0
 

General Whatever

Reply
Press space to scroll through posts
G General
General Whatever
ghazi
8K
121K
More threads by ghazi

Naseeruddin Shah writes on Diljit Dosanjh controversy: I feel no need to prove anything, including my patriotism​

The touchiness of the offence-taking brigade has begun bordering on the absurd. Anything that is remotely critical gets twisted to sound “anti-national”. The palpable poison in the air does not cause me despair or fear. It saddens me​

Actor Naseeruddin Shah and Actor-pop star Diljit Dosanjh. (Express Archives)
The gradually rising tide of jingoism, hatred and, of late, war fever here, cannot but have encouraged all “right” minded citizens to no longer bother disguising the bigotry that has been latent in them all along
Shah.jpg

Naseeruddin Shah
Jul 4, 2025 13:23 IST
  • share-btn

    Share
  • comment-btn

    Comments
My childhood — and upbringing — was divided between an orthodox Muslim home, a Roman Catholic, and then a Jesuit Christian school. Each ethos gave me what it could, but I was never sold on any of them and I knew what I liked or disliked about each, my own included. For example, I thought it grossly unfair that everyone “except us” was doomed to perdition and I have never been able to get my head around that. As children, we went to Pushkar, to the magnificent Jain temple and, of course, the dargah where dreadlocked sadhus in saffron shared a chillum with green-robed Sufis; Sikh pilgrims and Hindu pilgrims abounded.

Namaaz in the Adhai Din Ka Jhonpda surrounded by Hindu sculptures I thought was the coolest idea. The great Shankar Shambhu sang the praises of “Khwaja ji” accompanied by qawwals from all over the sub-continent, and even by a Baul singer. I never thought of myself as a Muslim (ergo different) and nothing in my surroundings made me feel I didn’t belong, no matter where I was. This was my country and I miss it.

Advertisement

The gradually rising tide of jingoism, hatred and, of late, war fever here, cannot but have encouraged all “right” minded citizens to no longer bother disguising the bigotry that has been latent in them all along. At the same time, it has been cause for concern for those who worry about the direction in which our country seems to be headed. The touchiness of the offence-taking brigade has begun bordering on the absurd. Criticising the quality of Hindi movies makes you “ungrateful”, a plea for sanity and brotherhood makes you “a traitor”, a grouse that Indians don’t obey traffic lights makes you get advised on where you should go, speaking up for a fellow artiste is “speaking against the country”.

Anything that is remotely critical gets twisted to sound “anti-national”. The actor who plays the lead in the beloved TV serial Anupamaa tartly enquires whether Pakistan “allows Indian artistes to perform there?” without knowing that not only do they allow us, they welcome us and honour us. And then is everyone who listens to Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan or Mehdi Hasan or Farida Khanum in India a traitor? Obviously, it’s only the Prime Minister who can go across the border to embrace his counterpart. For us ordinary mortals to do that is a sin. Is it in any way beneficial to us to hate every Pakistani citizen for what their government (read, army) does? Or, does it simply satisfy some feral urge?

In George Orwell’s book 1984, there exists a daily ritual where everyone drops whatever they are doing and abuses an Opposition leader: It is compulsory to participate in this “two minutes of hate”. Despite it having now become 24 hours of hate, no longer confined to the leader of the Opposition, the palpable poison in the air does not cause me despair or fear. It saddens me. Hatred is self-destructive but evidently it can be sustained indefinitely if one is to go by the continuing actions of some “cow vigilantes”.

Story continues below this ad

Besides, new hatreds can easily be created. I am an easy target for “nationalists” and paid trolls (who really could do with some help in spelling and grammar) because I feel no need to wear my love for anything, including my country, on my sleeve. I know what I feel, I trust my feelings and they are no one else’s business.

I was born in India into the fifth generation of a Muslim family, my wife into an even older Hindu one and we hope our children can be a combination of the best of both. My father refused to go to Pakistan when his brothers left, he was certain India had a future for us just as I feel it does for my offspring. This is a dream that cannot be abandoned.

If this is taken to be a justification of my Facebook post (which has been taken down, not deleted by me) in support of Diljit Dosanjh, so be it. But the fact is I need to justify nothing. I said whatever I had to say and I stand by it. Nor am I discouraged by the lack of support from the film industry. I wasn’t expecting any — they all either have too much to lose or they disagree. And to the trolls, particularly the one who said to me “Pakistan nahin ab kabristaan”, I can only quote Jigar Moradabadi: “Mujhe de na ghaiz mein dhamkiyaan, giren lakh baar ye bijliyan, / Meri saltanat yehi aashiyaan, meri milkiyat yehi chaar par (Don’t threaten me in anger, let lightning strike a thousand time/ My nest is my domain, these four feathers all I own).”

