that would have been provided to a minister or adviser to the interim government.

In the press release for the seven points, signed by Zihad Islam, a coordinator of the martyrs' families and injured of the uprising, they also said the medical expenses of the injured ones who received treatment at their own costs must be reimbursed.

Another demand was that the injured and the martyred be issued special cards and provided with a special monthly allowance for another generation along with their rehabilitation.

They made the demand for a museum by the name of "Smriti Foundation" commemorating those killed or injured during the mass uprising of 2024, and an annual mass signature campaign programme between July 1 and August 5.

They called for the formation of an independent probe committee to examine the medical files of those killed or those who lost limbs in the mass uprising, and legal action if any proof of medical negligence is found.

They also called for the swift prosecution of Awami League and its complicit forces, and a ban on these organisations.

They also demanded the accommodation of the voice of wounded protesters and families of those killed in the state reform initiatives of the future.

A group of protesters undergoing treatment for injuries suffered during the July-August mass uprising demonstrated in front of the National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopaedic Rehabilitation (NITOR) yesterday with various demands, including better treatment and government assistance.

The protesters relented and agreed to return to their hospitals with the assurance of support and quick release of funds after four advisers went to NITOR at 2:30am today and assured the protesters of proper treatment and rehabilitation.

The advisers last night offered to hold a meeting this afternoon with the representatives from among the protesters.​
 

Treatment of the injured: Why the ongoing neglect?
Editorial Desk
Updated: 15 Nov 2024, 15: 28

The interim government formed after the July uprising is about to complete 100 days in office. One of its key priorities was to provide support to the families of those who lost their lives and to help those who were injured.

But, even after all this time, a full list of the dead and injured has still not been made public. This raises serious concerns about the progress of the aid and rehabilitation efforts.

A Prothom Alo report published on 7 September stated that according to the Ministry of Health, more than 18,000 people have received treatment for injuries sustained during the uprising. Another report mention 875 deaths. The anti-discrimination student movement leaders argue that the actual number is much higher.

The July Shaheed Smriti Foundation has been formed to provide medical assistance to the families of those killed and injured in the student uprising. In addition, the Ministry of Health is responsible for offering healthcare.

It was announced that the government would provide free medical services in public hospitals and cover the costs at private hospitals as well. However, despite regular media reports of negligence in treating the injured, no effective action has been taken by the government.

Patients receiving treatment at the National Orthopedic Hospital (better known as Pangu Hospital) staged protests last Wednesday in response to the government's negligence. When they surrounded the health adviser but received no remedy, they left the hospital and took to the streets, blocking traffic in the area.

The injured had called for advisers to reach them by 10 pm, but none arrived at the appointed time. In the meantime, some representatives from the anti-discrimination student movement visited the hospital to try and persuade the injured, but their efforts were unsuccessful.

Finally, at midnight, four government advisers arrived at the site, expressed regret over the delay, and promised to resolve the issue by Thursday.

However, even then, the injured responded with anger. Some had lost their eyesight, while others had lost their hands or feet. To their dismay, the health adviser visited the fifth floor of the hospital but did not meet with the patients on the other floors.

The demand raised by the injured individuals who took to the streets in front of Pangu Hospital, calling for better treatment and rehabilitation, is just. They claimed that despite going to the residence of the chief adviser, they were unable to meet him.

Policymakers in the interim government promised to address the treatment of the wounded. However, many gaps remain in the execution of these promises. The health adviser, who was assigned to oversee the ministry, has been largely invisible in her role.

She had previously been attacked by physicians during a public event. On Wednesday, he had to abandon her car and leave the hospital in another vehicle to escape protests from the injured victims of the July movement.

Many have still not received the promised financial assistance of Tk 100,000 per person. What is the explanation for this neglect?

We hope that the decision made by the four government advisers regarding the treatment of the injured, as agreed in Thursday's meeting, will be implemented without delay.

The government should promptly publish a complete list of those killed and injured in the July uprising and update the public on the condition of the injured. If necessary, they should arrange for treatment abroad.​
 

Member Search / Jot Notes

Back