[🇧🇩] Monitoring Bangladesh's Economy

Quick Reply ✓ Posted!
Quick Reply ✓ Posted!
[🇧🇩] Monitoring Bangladesh's Economy
1K
55K
More threads by Saif

G Bangladesh Defense

GOVT MOVE TO RAMP UP TAX-GDP RATIO LOOKS ELUSIVE
NBR sets ambitious targets sans reality assessment


1794869456565.webp



An ambitious government target to ramp up Bangladesh's lowly tax-to-GDP ratio looks hard to achieve as the principal revenue authority is more interested in enhancing tax receipts sans reality checks.

The revenue board sets tax targets, change tax policies and attempt revenue reforms without an adequately functioning institutional research and analytical mechanism, analysts say.

Though it has a Research and Statistics (RnS) wing established in 1979 with a mandate to recommend reforms to the tax structure, suggest fiscal measures for national budgets and conduct studies on income tax, customs and VAT, the National Board of Revenue's (NBR) wing appears to have lost sight of its core purpose.

Despite the government's growing need for evidence-based policymaking to raise the country's tax-to-GDP ratio, the wing has failed to establish itself as a research institution, with virtually no substantive policy research undertaken during its nearly five decades of existence as a virtual do-nothing.

Economists and revenue officials say institutional neglect, frequent leadership changes, inadequate resources and a lack of government demand for independent analysis have reduced the wing largely to a statistics-gathering unit.

The NBR, the country's principal domestic revenue-mobilisation agency, accounts for around 85 per cent of total domestic revenues for financing government budget.

Revenue officials say the wing is now primarily engaged in collecting and compiling data from field offices and publishing the NBR's annual report, with little capacity to undertake meaningful research or policy analysis.

The wing currently has a seven-member team and operates without a separate research budget, adequate logistics, IT support or sufficient manpower.

Its leadership has also suffered from frequent changes, disrupting institutional continuity. In 2026 alone, the wing had to receive three directors-general (DGs).

The incumbent DG, Abul Bashar Md Shafiqur Rahman, took charge on October 27, 2026, after his two predecessors had served for around five months each before getting their marching orders.

He had previously served as DG of the wing from February 22 to November 19, 2023.

A senior NBR official described the position as a "dumping post", saying cadre officials posted there have limited opportunities to contribute to revenue administration.

"Few cadre officials are willing to stay long as DG of the Research and Statistics Wing, resulting in frequent leadership changes," he said.

The wing publishes an annual report of nearly 300 pages, but the publication process itself is considerably delayed, often taking two to three years.

The latest available report covers 2022-23, while a draft report for 2023-24 is just being prepared for publication.

A review by The Financial Express of the annual reports for the previous five years, alongside discussions with field-level officials, found inconsistencies in the reporting formats and figures.

Some officials said neither the NBR headquarters nor the relevant field offices could independently verify or take responsibility for certain figures.

For example, the data on taxpayers having different income ceiling or data of public limited companies' tax have no authenticity.

Although field offices signed and returned the prescribed reporting forms, some officials admitted they had done so without properly checking the figures, citing a lack of appropriate tools and resources for verification.

"When the Research and Statistics Wing sends us a format, field officials somehow fill it in with anticipated figures," said a tax commissioner at the field level, requesting anonymity.

He questioned the usefulness of publishing reports that have played little role in revenue planning or policymaking.

The limitations were also exposed during a recent meeting with an International Monetary Fund (IMF) mission, when the wing was asked whether it maintained data on personal income tax and corporate tax collections.

Officials reportedly answered in the negative.

Officials have confirmed data on different income ceilings of individual taxpayers or public limited companies, outstanding revenue, pending court cases, corporate-tax payment and the number of individuals and corporate taxpayers of different income ceilings are fabricated and cooked.

The wing's approved organogram provides for a deputy director-general as the second-in-command and four research officers. Those positions, however, have remained vacant, leaving the unit without the professional manpower required to fulfill its mandate.

Wing officials have also received no basic training in business-process analysis, according to revenue officials.

