| Global Defense, OSINT & Geopolitics Wire

[🇧🇩] Press Freedom in Bangladesh

[🇧🇩] Press Freedom in Bangladesh
85
5K
More threads by Saif

G Bangladesh Defense

Has the media gotten out of the grip of (self-)censorship?

1732840608115.webp

File Illustration: Biplob Chakroborty

In Bangladesh, the stories citizens read are often shaped not by journalistic choice alone but by an invisible force—censorship. Whether imposed directly by government actions or adopted defensively by journalists, this practice casts a long shadow over press freedom. Its roots lie in the country's legal and political framework, where repressive laws and political pressures compel journalists to avoid sensitive issues that might provoke legal repercussions or retaliation. This dynamic creates a delicate dance between journalists and the government, in which the former treads carefully so as not to cross the invisible line.

Since the regime change on August 5, 2024, there has been a surge in legal cases and intimidation against media outlets, amplifying fears and deepening the grip of self-censorship. Despite Dr Muhammad Yunus's stated commitment to press freedom, actions like the cancellation of press credentials and the incarceration of journalists send troubling signals, leaving media freedom in Bangladesh at a perilous crossroads.

The constitution of Bangladesh promises freedom of thought, conscience, and expression, alongside press rights under Articles 39(1) and 39(2), with caveats of "reasonable restrictions" for national security, public order, and morality—vague terms often misused by authorities to limit dissent and critical journalism. In addition to the constitution, the Press Council Act of 1974 supports press freedom and upholds journalistic integrity. Yet, the effectiveness of this Act is limited, and it lacks the enforcement muscle to shield journalists from legal and extra-legal threats.

For years, successive governments in Bangladesh have wielded repressive laws to penalise speech deemed, in their broad understanding, to be false, offensive, defamatory, or disruptive to law and order. Among the earliest and most contentious of these laws is the Special Powers Act of 1974, which established far-reaching state censorship by criminalising vaguely defined "prejudicial" content. This Act, and others like it, have been routinely exploited to silence dissenting voices and restrict the media's ability to report freely. Its impact is particularly alarming for two reasons: the government's expansive interpretation of what qualifies as "prejudicial" and the troubling conflation of legitimate criticism with threats to national security. These dynamics have allowed the Act to become a powerful tool for suppressing opposing views, undermining the free exchange of ideas that a vibrant democracy requires.

Subsequent laws, including the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Act, the Digital Security Act (DSA), and the Cyber Security Act (CSA), have continued this trend. Notorious provisions like Section 57 of the ICT Act penalised digital content deemed defamatory or religiously offensive with harsh sentences, fostering a culture of fear. Subsequently, the DSA of 2018 was enacted in response to public outcry over the ICT Act, while the CSA of 2023 followed as a reaction to international criticism of the DSA. Each of these laws has drawn criticism for pulling similar language from Section 57 of the ICT Act and repackaging it to retain authoritarian control over freedom of expression under broad pretexts like defamation, "negative propaganda," or hurting religious sentiments. Hundreds of arrests were made under this never-ending cycle of repressive laws, leading to accusations that the DSA (and then CSA) was used to silence dissent and discourage investigative journalism.

Since the fall of the past regime, the sacking of journalists for reportedly being linked with the previous government, without concrete criminal charges having been brought against them, is unsettling to say the least. Most recently, the government rescinded the press accreditation of numerous journalists, effectively restricting their access to government secretariats. Previously, the ICT Adviser Nahid Islam had, on several occasions, suggested that journalists could be prosecuted and punished due to their possible nexus with the erstwhile regime. The press secretary, Shafiqul Alam, gave a similar vague message. The cancellation of press passes and the administration's statement against journalists sends an ambiguous message: while the government maintains that it supports press freedom and expresses its willingness to repeal the draconian laws, its words and actions may pressure the media to cautiously choose its contents and stories.

It is important to mention that journalists are held to high professional and ethical standards and must uphold truth and accuracy in news reporting. The current legal framework, such as the 1993 Journalists' Code of Conduct, provides a grievance procedure if journalists breach their duties. The Code prohibits maliciously distorting or slanting news in commentary and headlines, requiring clear and fair presentation without bias. Newspapers are also expected to resist and expose crime and corruption. If any newspaper, news agency, editor, or journalist breaches journalistic ethics and codes of conduct, the Press Council, under Section 12(1) of the Press Council Act of 1974, may investigate complaints and warn, admonish, and rebuke the concerned parties after giving them an opportunity to be heard. There are legal recourse available in the existing Press Council Act and the Journalists' Code of Conduct.

The persecution of journalists without any specific allegations have attracted criticism from local and international quarters, raising alarms over the actual extent of media freedom in the country. Antoine Bernard of Reporters Without Borders called on the government to "stop the current legal harassment of more than 130 journalists" who have been charged with trumped-up crimes, as well as the arrest of some journalists without prior investigations. The Committee to Protect Journalists called for guaranteeing the procedural rights of incarcerated journalists.