The writer is an actor and author

Source: https://indianexpress.com/article/o...it-dosanjh-sardaar-ji-3-controversy-10105624/
 
Vsdoc said:

Naseeruddin Shah writes on Diljit Dosanjh controversy: I feel no need to prove anything, including my patriotism​

The touchiness of the offence-taking brigade has begun bordering on the absurd. Anything that is remotely critical gets twisted to sound “anti-national”. The palpable poison in the air does not cause me despair or fear. It saddens me​

Actor Naseeruddin Shah and Actor-pop star Diljit Dosanjh. (Express Archives)
The gradually rising tide of jingoism, hatred and, of late, war fever here, cannot but have encouraged all “right” minded citizens to no longer bother disguising the bigotry that has been latent in them all along
Shah.jpg

Naseeruddin Shah
Jul 4, 2025 13:23 IST
  • share-btn

    Share
  • comment-btn

    Comments
My childhood — and upbringing — was divided between an orthodox Muslim home, a Roman Catholic, and then a Jesuit Christian school. Each ethos gave me what it could, but I was never sold on any of them and I knew what I liked or disliked about each, my own included. For example, I thought it grossly unfair that everyone “except us” was doomed to perdition and I have never been able to get my head around that. As children, we went to Pushkar, to the magnificent Jain temple and, of course, the dargah where dreadlocked sadhus in saffron shared a chillum with green-robed Sufis; Sikh pilgrims and Hindu pilgrims abounded.

Namaaz in the Adhai Din Ka Jhonpda surrounded by Hindu sculptures I thought was the coolest idea. The great Shankar Shambhu sang the praises of “Khwaja ji” accompanied by qawwals from all over the sub-continent, and even by a Baul singer. I never thought of myself as a Muslim (ergo different) and nothing in my surroundings made me feel I didn’t belong, no matter where I was. This was my country and I miss it.

Advertisement

The gradually rising tide of jingoism, hatred and, of late, war fever here, cannot but have encouraged all “right” minded citizens to no longer bother disguising the bigotry that has been latent in them all along. At the same time, it has been cause for concern for those who worry about the direction in which our country seems to be headed. The touchiness of the offence-taking brigade has begun bordering on the absurd. Criticising the quality of Hindi movies makes you “ungrateful”, a plea for sanity and brotherhood makes you “a traitor”, a grouse that Indians don’t obey traffic lights makes you get advised on where you should go, speaking up for a fellow artiste is “speaking against the country”.

Anything that is remotely critical gets twisted to sound “anti-national”. The actor who plays the lead in the beloved TV serial Anupamaa tartly enquires whether Pakistan “allows Indian artistes to perform there?” without knowing that not only do they allow us, they welcome us and honour us. And then is everyone who listens to Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan or Mehdi Hasan or Farida Khanum in India a traitor? Obviously, it’s only the Prime Minister who can go across the border to embrace his counterpart. For us ordinary mortals to do that is a sin. Is it in any way beneficial to us to hate every Pakistani citizen for what their government (read, army) does? Or, does it simply satisfy some feral urge?

In George Orwell’s book 1984, there exists a daily ritual where everyone drops whatever they are doing and abuses an Opposition leader: It is compulsory to participate in this “two minutes of hate”. Despite it having now become 24 hours of hate, no longer confined to the leader of the Opposition, the palpable poison in the air does not cause me despair or fear. It saddens me. Hatred is self-destructive but evidently it can be sustained indefinitely if one is to go by the continuing actions of some “cow vigilantes”.

Story continues below this ad

Besides, new hatreds can easily be created. I am an easy target for “nationalists” and paid trolls (who really could do with some help in spelling and grammar) because I feel no need to wear my love for anything, including my country, on my sleeve. I know what I feel, I trust my feelings and they are no one else’s business.

I was born in India into the fifth generation of a Muslim family, my wife into an even older Hindu one and we hope our children can be a combination of the best of both. My father refused to go to Pakistan when his brothers left, he was certain India had a future for us just as I feel it does for my offspring. This is a dream that cannot be abandoned.