The absence of institutional research has wider implications for revenue planning. The NBR frequently sets ambitious collection targets that prove difficult to achieve, without conducting adequate studies to establish its actual revenue-mobilisation capacity.

Despite having a dedicated research wing, the revenue authority has not undertaken comprehensive assessments of its capacity to collect taxes or the potential revenue available from different sectors.

The government target of raising the tax-to-GDP ratio to 10.5 per cent by 2030 may remain elusive unless the revenue administration is equipped with adequate logistics, automation, transparency and analytical capacity.

Many revenue policy decisions are taken without prior impact assessments, only for the NBR to reconsider or reverse them later.

With skilled professionals and proper institutional supervision, the research wing could independently conduct such assessments, helping policymakers understand the revenue, economic and distributional implications of proposed tax measures.

An earlier initiative sought to reconcile discrepancies in revenue data, but the Integrated Budget and Accounting System (iBAS) has since emerged as the primary source of government revenue information.

The income tax, customs and VAT wings of the NBR also conduct research-related exercises independently, but officials from the Research and Statistics Wing are often not involved in those activities.

"Only addition and subtraction have been the wing's work since its inception," said a revenue official.

Research Director of CPD Towfiqul Islam Khan, head of the research wing, said the RnS Wing was one of the key institutional components needed for meaningful revenue reform, but its limited capacity and conventional data-collection methods had prevented it from addressing major tax-policy challenges.

He said political and administrative considerations strongly influenced revenue planning, reducing the demand for independent research and evidence-based policy decisions.

"Vested interests play a significant role in revenue policymaking, while political and administrative considerations often dominate decisions," he said.

The absence of transparent and credible revenue data also weakened accountability in tax policymaking, he added.

Mr Khan, however, views the NBR's ongoing move to digitise its databases as an opportunity to establish an authentic and reliable revenue-information system.

Dr Rashed Al Titumir, adviser to the Prime Minister on Finance and Planning, has said the IMF had given Bangladesh a 'C' grade on data credibility, an assessment that the country needed to take seriously.

"It is shameful for us that the authenticity of our data is being questioned."

He said NBR revenue data must follow the iBAS system to ensure consistency and credibility.

"We have instructed the NBR not to use administrative data," he said, adding that the fundamental problem lay in the sources and methods of data collection.

He also pointed to instances of overestimation and inaccurate reporting, saying that the country needed to address the underlying weaknesses in its revenue-data system.

Following the proposed bifurcation of the NBR, the Research and Statistics Wing could potentially become part of the policy wings of income tax, customs and VAT, where economists, tax specialists and other experts would work together, officials indicated.

Former NBR Commissioner Md Anwar Hossain, the longest-serving DG of the Research and Statistics Wing for around three years, says the institution has historically suffered from neglect and underutilization.

"With a few notable exceptions, the wing has lacked sustained strategic focus, largely due to limited institutional incentives and a lack of motivation among both its permanent staff and the leadership posted there over the years," he told The Financial Express.

As a result, its core mandate has often been sidelined by routine administrative duties rather than high-level analytical work, he said.

"The wing possesses immense latent potential to serve as the analytical backbone of our fiscal policy. However, realising this requires deliberate government backing, structured capacity building and modern management."

If formally integrated into the macroeconomic policy-planning process and empowered to conduct rigorous impact assessments, the wing could become a vital driver of sustainable revenue mobilisation, he added.

In modern tax administrations around the world, data analytics and policy research are indispensable, Mr Anwar said.

He has suggested targeted structural reforms, including the recruitment of specialised professionals, clearly-defined operational mandates and institutional autonomy, to enable the wing to function as a credible think-tank within the NBR.

Responding to criticism of the annual report, he acknowledged that concerns over its presentation, formatting and analytical depth were justified and that the publication required a comprehensive overhaul to meet modern reporting standards.

However, he said the weaknesses in the reports reflected broader systemic shortcomings rather than merely the limitations of the research wing.

"Until the NBR and its field offices, alongside allied financial and regulatory agencies, undergo complete automation with seamless API-based data sharing, the wing will remain constrained in its ability to gather real-time, granular data."