The interim government's stated objective to right past wrongs and implement reform seems to be out of step with the continued plight of the media landscape in Bangladesh. The gap between the government's declared goals and the actual circumstances raises serious concerns about the current state and future trends of media independence. It may also thwart the goals of the Public Media Reform Commission, which is currently undertaking the job of furthering press freedom in Bangladesh.

Protests in July and August have flagged one of the most severe failures of the media in maintaining neutrality in times of crisis, yet similar patterns of media restrictions persist. If Bangladesh is to break out of this cycle where news outlets act primarily as a mouthpiece for the government, changes must extend beyond cosmetic promises. The interim government now has an opportunity and a corresponding responsibility to show real commitment to freedom of the press, which it can do by letting the Media Reform Commission work independently and by taking tangible steps that create an atmosphere where journalists can work without fear of retribution.

Failing to pursue these fundamental reforms at this critical moment would perpetuate the past practice of media suppression and drastically reduce public expectations of meaningful democratic change. The stakes are particularly high, given Bangladesh's history of political volatility and the critical role a free press must play in guaranteeing governmental accountability and fostering robust public debate.

Sangita Gazi is a postdoctoral research scholar at The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania.​
 

There should be no interference in press freedom: Zonayed Saki
Staff Correspondent
Chattogram
Published: 29 Nov 2024, 23: 03

1732930444307.webp

Ganosamhati Andolan chief coordinator Zonayed Saki addresses as the chief guest at a mass dialogue at CRB Ground in Chattogram on 29 November 2024Prothom Alo

Ganosamhati Andolan chief coordinator Zonayed Saki on Friday said there should be no interference in the press freedom, people’s thinking, conscience and right to opinion.

“There should be no interference in the freedom of press, people’s thinking, conscience and right to opinion. Criticise the newspaper, everyone has that right. But attacking the newspaper office or something like that creates a perception around the world as if there is no press freedom in this country. This won’t bode well for us,” warned Zonayed Saki.

He was speaking as the chief guest at a mass dialogue at CRB Ground in Chattogram in the afternoon.

Chattogram unit of Ganosamhati Andolan organised the dialogue titled “Mass dialogue to establish a new political settlement for democratic transformation of the state”.

Over 500 leaders and activists of the party from Chattogram, Feni and other districts and upazilas attended the event.

Speaking about the killing of a lawyer in Chattogram, Saki said, “Saiful Islam was killed in a planned way. The Awami League and ISKCON men under the banner of ISKCON killed him. The banner of ISKCON was used so that the blame goes to the people of the Hindu community and the Muslims carry out attacks out of grievances, and they could send the photographs to the US.”

He stated, “We saw acclaimed media like Reuters carried a report that said the lawyer of Chinmoy Das has been killed. This is their plan. The image of Bangladesh is being presented to the western countries in such a way that the Hindus, Buddhists, Christians and other communities are not safe here.”

Expressing that staying in India, Sheikh Hasina has been conspiring to destroy Bangladesh, Zonayed Saki said, “You have thwarted their plot. You did not let any attack be carried out in Chattogram. As no attack is being carried out, the Awami League activists themselves are attacking the people of Hindu community now. I have heard there was an attempt to carry out an attack even today (Friday). That is why we need to forge a united measure to prevent those. Those who would attack the people of Hindu community are aides of the fascist and agents of local and foreign plotters. They want to destroy the uprising in Bangladesh and this government.”

Zonayed Saki contends there could be such elements within the government too, since many of their aides are still there hiding in various departments. They have to be identified and brought to book.

Mentioning the people as the centre of power, the Ganosamhati Andolan chief coordinator said there should be laws to ensure accountability of the people’s representatives to the people. For this there has to be the constitution and laws. Article 70 of the existing constitution has to be amended. Only the government will not appoint people in the constitutional posts. Instead, the governing party, the opposition and the judiciary will appoint their representatives, so that no partisan person could be appointed there. The judiciary must be made independent.

Indicating the government, Zonayed Saki said, “Maybe the interim government could not perform up to the people’s expected level as of now, we are criticising the government for that. Despite that, this interim government has been trying to carry out its responsibilities aligning with the interests of the people. We will criticise them and at the same time help them. A democratic constitution, reforms of the state and its laws and democratic elections are required for a new political settlement.”

He called on everyone to be united to form such a democratic force.

The dialogue was chaired by Ganosamhati Andolan’s Chattogram district unit coordinator Hasan Maruf.

Other speakers at the event also put emphasis on unity to work so that no autocratic force could usurp power in the new Bangladesh achieved through a mass-uprising.​
 

Environment for free expression must: Matiur Rahman


1733272009713.png
​

Photo: Collected

Prothom Alo Editor Matiur Rahman today said many reforms have to be made in the administration.

Matiur made the remarks as a guest speaker at an award ceremony held in honour of the late Professor Sitara Parveen of the Department of Mass Communication and Journalism at Dhaka University.

And to be successful in state affairs, there should be an open democratic environment and free expression throughout the society, he added.

There must be more open discussions on all important state issues.

"We have to work for journalism with courage from an independent and non-partisan position," Matiur said.

The event took place at the Professor Muzaffar Ahmed Chowdhury Auditorium in the Faculty of Social Sciences.

