| Global Defense, OSINT & Geopolitics Wire

[🇧🇩] International Crimes Tribunal Act & The Crimes Against Humanity

[🇧🇩] International Crimes Tribunal Act & The Crimes Against Humanity
110
5K
More threads by Saif

G Bangladesh Defense

Sheikh Hasina regime: trials and tribulations
by Zaki Omar 06 November, 2024, 00:00

1730943477685.webp

International Criminal Court. | Human Rights Watch

AS THE world looked on in utter horror, the brutality of the Sheikh Hasina regime unfolded with unbridled extremes, reaching its peak intensity in the second half of July 2024. By the end of July, the unabated murders, tortures, enforced disappearances and imprisonments had reached a stage unseen or unheard of since the days of the Pakistani army’s brutal occupation in 1971. As an international human rights lawyer from Bangladesh, I could no longer remain a mere observer. I rang my friend and former colleague Ms Alison Battisson, the best international human rights lawyer that I know in Australia, and we decided to lodge an urgent communique with the Office of the Prosecutor at the International Criminal Court on August 1, 2024.

Almost 12 weeks on, the scenario has changed drastically. Hasina has fled the country, and the interim government is juggling multiple challenges while striving to get state machinery back in sustainable order. Of significant relevance to this article, which will hopefully reach the attention of the chief adviser Professor Muhammad Yunus, the interim government has also appointed a chief prosecutor with a view to prosecuting perpetrators of the Hasina regime in the International Crimes Tribunal of Bangladesh.

While being fully respectful of the wishes and sentiments of all concerned to conduct trials of the Hasina regime in Bangladesh for the heinous crimes against humanity, this author requests the interim government to consider referring the Hasina regime’s crimes against humanity to the Office of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court for reasons including the following:

Firstly, investigation and trial by prosecutors at the ICC will attract a lot more international credibility than that of an ICT in Bangladesh. This is not to undermine the quality or prudence of our capable law officers; however, the foundational framework of the ICT has caused concerns amongst human rights groups in the past both in terms of its substantive and procedural aspects. For example, inclusion of the death penalty, offences not being delineated with sufficient clarity, perceived lack of due process for rights of accused, and prohibition in Article 47A of our constitution against right of judicial review have not only made the ICT susceptible under international standards of best practices but also require constitutional refurbishments not within the purview of the current interim government.

Secondly, the investigation and fact-finding in the age of video, audio and electronic evidence will greatly benefit from the resources and expertise of the ICC prosecutors and relevant United Nations bodies. Human Rights Watch has proposed to our interim government to present, or support the adoption of, a resolution at the United Nations Human Rights Council that establishes a UN-backed independent mechanism with a comprehensive mandate to investigate, collect, store, and analyse evidence and cooperate with credible and independent national and international bodies towards accountability in relation to the violent incidents of July and August 2024 and its root causes. The material scope of an investigation encompasses acts by all relevant actors, including but not limited to previous cases of enforced disappearances, extrajudicial killings and torture.

Thirdly, an ICC investigation will encompass all relevant actors of the Hasina regime in their involvement in crimes against humanity in Bangladesh. This will provide further credence and credibility to the interim government in its aspired role of impartiality and accountability while being steadfastly committed to the cause of justice. It will negate fear of cherry-picking of accused, or worse, a vengeful political witch-hunting exercise. As it stands, the current attorney general of Bangladesh has been a senior office bearer of the Bangladesh Nationalist Party until the day of his appointment; his additional attorney generals are all known as pro-BNP lawyers. I have personally known them as lawyers of excellent credentials and experiences; however, the fact that they are aligned with a political party at the receiving end of brutal oppression by the Hasina regime for 15 years causes concerns regarding perceived bias. The chief prosecutor of the ICT was not only the defence counsel for the Jamaat-e-Islami leaders who were previously tried in the ICT, he also served as junior counsel of the former assistant secretary general of the Jamaat-e-Islami who led the defence counsel team. We need to heed the old adage that justice must not only be done, it must also be seen to be done.

Fourthly, Sheikh Hasina is currently in India under state protection. The extradition treaty between India and Bangladesh puts an onus on India to extradite Hasina to Bangladesh under prescribed circumstances, unless the extradition is not requested ‘in good faith’ or will not serve ‘interests of justice’. For the reasons enumerated above, it will be wise to refer Hasina and her regime to the jurisdiction of the ICC and negate the possibility of India citing lack of good faith or interests of justice in order to refuse extradition, or worse, granting her a permanent political asylum for those reasons.

Fifthly, the ICC referral process may present itself as a great opportunity to establish a sound and credible factual archive of crimes committed by the fascist Hasina regime for historical records. It will pave the way to form a Truth and Reconciliation Commission without judicial powers to be mandated by the ICC and supported by our local and ICC investigators, UN experts and international human rights organisations to collect, verify, collate and archive evidence of atrocities committed by the Hasina regime. This will not only pave the way for historical evidence for future generations but will also facilitate eventual reconciliation of deep political divides that permeate our society at large. The body of evidence thus gathered and verified can then be utilised by the prosecutors at the ICC to further its prosecution of alleged perpetrators.

Karim Khan KC, the chief prosecutor at the ICC, has met chief adviser Professor Muhammad Yunus and expressed his willingness to cooperate with the interim government. However, the ICC at this stage is unlikely to proceed with its investigation into crimes against humanity perpetrated by the Hasina regime unless voluntarily referred to by the interim government while holding its domestic investigations or prosecutions in abeyance. Because of the issue of admissibility under the Rome Statute by which it is governed, the ICC will not assume jurisdiction in cases where the relevant member state is investigating or prosecuting the alleged perpetrators under its own domestic laws. However, for the sake of international credibility and eventual healing of the deepening fault lines of historical animosity that have divided us since independence, an impartial international conduct of trials by ICC prosecutors at this juncture may well be the most prudent way forward.

