[🇧🇩] Indo-Bangla Relation: India's Regional Ambition, Geopolitical Reality, and Strategic Options For Bangladesh

  • Thread starter Thread starter Saif
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 442
  • Views Views 8K
[🇧🇩] Indo-Bangla Relation: India's Regional Ambition, Geopolitical Reality, and Strategic Options For Bangladesh
442
8K
More threads by Saif

G Bangladesh Defense Forum

Dhaka committed to boosting Indian Ocean partnership: foreign adviser

1739747053167.png

Md Touhid Hossain. File photo

Bangladesh has reiterated its commitment to embracing the tremendous opportunities that the Indian Ocean region offers by strengthening partnerships.

"We are committed to strengthening our partnerships across the Indian Ocean, addressing emerging challenges, and embracing the tremendous opportunities this region offers," said Foreign Affairs Adviser Md Touhid Hossain today.

The multiple challenges and other geo-economic and geo-strategic factors require increased cooperation among the States, he said.

Hossain made the remarks while speaking at the plenary session titled "Strengthening Maritime Supply Chains: Overcoming Disruptions and Enhancing Resilience" as part of the 8th Indian Ocean Conference (IOC)-2025 in Muscat, Oman.

Sheikh Humaid Al Maani, Head of the Diplomatic Academy, MoFA, Oman chaired the session.

The foreign adviser said the Indian Ocean region is a crucial strategic area that links the Asia-Pacific and African regions, with profound economic, political and security significance.

The conference provided a platform for participants to engage in "constructive discussions, share ideas, exchange knowledge, identify actionable solutions, and build meaningful partnerships and cooperation" in the region.

"We look forward to working together to ensure a brighter, more prosperous future for all nations of the Indian Ocean and beyond," Adviser Touhid said.

As a littoral state, he said, Bangladesh has long been a centre of maritime activities and it actively participates in various regional platforms, including the Indian Ocean Rim Association and the International Seabed Authority.

The 8th Indian Ocean Conference is being held under the theme "Voyage of New Horizons of Maritime Partnership."

He said Bangladesh places strong importance on maritime cooperation for facilitating the efficient movement of goods, services and people and for advancing food security, energy security, water cooperation, disaster risk reduction and providing fair access to global public goods. Bangladesh advocates for "shared prosperity" through "shared responsibility".

Maritime transport is the main artery of global trade and maritime supply chains remain the backbone of the global economy, he added.

He said eighty percent of global trade by volume, and over seventy percent by value, is transported by sea and the Indian Ocean, the world's third-largest body of water, plays a crucial role in this global trade.

Approximately 80 percent of the world's seaborne oil trade transits through the strategic choke points of the Indian Ocean, making it a vital link between the East and the West.

"Countries depend on the Indian Ocean for the movement of goods through maritime trade routes, safeguarding their economic and energy interests. However, the sector is facing multifaceted challenges that endanger the efficiency, reliability, resilience and sustainability of maritime supply chains," he said.

Maritime supply chain is vulnerable to many challenges like port congestion, capacity limitations, regulatory, operational and administrative issues, cyberattacks, piracy, and geopolitical tensions, which can disrupt the efficiency of maritime supply chains.

"We must also remember that the oceans are not only a driving force for global economic growth but also a vital source of food security," Hossain said.

The oceans are facing growing pressures from population growth, global competition for resources, rising food demand, water scarcity, maritime security threats, climate change, biodiversity loss and marine pollution.

"We need to take appropriate actions to tackle the maritime security threats of piracy, armed robbery, human trafficking, illegal arms trade, and illegal and unregulated fishing, among others. We need to address regulatory and administrative issues," said the foreign adviser.

The global economy, food security, and energy supplies are at increasing risk due to vulnerabilities at key maritime routes, he noted.

"We must take measures to address vulnerabilities and enhance resilience," he said

Strengthening maritime supply chains involves a holistic approach combining technology, infrastructure improvements, strategic planning, risk management strategies and cross-border collaboration.

