Donate ☕
201 Military Defense Forums
[🇧🇩] - India Out Campaign in Bangladesh | Page 10 | PKDefense
Home Login Forums Wars Movies Watch Videos
Serious discussion on defense, geopolitics, and global security.

[🇧🇩] India Out Campaign in Bangladesh

Reply (Scroll)
Press space to scroll through posts
G Bangladesh Defense
[🇧🇩] India Out Campaign in Bangladesh
101
6K
More threads by Saif

Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Fact Check Respond
Yes @Old School bhai, it's distracting Anti Hasina movement which I'd true bhai! But how it is helping BJP? Please elaborate so that others also can have some knowledge about it ( if they want to learn of course) !
It is not a trivial question. BJP's political capital is defending Hindutva Bharat. The bigger the threat to Bharat, the better its claim to be the defender of India is justified. When anti-Indian activities increase in India's neighborhood, BJP's popularity increases. When it's quiet, the BJP ensures there is something to stir up the unrest. It's especially true during election years. More anti-India activities in the neighborhood mean more votes for BJP. If you see, the BNP is not even hurting or targeting the big businesses that are allies of the BJP, like the ADANI or TATA group. BNP targets smaller groups producing toothpaste, hair oils, etc., but enough to get anti-India publicity.
Finally, this campaign is not against the Hasina regime, and the Hasina regime pays a huge amount of money to ADANI groups to keep BJP in line while maintaining a powerful China connection. So, it will also help Hasina to show the Chinese that she is not stopping this anti-India campaign but allowing it to continue. Do you think you can still openly make "Boycott India" videos in Dhaka if Hasina's intel agencies and Police / RAB want to stop it? This campaign benefits Hasina, too.
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Fact Check Respond
  • Wow (+2)
Reactions: Vikings
.
It is not a trivial question. BJP's political capital is defending Hindutva Bharat. The bigger the threat to Bharat, the better its claim to be the defender of India is justified. When anti-Indian activities increase in India's neighborhood, BJP's popularity increases. When it's quiet, the BJP ensures there is something to stir up the unrest. It's especially true during election years. More anti-India activities in the neighborhood mean more votes for BJP. If you see, the BNP is not even hurting or targeting the big businesses that are allies of the BJP, like the ADANI or TATA group. BNP targets smaller groups producing toothpaste, hair oils, etc., but enough to get anti-India publicity.
Finally, this campaign is not against the Hasina regime, and the Hasina regime pays a huge amount of money to ADANI groups to keep BJP in line while maintaining a powerful China connection. So, it will also help Hasina to show the Chinese that she is not stopping this anti-India campaign but allowing it to continue. Do you think you can still openly make "Boycott India" videos in Dhaka if Hasina's intel agencies and Police / RAB want to stop it? This campaign benefits Hasina, too.
It looks world and regional politics is much more complicated than common folks can ever imagine! What a nice way to appease both China and India together! Only if BNP ( under zia family) understood that voters are nothing but puppets, they ( BNP) wouldn't have made wrong decisions based on their voter base! The result is , I think they ( or maybe just Zia family) are forever kicked out from politics!

It's clear that Khaleda zia was never a real politician! She should have understood that it's not the voters, but deep state of Bangladesh allowed her to become prime minister 3 times!

So where democracy actually stands in these countries ; specially in South Asia? From a political analyst Gautam das ( Bangladeshi) I heard ( from his talk show , he isn't very famous though among common Bangladeshi folks) that 69 and 90 were both plotted!

However @Old School bhai , I think India also does have a deep state? What say you?
 