If this is taken to be a justification of my Facebook post (which has been taken down, not deleted by me) in support of Diljit Dosanjh, so be it. But the fact is I need to justify nothing. I said whatever I had to say and I stand by it. Nor am I discouraged by the lack of support from the film industry. I wasn’t expecting any — they all either have too much to lose or they disagree. And to the trolls, particularly the one who said to me “Pakistan nahin ab kabristaan”, I can only quote Jigar Moradabadi: “Mujhe de na ghaiz mein dhamkiyaan, giren lakh baar ye bijliyan, / Meri saltanat yehi aashiyaan, meri milkiyat yehi chaar par (Don’t threaten me in anger, let lightning strike a thousand time/ My nest is my domain, these four feathers all I own).”

The writer is an actor and author

Source: https://indianexpress.com/article/o...it-dosanjh-sardaar-ji-3-controversy-10105624/
Click to expand...

Like Javed Akhtar, he is a hidden Jihadi. YE BC ko jab Hindu o ko mara jata tha tab kuchha bura nahi dikha. When Hindus have just started questioning the injustice, this brigade shouts intolerance.
 
Krishna with Flute said:
Like Javed Akhtar, he is a hidden Jihadi. YE BC ko jab Hindu o ko mara jata tha tab kuchha bura nahi dikha. When Hindus have just started questioning the injustice, this brigade shouts intolerance.
Click to expand...

Valid point bhai.

But aaj kal ke mahaul mein, sab apni dekhte hain.

Sab. Hindus and Parsis included.

That's the sort of damage Modi and his brand of politics has done to our social fabric.
 
Vsdoc said:
Valid point bhai.

But aaj kal ke mahaul mein, sab apni dekhte hain.

Sab. Hindus and Parsis included.

That's the sort of damage Modi and his brand of politics has done to our social fabric.
Click to expand...

Not by Modi Brand politics. As the Sickulars are not able to defeat Modi, they starts abusing him. As if that was not enough, they started abusing nation and whosoever support Modi. Nationalist hit back and that is how the cycle begun.
 
Vsdoc said:

Naseeruddin Shah writes on Diljit Dosanjh controversy: I feel no need to prove anything, including my patriotism​

The touchiness of the offence-taking brigade has begun bordering on the absurd. Anything that is remotely critical gets twisted to sound “anti-national”. The palpable poison in the air does not cause me despair or fear. It saddens me​

Actor Naseeruddin Shah and Actor-pop star Diljit Dosanjh. (Express Archives)
The gradually rising tide of jingoism, hatred and, of late, war fever here, cannot but have encouraged all “right” minded citizens to no longer bother disguising the bigotry that has been latent in them all along
Shah.jpg

Naseeruddin Shah
Jul 4, 2025 13:23 IST
  • share-btn

    Share
  • comment-btn

    Comments
My childhood — and upbringing — was divided between an orthodox Muslim home, a Roman Catholic, and then a Jesuit Christian school. Each ethos gave me what it could, but I was never sold on any of them and I knew what I liked or disliked about each, my own included. For example, I thought it grossly unfair that everyone “except us” was doomed to perdition and I have never been able to get my head around that. As children, we went to Pushkar, to the magnificent Jain temple and, of course, the dargah where dreadlocked sadhus in saffron shared a chillum with green-robed Sufis; Sikh pilgrims and Hindu pilgrims abounded.

Namaaz in the Adhai Din Ka Jhonpda surrounded by Hindu sculptures I thought was the coolest idea. The great Shankar Shambhu sang the praises of “Khwaja ji” accompanied by qawwals from all over the sub-continent, and even by a Baul singer. I never thought of myself as a Muslim (ergo different) and nothing in my surroundings made me feel I didn’t belong, no matter where I was. This was my country and I miss it.

Advertisement

The gradually rising tide of jingoism, hatred and, of late, war fever here, cannot but have encouraged all “right” minded citizens to no longer bother disguising the bigotry that has been latent in them all along. At the same time, it has been cause for concern for those who worry about the direction in which our country seems to be headed. The touchiness of the offence-taking brigade has begun bordering on the absurd. Criticising the quality of Hindi movies makes you “ungrateful”, a plea for sanity and brotherhood makes you “a traitor”, a grouse that Indians don’t obey traffic lights makes you get advised on where you should go, speaking up for a fellow artiste is “speaking against the country”.

