Vsdoc
Senior Member
- Joined
- Sep 8, 2024
- Messages
- 6,480
- Questions Answered
- 1
just the other day, right ?![]()
And its a lot more recent to say Iran being a Muslim nation.
Generaljust the other day, right ?![]()


How old is the dharm, Doc ?And its a lot more recent to say Iran being a Muslim nation.


How old is the dharm, Doc ?
Gooble AI sez:
pinpointing its exact age is difficult as it has evolved over millennia through various cultural and historical influences. Some scholars estimate its age to be over 5,000 years, while others believe it to be even older.
Wendy Doniger sez:
According to Doniger, Hinduism may have roots in pre-historic (pre-textual, pre-Vedic) Mesolithic prehistoric religion, such as evidenced in the rock paintings of Bhimbetka rock shelters, which are about 10,000 years old ( c. 8,000 BCE), as well as Neolithic times.
------------------------------------------------------------
who's to say ?
online bhot charcha hai is vishay par.
old as fvk is all I know
weathered many a tempest, has the 'eternal way'
codified nahi hai
atheism, agnosticism, skepticism to extreme ritualism, sab kuch hai
hot topic beef ko le ke bhi debate hai, cow vs bull.. kaun hai asli holy ?
complicated scene hai, Doc.. we don't do this haram vs halal black and white binary bs


Simple majority + indigenous culture, I guess.Well, for 1700 years, till say the 12th century, from around 500 BC, it shared space with Buddhism.
So again I ask you, how does that make India a Hindu nation.
Or are you saying that all Christians and all Muslims are essentially just Jews?
Not at all clear to me.Simple majority + indigenous culture, I guess.
just like:
Saudi and Iran are mull mulks
Italy is a Christy mulk
Russia is an orthodox Christy mulk
Myanmar is a Buddhist mulk
India is a Dharmi mulk
-------------
clear as day, isn't it ?


laga re,
kha re..
is shining

Not really.
Even as recently as a thousand years ago, there was a Hindu Renaissance ... revival ... which is a pseudonym for a brutal crushing and killing off of Buddhism across India.
It was in response to Sharma's post.
No post is made in a vacuum. Do follow the entire trail.
