"We need to facilitate maritime connectivity, reduce the trade barriers," he said, adding that they also need to consider liberalisation of the visa regime, particularly easing visas and other administrative processes for the seafarers, ensuring facilities for them, as their roles are crucial in maintaining the maritime supply chain.

He said the Indian Ocean has historically been a region of great collaboration.

"The benefits of multilateral cooperation in maritime issues are likely to increase over time," Touhid said, adding that to ensure a resilient and improved shared future, it is essential for the countries in the Indian Ocean region to explore opportunities for mutual collaboration across all possible areas.

Each coastal nation should ensure that growth and prosperity in the Indian Ocean region, as well as the surrounding seas and bays, are built on mutual trust, respect.

All nations should understand the idea of equal interests, as all littoral states collaborate to develop together, he added.

"We also must prioritise conservation and the sustainable use of ocean and coastal resources to ensure that the use of these resources does not contribute to the decline in the health of oceanic and coastal environments," the foreign adviser said.​
 

Bangladeshis’ credit card spending drops in India
Staff Correspondent 16 February, 2025, 22:47

1739751528426.png

A file photo shows a salesperson swiping credit card of a customer through a POS machine. | New Age photo

Credit card spending by Bangladeshis in India has been falling, while such expenditures in USA, Thailand and Singapore have been rising, according to central bank data.

Industry insiders attribute this shift to India’s restricted visa issuance, which has reduced the number of Bangladeshi patients and tourists visiting the country.

In December 2024, Bangladeshi credit card spending in India fell to Tk 40 crore from Tk 47.2 crore in November.

In contrast, Thailand and Singapore saw substantial increases.

Spending in Thailand reached Tk 64.8 crore in December, up from Tk 42 crore in September, making it the second-largest destination for Bangladeshi credit card transactions abroad.

Similarly, spending in Singapore rose to Tk 41.2 crore in December from Tk 30 crore in September.

Historically, India had been the top destination for Bangladeshi credit card spending abroad. From March 2023 to June 2024, India consistently held the top spot.

However, with the student quota reform protests in July—eventually turning into the movement that led to the fall of the Awami League-led government on August 5—the United States overtook India as the leading destination.

In July 2024, Bangladeshis spent Tk 79 crore in the USA, surpassing India’s Tk 73.2 crore.

By December 2024, the USA maintained the top position with Tk 74.3 crore in transactions, followed by Thailand (Tk 64.8 crore), Singapore (Tk 41.2 crore), and India (Tk 40 crore).

India’s share of total overseas credit card spending by Bangladeshis dropped from 19.95 per cent in December 2023 to just 8.13 per cent in December 2024.

India has traditionally been the most popular outbound destination for Bangladeshis, accounting for around 40 per cent of total travellers due to cultural ties, proximity, and easy visa access.

Following the political transition in August and the formation of the interim government, India scaled down its visa operations in Bangladesh, approving only medical and emergency cases under certain conditions.

As a result, many Bangladeshis seeking medical treatment or travel options have shifted to Thailand, Malaysia, and Singapore.

Tourists who previously visited Kolkata are now opting Thailand, Singapore, and Nepal instead.

Meanwhile, domestic credit card transactions in Bangladesh rose by 15.10 per cent in December, reaching Tk 3,215 crore from Tk 2,793 crore in November.

International credit card transactions also increased by 13.98 per cent, amounting to Tk 491.5 crore in December compared to Tk 431.2 crore in November.

Additionally, transactions involving foreign-issued credit cards used within Bangladesh saw an 18.90 per cent rise, climbing to Tk 240.9 crore in December from Tk 202.6 crore in November.​
 
কলকাতায় বাংলাদেশি পর্যটকের অভাবে দুরাবস্থা (Kolkata businesses are facing severe hardship due to the absence of Bangladeshi tourists)

 

Dhaka, Delhi agree to establish good working relations: Touhid
1740093224790.png

Photo: BSS

Foreign Affairs Adviser Md Touhid Hossain today said both Dhaka and Delhi have agreed to establish good working relations by addressing the remaining challenges.

