General Whatever

[Sharma Ji]

I am not trying to convert you. Even remotely.

If Hindus are happy voting for BJP, knock yourselves out.

I can't speak for the collective, but alag alag motivations hoti hain logon ki behind why they might support or oppose a party.

Not a Hindu rashtra guy here, we already live in one.. codifying this xhit runs against my dharmi philosophical grain.

 

[Vsdoc]

India is definitely a Hindu nation. What is the identity of India?

Not really.

Even as recently as a thousand years ago, there was a Hindu Renaissance ... revival ... which is a pseudonym for a brutal crushing and killing off of Buddhism across India.

 

[Sharma Ji]

India is definitely a Hindu nation. What is the identity of India?

Maal sabko pata hai kya hai, fir chepi ki kya zaroorat.. ?

right ?

 

[Vsdoc]

Because you talked about temples.

It was in response to Sharma's post.

No post is made in a vacuum. Do follow the entire trail.

 

[Sharma Ji]

Even as recently as a thousand years ago

just the other day, right ?

 

[Vsdoc]

just the other day, right ?

Just putting perspective to the assertion that India is a Hindu nation.

 

[Vsdoc]

just the other day, right ?

And its a lot more recent to say Iran being a Muslim nation.

 

[Sharma Ji]

And its a lot more recent to say Iran being a Muslim nation.

How old is the dharm, Doc ?

Gooble AI sez:

pinpointing its exact age is difficult as it has evolved over millennia through various cultural and historical influences. Some scholars estimate its age to be over 5,000 years, while others believe it to be even older.

Wendy Doniger sez:

According to Doniger, Hinduism may have roots in pre-historic (pre-textual, pre-Vedic) Mesolithic prehistoric religion, such as evidenced in the rock paintings of Bhimbetka rock shelters, which are about 10,000 years old ( c. 8,000 BCE), as well as Neolithic times.
------------------------------------------------------------

who's to say ?

online bhot charcha hai is vishay par.

old as fvk is all I know

weathered many a tempest, has the 'eternal way'

codified nahi hai

atheism, agnosticism, skepticism to extreme ritualism, sab kuch hai

hot topic beef ko le ke bhi debate hai, cow vs bull.. kaun hai asli holy ?

complicated scene hai, Doc.. we don't do this haram vs halal black and white binary bs