Anything that is remotely critical gets twisted to sound “anti-national”. The actor who plays the lead in the beloved TV serial Anupamaa tartly enquires whether Pakistan “allows Indian artistes to perform there?” without knowing that not only do they allow us, they welcome us and honour us. And then is everyone who listens to Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan or Mehdi Hasan or Farida Khanum in India a traitor? Obviously, it’s only the Prime Minister who can go across the border to embrace his counterpart. For us ordinary mortals to do that is a sin. Is it in any way beneficial to us to hate every Pakistani citizen for what their government (read, army) does? Or, does it simply satisfy some feral urge?

In George Orwell’s book 1984, there exists a daily ritual where everyone drops whatever they are doing and abuses an Opposition leader: It is compulsory to participate in this “two minutes of hate”. Despite it having now become 24 hours of hate, no longer confined to the leader of the Opposition, the palpable poison in the air does not cause me despair or fear. It saddens me. Hatred is self-destructive but evidently it can be sustained indefinitely if one is to go by the continuing actions of some “cow vigilantes”.

Story continues below this ad

Besides, new hatreds can easily be created. I am an easy target for “nationalists” and paid trolls (who really could do with some help in spelling and grammar) because I feel no need to wear my love for anything, including my country, on my sleeve. I know what I feel, I trust my feelings and they are no one else’s business.

I was born in India into the fifth generation of a Muslim family, my wife into an even older Hindu one and we hope our children can be a combination of the best of both. My father refused to go to Pakistan when his brothers left, he was certain India had a future for us just as I feel it does for my offspring. This is a dream that cannot be abandoned.

If this is taken to be a justification of my Facebook post (which has been taken down, not deleted by me) in support of Diljit Dosanjh, so be it. But the fact is I need to justify nothing. I said whatever I had to say and I stand by it. Nor am I discouraged by the lack of support from the film industry. I wasn’t expecting any — they all either have too much to lose or they disagree. And to the trolls, particularly the one who said to me “Pakistan nahin ab kabristaan”, I can only quote Jigar Moradabadi: “Mujhe de na ghaiz mein dhamkiyaan, giren lakh baar ye bijliyan, / Meri saltanat yehi aashiyaan, meri milkiyat yehi chaar par (Don’t threaten me in anger, let lightning strike a thousand time/ My nest is my domain, these four feathers all I own).”

The writer is an actor and author

Source: https://indianexpress.com/article/o...it-dosanjh-sardaar-ji-3-controversy-10105624/
Click to expand...

This is good. Till your career is good, do it. When it is over, play victim card to be in lime light to be the Hero of Siculars, Commies and Islamist. It is batter to be hero of Fringe elements rather than being forgotten.
 
Last edited:
Krishna with Flute said:
Not by Modi Brand politics. As the Sickulars are not able to defeat Modi, they starts abusing him. As if that was not enough, they started abusing nation and whosoever support Modi. Nationalist hit back and that is how the cycle begun.
Click to expand...
What is a sickular?

If you mean secular, what is wrong?

Do you want India to be a Hindu Pakistan?
 
Vsdoc said:
@Bagheera0084 @Sharma Ji

As Hindu Modi supporters, do chime in too.
Click to expand...
Oh please, Doc.. aap 'sickular' ka matlab acchi tareh jaantey ho.

As I've said many times before, I'm all for it, a militant form, true secularism, as envisioned by the French.

Hamare yahan ka toh ekdum ghatiya milavat wala hai, a bimaar form of it, hence the sick..

jiske under instead of separation of "church" and state

yahan fusion of church + mosque + temple + gurudwara + godknows what all ka mishrand sa ho ria hae !

je kya baat hui ???
picard-wtf-meme-template-regular-72139fdb.webp
 
Sharma Ji said:
Oh please, Doc.. aap 'sickular' ka matlab acchi tareh jaantey ho.

As I've said many times before, I'm all for it, a militant form, true secularism, as envisioned by the French.

Hamare yahan ka toh ekdum ghatiya milavat wala hai, a bimaar form of it, hence the sick..

jiske under instead of separation of "church" and state

yahan fusion of church + mosque + temple + gurudwara + godknows what all ka mishrand sa ho ria hae !

je kya baat hui ???
picard-wtf-meme-template-regular-72139fdb.webp
Click to expand...
So you want to kick out the rest and just keep the Mandirs?

As a Hindu India.
 

Quotes

Previous Thread

How to protect against ‘GoldPickaxe': The First iPhone Trojan

Next Thread

Posts you haven't read yet..

Countries Unread Posts

Continents Unread Posts

Latest Posts

Latest Posts

Back
Top
PKDefense - Recommended Toggle
⬆️ Top
Read Watch War Archive