Zaki Omar is an international human rights lawyer based in Australia.​
 

Want to leave culture of filing wholesale cases behind: Asif Nazrul

1731454400056.webp

Prof Asif Nazrul

Law Affairs Adviser Asif Nazrul today said the government wants to come out of the culture of filing wholesale cases.

"We want to establish true justice. We want to get out of the culture of filing wholesale cases, using the judiciary to harass people, destroying people's livelihoods, and creating continuous grievances, anger, and discord among people," he said while addressing the judges of the High Court Division.

"People come to the judges asking for justice. They [judges] feel embarrassed. Why do you feel embarrassed? The people seeking justice have come to you after finding no justice elsewhere. How can you feel embarrassed?" he asked.

"You felt embarrassed to accept the appeal of the current Chief Advisor Dr Yunus. Why did you feel that way? Isn't this your duty? Isn't it your constitutional duty? You can listen [hold hearing] and reject it. That's not a problem. Your reputation has been tarnished by some judges," added Asif Nazrul.

"Don't say these things anymore. People are not fools," he also said.

"The fascist government started the culture of false and wholecase cases ... Many have been subjected to that," he added.​
 

It’s embarrassing for the govt
Says Asif Nazrul

1731454495341.webp


Law Adviser Asif Nazrul yesterday said common people, particularly the political victims and rivals, are still filing wholesale cases against others since August 5, which is embarrassing for the current government.

"During the regime of the fascist government, ghost cases were filed against people. The then government itself used to file such cases," the adviser said.

"Our government is not filing such cases," he said.

Asif Nazrul made the remarks while talking to reporters after a meeting with the members of the judiciary reform commission at the Judicial Administration Training Institute (JATI) in the capital.

Asif Nazrul said he requested the members of the judiciary reform commission to provide suggestions to the government regarding how to deal with this crisis.

He also said the interim government is working to formulate a law for the appointment of High Court judges.

In 2008, an initiative was taken to make a law for the appointment of HC judges, but it was cancelled during the Awami League's regime.

At the meeting, Asif Nazrul appreciated the progress of the judiciary reform commission's activities.

He said the government is optimistic about the commission's way of working despite limitations.

Members of the commission, including its chief, Justice Shah Abu Nayeem Mominur Rahman, were present at the meeting.​
 

Limon sues Tarique Siddique, Ziaul Ahsan
United News of Bangladesh . Dhaka 13 November, 2024, 00:46

1731457606049.webp

Limon Hossain. | New Age photo.

Limon Hossain, a resident of Jhalakati who lost his leg after being shot by the Rapid Action Battalion, has filed a complaint with the International Crimes Tribunal against nine individuals, including Sheikh Hasina’s former military adviser Tarique Ahmed Siddique and former RAB officer Ziaul Ahsan.

Limon filed the complaint on Tuesday at the office of the tribunal’s chief prosecutor.

Speaking to reporters, he stated that under the fascist Sheikh Hasina government, he was denied justice. In the hope of justice, he filed the complaint with the ICT.

Chief prosecutor Mohammad Tazul Islam informed reporters that multiple complaints were received against Ziaul Ahsan, former director-general of the National Telecommunication Monitoring Centre. Investigators had found evidence linking him to numerous killings and disappearances.

Ziaul Ahsan is currently under arrest on a tribunal order, and permission has been granted for a one-day interrogation.

Limon, son of Tofazzel Hossain from Saturia village in Rajapur, Jhalakathi, was injured in 2011 when he was shot by RAB while retrieving cattle near his home. Due to inadequate treatment, his left leg had to be amputated below the knee, leaving him permanently disabled.​
 

ICT seeks red notice for Hasina’s arrest
Chief prosecutor’s office writes to Interpol through IGP

1731547387475.webp

File photo

The chief prosecutor of the International Crimes Tribunal has sought an Interpol red notice for the arrest of former prime minister Sheikh Hasina.

Chief Prosecutor Chief Prosecutor Tajul Islam's office on Sunday wrote to the Interpol through the inspector general of police (IGP).

Hasina is accused of committing crimes against humanity and she is a fugitive, he told reporters in front of his office yesterday, adding that the IGP would forward the letter to the international organisation which facilitates worldwide police cooperation.

"There is an arrest warrant for her [in Bangladesh]…. We requested Interpol to arrest her or at least issue a red notice," he said.

A red notice is a request to law enforcement worldwide to locate and provisionally arrest a person pending extradition, surrender, or similar legal action, according to the Interpol website.

Over 100 complaints of crimes against humanity have been filed against Hasina, said prosecutors.

Tajul said the tribunal also issued arrest warrants for four absconding police officers on charges of committing atrocities in the capital's Jatrabari during the mass uprising.

"Journalists and citizens filmed how a young man, injured in the leg, was rescued by his colleague and was being taken away, when Zakir Hossain, then officer-in-charge of Jatrabari Police Station, went close to them and shot him in the chest to ensure his death," he said.

The tribunal has also granted permission to the prosecutors to interrogate Maj Gen (sacked) Ziaul Ahsan, now in jail, for a day.

The three-judge panel of the ICT led by Justice Md Golam Mortuza Mozumder gave the permission.

The date of Ziaul's interrogation will not be revealed for security concerns, he said.

"He was involved in numerous murders and enforced disappearances. The ICT probe body has evidence," he said.​