Once such digital integration is achieved, both the accuracy of the data and the quality of the annual report will improve significantly, he hopes.​
 

Why objective calculation of GDP is a must

Even the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) was impressed by the performance of Bangladesh on the economic front during the first half of the past decade. But it also underscored that some of its achievements could not be explained by the related economic theories. The EIU suspected that there was many a slip twixt the cup and the lip. So it concluded that Bangladesh's was a unique case. The development narrative espoused by the Awami League government of the time continued unchallenged. On rare occasions, though, some minor chinks got exposed when official statistics provided by the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) did not match data or figures of the Bangladesh Bank and other organisations and institutes concerned. There was a hunch that something was missing somewhere or doctored in order to create a positive impression.

Now a forensic audit report — one that is specifically conducted to reconstruct illegal financial activities and withstand legal or regulatory scrutiny — has, according to the Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies (BIDS), unearthed the missing link. The missing link is the overvaluation of the country's Gross Domestic Product (GDP) with the doctored official figures prevailing over the evidence-based data obtained at the grass-roots levels. Referring to the BIDS findings, prime minister's adviser on finance and planning Rashed Al Mahmud Titumir claims, "GDP estimates were overvalued by 0.7-1.13 percentage points" during the decade starting from the financial year 2014-15. This accounted for 10-18 per cent of the reported growth figure. Primarily the manufacturing sector was subjected to such distortions with particular emphasis on sub-sectors like cement, petroleum, pharmaceuticals and other industries, leaving readymade garments alone. Researchers at the BIDS found the anomalies following their close examinations of the methodologies and data sources used to calculate GDP. A cursory look at the manipulated data gives a false impression of slight tempering but when their contributions at 10-18 per cent of the total growth are taken into account, the magnitude of doctoring of data becomes evident.

Extrapolation of values presents an artificial picture of development—one that triggers all kinds of misdirected policies and priorities. Researchers arrive at undesirable conclusions. Objectivity and credibility become a casualty. Although it serves a government temporarily, in the long run it backfires to make the authority a victim of its own misdeed. This is exactly why organisations like the BBS should be made independent and allowed to carry out its business without taking any brief from the higher authority.

Thankfully, the incumbent government has proposed such an arrangement for the BBS. The national statistical organisation should be accountable to the people, not the government. It should take up studies with particular focus on social disparities and discriminations. The evidence-based data may help researchers and policymakers to pinpoint anomalies in the distribution of wealth and possible remedies. Successive governments have created an oligarchic society where the privileged have been pampered to the denial of basic human rights of the majority of the people. Such archaic development priorities should be exposed by authentic studies in the interest of dismantling yawning social divides and forging national unity on equalitarian terms and conditions. The dispensation of governance on this line alone can meet the expectations of the masses.​
 

A trillion-dollar economy by 2034?


1794869957143.webp



While speaking at an international conference on sovereign debt management recently, Finance and Planning Minister Amir Khosru Mahmud Chowdhury reiterated the government's objective of turning Bangladesh into a trillion-dollar economy by 2034. Evidently, it is a political ambition of the incumbent government. However, there is a roadmap under the government's five-year development programme to realise the ambition. Increasing investment, widening the revenue base, ensuring energy security and diversifying the country's manufacturing and export sectors are integral to that roadmap.