Last edited:
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Fact Check Respond
  • Like (+1)
Reactions: Old School
However @Old School bhai , I think India also does have a deep state? What say you?
I know Gautam Das, but he misses the crucial details. He works with the Chinese, though. Old KGB files revealed that the KGB funded both Mujib and Bhutto with Soviet oil money during the 1970 election. Major Dalim described in detail how his "Sena Parishad" group made Khaleda Zia win the 1991 election.
Deep states have existed in every state since ancient times. They are a nexus between the oligarchs and the civil-military bureaucracy. Textbooks don’t discuss this aspect of the state because the deep state controls what goes into them. The same goes for the media.
Indian biggest businesses, such as Adani, Tata, Ambani, etc., have long working relationships with their bureaucracy. This nexus is more powerful than any political party. Naive people mistakenly believe that poor and ordinary people elect the government.
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Fact Check Respond
  • Like (+1)
Reactions: Vikings
I know Gautam Das, but he misses the crucial details. He works with the Chinese, though. Old KGB files revealed that the KGB funded both Mujib and Bhutto with Soviet oil money during the 1970 election. Major Dalim described in detail how his "Sena Parishad" group made Khaleda Zia win the 1991 election.
Yes understood! Thanks for the information!


Deep states have existed in every state since ancient times. They are a nexus between the oligarchs and the civil-military bureaucracy. Textbooks don’t discuss this aspect of the state because the deep state controls what goes into them. The same goes for the media.
Indian biggest businesses, such as Adani, Tata, Ambani, etc., have long working relationships with their bureaucracy. This nexus is more powerful than any political party. Naive people mistakenly believe that poor and ordinary people elect the government.
Since deep state existed from ancient times , so I think India deep state wants BJP to stay in power for longer period of times? Could it be the reason that Pinaki and BNP is triggering Indian people by this boycott drama in Bangladesh to agitate Indian people for purpose? So that BJP win again because they need to defend Bharat?

If that's the case , then I'm not sure what's waiting in future for neighbours of India!

Although they aren't nearly as powerful ( militarily ) as they pretend, but they have deep pockets and lots of oligarchs who are listed among world's top billionaires!

However I think China want stability, hence Bangladesh will not meet the fate of sikkim or Hyderabad! What say you @Old School bhai?

Honestly speaking sometimes my rational mind doesn't work and I fear that India may try to devour Bangladesh; at least a part of Bangladesh, if not fully!

I think their target is Rangpur division! Because it will strengthen their chicken neck!
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Fact Check Respond
  • Like (+1)
Reactions: Old School
Yes understood! Thanks for the information!



Since deep state existed from ancient times , so I think India deep state wants BJP to stay in power for longer period of times? Could it be the reason that Pinaki and BNP is triggering Indian people by this boycott drama in Bangladesh to agitate Indian people for purpose? So that BJP win again because they need to defend Bharat?

If that's the case , then I'm not sure what's waiting in future for neighbours of India!

Although they aren't nearly as powerful ( militarily ) as they pretend, but they have deep pockets and lots of oligarchs who are listed among world's top billionaires!

However I think China want stability, hence Bangladesh will not meet the fate of sikkim or Hyderabad! What say you @Old School bhai?

Honestly speaking sometimes my rational mind doesn't work and I fear that India may try to devour Bangladesh; at least a part of Bangladesh, if not fully!

I think their target is Rangpur division! Because it will strengthen their chicken neck!

No country wants to burden an additional 180 million people by annexing Bangladesh if they can squeeze out the benefits some other way. Bengalis have nothing to worry about suffering the fate of Sikim or Hyderabad, which were not the same things. India is already a very large country anyway.

Chicken Neck has no military significance because there is no physical wall there saying the Indian army can not enter nearby Bangladesh to defend their territory. I am sure that Indians will manage to get military transit to that area over Bangladesh by mutual agreement. Otherwise, they will use the transit without permission anyway. People who talk about this so-called "Chicken Neck" did not attend a good military college. China and India are both Nuclear power and they are unlikely to go to war. India is a big Chinese market too.

However, Pakistan is another story. It is the birthplace of Hinduism and the Indus civilization, and therefore, Indians have a different approach to Pakistan. We are also the gateway to the Middle East and Central Asia since we have cut off The Wakhan Corridor bordering Gilgit-Baltistan from Indian-occupied Kashmir. Indians are upset about this huge strategic loss. There are other ideological issues, too. Hence, we need a powerful deterrent strategy towards Indian expansionism as far as Pakistan is concerned.
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Fact Check Respond
  • Like (+1)
Reactions: Vikings

Members Online

⤵︎

Latest Posts

Latest Posts