"We agreed that we need to reach a good working relationship," the adviser told reporters at the foreign ministry this afternoon, referring to his recent meeting with Indian External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar in Muscat, Oman.

He noted that trade between the two countries has regained momentum and is approaching previous levels, but some issues, such as visa-related challenges, still need to be resolved.

Responding to a query, the adviser said no specific challenges were identified during the discussion, but both sides acknowledged the need to overcome certain obstacles to further strengthen bilateral ties.

Touhid said he invited Jaishankar to visit Bangladesh, highlighting the existing foreign minister-level mechanism. The last foreign minister-level meeting took place in New Delhi.

He mentioned that Bangladesh would arrange Jaishankar's visit once a suitable date is set.

Regarding the extradition of ousted prime minister Sheikh Hasina, Hossain said no specific discussions were held on the matter, but general issues were discussed.

He said it is an independent issue, and Bangladesh requested Hasina's extradition following the court order.

About the pause in US funding, Touhid clarified that the funding cut is not a Bangladesh-specific issue.

He said Bangladesh needs to find ways to overcome the challenges posed by the cuts.

On the sidelines of the 8th Indian Ocean Conference (IOC), Adviser Touhid met Jaishankar in Muscat, Oman, on Sunday.

During the meeting, both leaders acknowledged the challenges in bilateral relations, underscoring the importance of working together to address them.​
 

Foreign adviser reacts to Jaishankar’s comments on Dhaka-Delhi ties
NGO Bureau finds no entry of $29 million USAID fund
FE ONLINE REPORT
Published :
Feb 24, 2025 20:37
Updated :
Feb 24, 2025 20:37

1740443982998.png


India has to decide what kind of relationship it wants with Bangladesh, said Foreign Adviser Touhid Hossain on Monday when asked to respond to the comments of his Indian counterpart S Jaishankar.

“Mr Jaishankar said that Bangladesh has to decide what kind of relationship it wants with India, and my comment on the statement is that at the same time, India has to decide what kind of relationship it wants with Bangladesh,” the foreign adviser told the reporters at the foreign ministry.

"This is the issue for both sides, and there is nothing wrong in making this observation.”

"I think we have a very clear decision over the issue, and that is we want good working relations with India. And it is on the basis of mutual respect and reciprocal interest,” the adviser said.

Responding to another question, he said, India needs to decide what kind of relationship they want with us.

"But he (Mr Jaishankar) said that many in Bangladesh are making negative remarks against India. I do not want to say whether it is justified or not, but my point is that people from both sides are making such remarks. A chief minister of one of their states already called for the deployment of UN forces in Bangladesh. Another of their central ministers has been making remarks against Bangladesh frequently. Having this situation, we are trying to advance our relationship.”

"So, our position is that. We need to move forward to have better relations, brushing aside the silly comments made by a handful of people,” he explained.

But Mr Touhid categorically said that the objectionable remarks made by former prime minister Sheikh Hasina, now in India, is an impediment to advancing bilateral ties between Bangladesh and India.

"If any kind of untoward situation arises here, we will address it, but it is recognised by all that her speeches are adding fuel to the fire,” the foreign adviser noted.

"In the same manner, issuing visas to Bangladeshis is absolutely their sovereign right, and we have nothing to say about it. But when we see that the number of visas is reduced, we will definitely look for alternative ways. It is very natural,” he said.

On Jaishankar’s comment about minorities in Bangladesh, he said that India media has created a fake news campaign to establish that minorities are being tortured here, and on the basis of this campaign, many persons are raising such allegations.