Now, according to the provisional estimates of the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS), the size of the economy in FY26 was USD501 billion with its per capita income standing at USD3,020 against the previous fiscal's USD2,769. So, to double the size of the economy in eight years, its annual growth in nominal dollar terms has to be around 9 per cent. Notably, the government has set a real GDP growth target of 6.5 per cent for the current fiscal. But what complicates the arithmetic is that even with satisfactory growth in taka terms, the value of the additional wealth so created as expressed in US dollars might be less if the taka loses value against the dollar. The IMF, the World Bank (WB) and the Asian Development Bank (ADB), on the other hand, have brought down their projections of Bangladesh's GDP growth for the current fiscal to 3.2, 3.4 and 4.0 per cent respectively. The WB projects 3.9 per cent for FY28. Challenges that the economy is faced with including unreliable energy supplies, the precarious condition of the banking sector and the resulting sluggishness in private investment are not going to go away shortly. In fact, the government has to do much to restore the economy to its former growth trajectory, let alone double its size. Admittedly, the finance minister himself is aware of the limitations of borrowing from any single source to meet the country's capital requirement. Even if USD5 billion could be raised annually from the international capital markets, repayment obligations against past foreign borrowings alone are going to be of a similar order. The country's external debt servicing is expected to reach USD5.5 billion in FY30. So, where will the money for fresh investment come from? Notably, the government aims to raise the proportion of total investment to 40 per cent of GDP by FY31. Unless the domestic private sector is invigorated and foreign direct investment (FDI) comes in substantial amounts, such a level of investment cannot be conceived of. Then there is the question of the government's capacity to mobilise resources. With the tax-to-GDP ratio at hardly 7 per cent, the government is left with little money after meeting its recurring expenditures including debt servicing. Worse yet, a sizeable amount of the tax money might be required to rehabilitate banks whose funds were misappropriated. Why should the honest taxpayers be made to pay for the misdeeds of unscrupulous bank borrowers while many wealthy individuals and businesses continue to enjoy undue tax privileges? In fact, the issue of bringing such quarters within the tax net is largely a political one. Reconciling the government's growth objectives with the fiscal and monetary reforms being negotiated with the IMF and other multilateral lenders will also require considerable skill. For instance, to reduce subsidy expenditure, the government cannot indiscriminately raise the prices of electricity and fertilisers and thereby discourage both industrial and farm production. Add to that the cost of protecting the economy, particularly its agriculture, against the vagaries of climate change.

Bangladesh cannot borrow its way to becoming a trillion-dollar economy. The country needs to create conditions where even the small savers would feel secure about investing in productive enterprises. Skill development of its workforce, local technological innovations and their commercial exploitation can contribute immensely towards increasing productivity. And even if the goal of a trillion-dollar economy is achieved some years later than envisaged, it should be no cause for disappointment. What should concern us more is if, by then, the bulk of the population's economic lot has improved or not.​
 

ADB keen to support Bangladesh’s capital market development


1794871247060.webp



The Asian Development Bank (ADB) has expressed keen interest in supporting the development of Bangladesh’s capital market, opening up prospects for greater institutional cooperation, private sector investment and expanded public-private partnerships (PPPs) to strengthen the country's investment ecosystem.

A high-level ADB delegation led by Takeo Koike, head of the ADB's Office of Markets Development and Public-Private Partnership (OMDP), conveyed the interest during a meeting with Bangladesh Securities and Exchange Commission (BSEC) Chairman Masud Khan at the commission's office in Agargaon, Dhaka, on Monday.

The discussions focused on the potential areas of cooperation between the securities regulator and the Manila-based multilateral development lender, particularly in strengthening the institutional capacity of the capital market, promoting private sector development and creating new avenues for investment, according to a BSEC statement.

The ADB's interest comes at a time when Bangladesh needs a stronger and more diversified capital market to mobilise long-term financing for businesses, reduce excessive dependence on bank borrowing and support private sector-led economic growth.

During the meeting, the BSEC chief outlined various initiatives undertaken by the current commission to develop, expand and modernise the country's capital market, along with its future plans.

He also highlighted the importance of making the capital market more vibrant and effective in supporting private sector expansion and generating new investment opportunities.

The ADB delegation expressed its willingness to work with Bangladesh in advancing capital market development. The potential areas of engagement included enhancing institutional capabilities, facilitating private sector growth and exploring opportunities to strengthen PPP initiatives.

The discussions also covered how the capital market could play a greater role in supporting investment and broadening financing opportunities for the country’s businesses.

The BSEC assured the ADB delegation of providing necessary cooperation in pursuing collaborative initiatives for the development of the country’s capital market.

Both sides held discussions on various aspects of market development and possible avenues for future cooperation.​
 

PKDefense Forums: Country-by-Country Military Discussions

Log In Register Forums
Latest
Back