DU Vice-Chancellor Prof Dr Niaz Ahmed Khan paid glowing tribute to the memory of Prof Dr Sitara Parvin.

A total of 10 meritorious students of the Department of Mass Communication and Journalism of DU were recognised with the Prof Sitara Parvin Award for their outstanding results in BSS (Hons) final examination of 2022.

Prof Dr Sitara Parvin, daughter of former President Justice Shahabuddin Ahmed and wife of retired Journalism Prof Dr Ahaduzzaman Mohammad Ali, died in a tragic road accident on June 23, 2005 in the US.​
 

Reduce VAT on newsprint, ensure press freedom
Noab urges Media Reform Commission

1733876563001.webp


Members of Newspaper Owners' Association of Bangladesh (Noab) yesterday met the Media Reform Commission and spoke for press freedom, independent journalism, and reduction of VAT on newsprint.

During a views-exchange meeting with the commission, they demanded the necessary reforms in the Bangladesh Press Council and Department of Films and Publications (DFP) and underscored the necessity of lessening politicisation in newspaper ownership.

Kamal Ahmed, chief of the commission, stressed that the media should be free from any political influence so that they can work for the interest of the people.

He underlined the need for media free from political influence given the grievance expressed over the failure and controversial role of many media during the July-August uprising.

The meeting was held at the office of Noab President AK Azad.

"We don't have the environment for independent media due to the existing legal framework for the media," said a press release of the commission, quoting Mahfuz Anam, The Daily Star editor and publisher, as saying.

Prothom Alo Editor and Publisher Matiur Rahman said the newspaper industry became sick in this digital era. Besides, circulation of newspapers and the income from advertisement dropped sharply due to the Covid-19 pandemic.

Mentioning that the previous governments tried to control the media, he said, "No governments in the past allowed media freedom and journalists could not work independently."

However, the previous government considered newspapers as its enemy, he said.

New Age Publisher Shahidullah Khan questioned the necessity of the enlistment of media outlets. He said the Press Council should be modernised and kept free from any influence of the executive.

Urging the commission to be careful so that no vested quarters can misguide them, Bonik Barta Editor and Publisher Dewan Hanif Mahmud criticised filing of cases against editors and journalists and the revocation of accreditation cards of journalists.

AK Azad, also the publisher of daily Samakal, said they, as publishers, had to face threats and incur financial loss. Except for the newspaper industry, all other industries got incentives during the Covid-19 pandemic, he said.

He also hoped that the Media Reform Commission would place specific recommendations for the independence of editors.

During the meeting, Kamal said there is no way that the commission would be influenced by any vested quarters, and that they would submit recommendations based on the opinions of stakeholders.

He added that the commission would seek opinions from all stakeholders to prepare guidelines for the state-run Bangladesh Betar, BTV, and Bangladesh Sangbad Sangstha (BSS).

Daily Sangbad Editor Altamash Kabir and daily Financial Herald Publisher Masrur Reza also spoke at the meeting attended by other members of the commission.​
 

Student protesters entered Somoy TV owner’s offices, journos sacked

1735088615678.webp


A gang of Bangladesh student protesters entered the offices of the investor of a television station, accusing it of "propaganda", protesters said yesterday, with at least five journalists subsequently fired.

The students had taken part in the August revolution that toppled prime minister Sheikh Hasina, whose tenure was marked as one of the worst periods for media freedom.

Hasnat Abdullah, convener of the Anti-Discrimination Students Movement, led around 15 to 20 students on December 17 to the offices of City Group, which invests in Somoy Television.

"Somoy Television was spreading propaganda, twisting my comments, and accommodating the views of a fallen political party," Hasnat told AFP.

"We are staunch supporters of press freedom, but the press must remain unbiased," Hasnat said, adding that he saw no issue in making demands -- but rejecting reports that the students had handed over a list of those they wanted to be fired.

The managing director of the business conglomerate that funds the television station did not respond to repeated requests for comment.

The incident has intensified fear among journalists in the wake of the revolution.

One journalist, Omar Faroque, who had been a senior editor of the television station, said he was among the five who received a termination letter without reason.

"The television authorities requested a few of us to step down for the greater good of the station," Faroque told AFP.

"We demanded an explanation for the decision, but the authorities refused to provide any."

Chief Adviser Prof Muhammad Yunus has repeatedly insisted he wants media freedom.

CA's Press Secretary Shafiqul Alam sought to distance the government, saying that if someone "takes any action, the responsibility lies with them".

Press watchdogs say many journalists -- seen by critics as having supported Hasina when she was in power -- face police investigations in apparent retaliation for their past work.

At least four journalists were imprisoned, and scores are facing legal cases across the country.

Hasina and her government were frequently accused of exerting undue pressure on the handful of independent media outlets, including shutting down newspapers and TV channels and imprisoning journalists.

After Hasina's government fell, several TV channels, including Somoy TV, came under attack for their alleged allegiance to her Awami League.

In November, protesters besieged the offices of Prothom Alo, the largest Bangla-language newspaper, and threatened to shut it down, as well as The Daily Star.

Press freedom in Bangladesh has long been under threat.

Bangladesh ranks 165 out of 180 countries in press freedom, according to Reporters Without Borders.​