“Moreover, minorities living in Bangladesh cannot be the headache of Indians, as minorities in India cannot be our headache. We should stick to a non-interference policy about it,” he said.

He said the government is looking into the issues related to the minority people living here, as they are the citizens of Bangladesh, and they enjoy the same rights as I enjoy here.

"And the government always tries to ensure these rights,” he added.

About Donald Trump’s comment on the 29 million dollar aid to a Bangladeshi NGO, the adviser said the NGO Affairs Bureau of Bangladesh said that they could not find any such entry.

"And no NGO can have a single penny without bypassing the Bureau, he said, adding that he had not any information in addition to that.

Regarding the reports of Bangladeshis fighting in Ukraine, he said that the ministry has asked the mission in Moscow to look into the matter.

But it is hard to prevent; if they are given Russian citizenship, it will be difficult to get them back, he noted.

"Many undesirable things are happening. None want to see that a Bangladeshi is drowned in the Mediterranean Sea, but such incidents are occurring, and we cannot prevent it despite our serious efforts,” he argued.

Asked to comment on the reports that he has failed to give proper leadership in the foreign ministry in the first six months of the present government, the adviser said, "If a better alternative than me is found who can lead the foreign ministry more efficiently, I am ready to welcome him.”​
 

Jaishankar’s remarks on Bangladesh: A deeper understanding is necessary

1740700555081.png

India's External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar. FILE PHOTO: REUTERS

India's External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar recently made some strong remarks about Bangladesh at the Delhi University Literature Festival. Here are some key excerpts from his speech, "Things happened there last year, all of you are aware of it… for us what is very troubling, there are two aspects of it… the spate of attacks on the minorities… it is something which impacts our thinking and… we have to speak up about… they have to make up their mind what kind of relationship they want with us. Because every day, somebody in Bangladesh, who is in the interim government… if they stand up and blame India for everything, and some of the things in the reports are ridiculous… I think this is a decision also that they have to make. About what kind of relationship they want.

"We have sent a very clear signal, okay we are a neighbour, we would like for things to calm down… But we would obviously not like to see the messaging and… signalling which is continuously hostile in a way to India."

Let's start from the very beginning—about what happened in Bangladesh last year. In July-August, a mass uprising erupted against Sheikh Hasina's Awami League government. During the protests, approximately 1,500 students, workers, and citizens lost their lives, while around 20,000 others were injured. A United Nations Fact-Finding Mission reported, "The prime minister herself told security force officials to kill protesters to quell the protests and specifically demanded 'arrest the ringleaders of the protests, the troublemakers, kill them and hide their bodies.'"

Despite these serious allegations, Indian officials and some segments of its media have barely mentioned these facts. They have hardly acknowledged that Sheikh Hasina and numerous other Awami League leaders—whom India has sheltered—stand accused of mass murder. If Mr Jaishankar and other Indian officials are truly aware of what happened in Bangladesh, why this omission?

On the issue of minority attacks, this newspaper, along with other media outlets as well as the interim government itself, have acknowledged and reported on incidents of attacks on minorities after the Awami League's unceremonious ouster. Many of these attacks occurred on August 5-8, when the country totally lacked law enforcement services. A number of minority community members—including Hindu Bangladeshis—were attacked, but some of them were attacked because of their political affiliation with the Awami League and the resentment among people towards the former ruling party.

While this context helps explain the attacks, it does not excuse them. The interim government has repeatedly stated that even a single attack on a member of a minority community is unacceptable.

However, segments of the Indian media have been caught exaggerating reports. And the extent of falsification even extended to presenting events in India as occurring in Bangladesh.

In fact, if we consider how some segments of the Indian media, social media, and commentators on other platforms have covered Bangladesh over the past six months, it has been nothing short of an information war against Bangladesh.

Indian government officials, too, have harped on this matter, with West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banarjee even suggesting that India should seek the deployment of UN peacekeeping forces in Bangladesh—raising concerns about Bangladesh's sovereignty.

What about the rights of minorities in India, though? Since 2014, leaders of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) have made many openly hostile remarks against Muslims. Some examples include:

i) On May 14, 2014, BJP leader Giriraj Singh said, "Is it not true that people involved in terror activities belong to a particular religion?"

ii) On September 14, 2014, MP Sakshi Maharaj claimed, "Terrorism is being taught in madrassas."

iii) In March 2016, BJP leader and Union Minister Anantkumar Hegde stated, "As long as Islam exists, there will be terrorism. Until we uproot Islam, we cannot eliminate terrorism."

iv) On February 6, 2018, MP Vinay Katiyar declared, "Muslims should not stay in this country. They have partitioned the country based on population. So why are they still here? They should go to Bangladesh or Pakistan… They have no business being in India."

And these are only a few examples.

On August 14, 2024, Human Rights Watch reported that since March 2024, of the 173 speeches delivered by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, 110 contained Islamophobic remarks.

Yet, Bangladesh has rarely issued statements of concern about minorities in India, treating these issues as the latter country's internal affairs. Notably, India rarely expressed similar concerns about minority rights during Hasina's tenure, despite similar incidents occurring, leading to some deaths and many injuries. Since Hasina's fall, however, India appears to have taken a different approach towards Bangladesh. This raises questions about the sincerity of these recent concerns from India.

Mr Jaishankar has said India has sent a very clear signal that it wants things to "calm down," but it does not want to see hostile messaging from members of the Bangladesh government. Such restraints, however, should be mutual.

In light of that, it is important to mention that BJP leaders have repeatedly accused Bangladeshis of trying to take over the "rightful land" of Indians, referring to them as "Jihadis," "infiltrators," and "termites," who should be identified and drowned in the Bay of Bengal. Do these remarks not come off as hostile?

And what about BJP leader Dilip Ghosh's comment in December 2024—months after the interim government took office—that Bangladesh's forces are no match for India and that Bangladesh's political leaders should "think carefully" about the ongoing turmoil? Was that a friendly message?

Moreover, the continued killings of Bangladeshis by Indian border forces, despite repeated promises of zero border killings, sends more contradictory signals. So does India's failure to share the water of Teesta River with Bangladesh, despite previous assurances.

India should understand that Bangladesh has a legitimate right to feel aggrieved by these and other unresolved matters. And the Indian government should be willing to listen to these grievances instead of ignoring them.

The Bangladesh government, similarly, should listen carefully to the legitimate concerns raised by India. In this case, for example, Mr Jaishankar's point of not sending hostile signals should be taken seriously by the Bangladesh government.

There are two other important lessons that Bangladesh should draw from this situation. First, for years, India engaged only with one political party in Bangladesh—Sheikh Hasina's Awami League—and treated it as the sole representative of the country. Bangladesh must not make the same mistake. India is a vast, diverse nation. The majority of its people, if they truly understood the oppressive nature of Hasina's regime, would likely sympathise with the Bangladeshi people.

Even if there are groups in India we disagree with, we must continue to engage with the broader Indian population. This will benefit both nations.

Second, we must realise that there is no place for ego in foreign policy. Some Bangladeshi commentators have suggested that India's reaction to Hasina's ouster is driven by bruised egos—because India lost a pliant ally and failed to predict the changing political landscape. But foreign policy must not be driven by ego or emotion—and this also applies to us. It should be rooted in pragmatism, common sense, and mutual benefit.

And so, if Bangladesh and India truly want a stable relationship, and we believe they do, both sides must acknowledge their shortcomings and address each other's concerns with sincerity.

Eresh Omar Jamal is head of the editorial department at The Daily Star.​
 

Latest Tweets

Sharma Ji Mainerik Sharma Ji wrote on Mainerik's profile.
tiktok ? .. its blocked here, can't see.

congrats to Pakistan, what did they win ?

Latest Posts

Back