Home Watch Videos Wars Movies Login

[🇧🇩] Indo-Bangla Relation: India's Regional Ambition, Geopolitical Reality, and Strategic Options For Bangladesh

[🇧🇩] Indo-Bangla Relation: India's Regional Ambition, Geopolitical Reality, and Strategic Options For Bangladesh
579
26K
More threads by Saif

G Bangladesh Defense
Country specific languages can be posted but only in there respective country defense sections. IE: Bengali in Bangladesh Defense. Hindi/Gujarati/Punjabi/etc., in Indian defense and so on.

So essentially country specific defence sections should become echo chamber silos where only members of that country who can understand the tongue can participate?

So Hindi videos for the Indian section. Along with the 26 other major languages spoken in India.

And similarly, members can converse in thise languages too?

Tower of Babel comes to mind. But hey, its your forum.

I'm still waiting for @PakistanProud to remove my Moderator tag as requested.
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Respond
So essentially country specific defence sections should become echo chamber silos where only members of that country who can understand the tongue can participate?

So Hindi videos for the Indian section. Along with the 26 other major languages spoken in India.

And similarly, members can converse in thise languages too?

Tower of Babel comes to mind. But hey, its your forum.

I'm still waiting for @PakistanProud to remove my Moderator tag as requested.
Thank you for sharing your perspective. I understand your concern about creating "echo chambers" in country-specific sections.

The intention behind allowing posts in local languages is to enable more meaningful discussions among those who are most familiar with the topics at hand. However, I completely agree that inclusivity is important.

To strike a balance, we might consider encouraging users to provide a brief summary or translation in English when posting in local languages.
This way, members who may not speak the language can still engage with the content and contribute to the discussion.

We are an international 'defense' forum and this opens the floor for others to share their views, fostering a collaborative environment.
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Respond
  • Love (+3)
Reactions: Bilal9
Thank you for sharing your perspective. I understand your concern about creating "echo chambers" in country-specific sections.

The intention behind allowing posts in local languages is to enable more meaningful discussions among those who are most familiar with the topics at hand. However, I completely agree that inclusivity is important.

To strike a balance, we might consider encouraging users to provide a brief summary or translation in English when posting in local languages.
This way, members who may not speak the language can still engage with the content and contribute to the discussion.

We are an international 'defense' forum and this opens the floor for others to share their views, fostering a collaborative environment.

That is exactly the point of ANY forum.

Not just defence/defense.

Otherwise, it becomes a one sided archive or blog, like most of the Bangladeshi section anyways is.
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Respond
That is exactly the point of ANY forum.

Not just defence/defense.

Otherwise, it becomes a one sided archive or blog, like most of the Bangladeshi section anyways is.
I appreciate your input and understand your concerns about maintaining a balanced dialogue on forums. You’re right that forums should promote diverse discussions, and that’s something we all value.

The aim of allowing country-specific languages in those sections is to encourage participation from members who might otherwise feel excluded. While some sections may currently seem one-sided, my hope is that by providing a space for local languages, we can foster more engagement among those who are familiar with the nuances of their country’s defense matters.

We are always open to hear any suggestions you might have on how we can improve engagement while ensuring that all voices are heard.
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Respond
  • Love (+3)
Reactions: Bilal9
I appreciate your input and understand your concerns about maintaining a balanced dialogue on forums. You’re right that forums should promote diverse discussions, and that’s something we all value.

The aim of allowing country-specific languages in those sections is to encourage participation from members who might otherwise feel excluded. While some sections may currently seem one-sided, my hope is that by providing a space for local languages, we can foster more engagement among those who are familiar with the nuances of their country’s defense matters.

We are always open to hear any suggestions you might have on how we can improve engagement while ensuring that all voices are heard.

Having an English only rule is the obvious suggestion.

Its not like everyone participating here does not know English.

Or cannot find relevant/similar content in English to post.

There are exactly 2 members here who understand Bangla.

And everyday the rest of the membership is bombarded with 20-30 Bangla threads.

Trump ... Bangla thread.

Ukraine war ... Bangla thread.

Gaza Israel .... Bangla thread.

India China ... Bangla thread.

There is one Bangla member who is abusing the forum as his own private national soapbox archive.

And being given covering fire by another Bangla moderator.
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Respond
Having an English only rule is the obvious suggestion.

Its not like everyone participating here does not know English.

Or cannot find relevant/similar content in English to post.

There are exactly 2 members here who understand Bangla.

And everyday the rest of the membership is bombarded with 20-30 Bangla threads.

Trump ... Bangla thread.

Ukraine war ... Bangla thread.

Gaza Israel .... Bangla thread.

India China ... Bangla thread.
I understand your frustration with the current volume of Bangla threads and appreciate that you’re looking for a more balanced discussion.

I believe that as our community grows, we will see more diverse participation from members around the world. For now, allowing discussions in specific languages can help foster a sense of belonging and encourage engagement among those who may be more comfortable expressing their ideas in their native tongue.

As the forum evolves, we can revisit these language policies based on the community's needs. I’m optimistic that with time, we’ll find the right balance that accommodates everyone while still promoting lively discussions.

Let’s keep the dialogue open, and I appreciate your contributions to shaping this community.
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Respond
  • Love (+3)
Reactions: Bilal9

Indo-Bangla ties can’t be limited to a single issue
Indian envoy tells session of Bay of Bengal Conversation

1731888243389.webp

Photo: Collected

The mutual cooperation between Bangladesh and India is multidimensional and cannot be restricted to a single issue, said Indian High Commissioner to Bangladesh Pranay Kumar Verma.

He made the remark yesterday addressing the second session of the Bay of Bengal Conversation symposium, organised by the Centre for Governance Studies at the Pan Pacific Sonargaon in Dhaka.

"Our relations can't be restricted to a single agenda or a single issue. The reality of our interdependence and mutual benefit will keep asserting itself over and over again regardless of the change in political will.

"Regardless of how it [the relations] may be characterised, we [India] believe it's a people-centric relationship … India will continue to seek a stable relationship for the sake of the people," he said.

"We issue more visas than any other diplomatic missions here," Verma said, additionallynoting that visa operations arecurrently limited.

He added that Bangladesh's zero tolerance for terrorism and refusal to harbour Indian anti-insurgency elements areimportant to India.

"Bangladesh sits at the intersection of most of India's foreign policy decisions. Our peace, progress, and security are interlinked."

Meanwhile, Dr Sreeradha Datta, professor at the Jindal School of International Affairs at OP Jindal Global University, said, "Integration in South Asia can only happen surrounding the India-Bangladesh caucus. That's how important it is."

The relationship between the two countries has been under pressure after former prime minister Sheikh Hasina sought refuge in India following her ouster on August 5.

Indian Foreign Affairs Minister S Jaishankar told the Rajya Sabha on August 6 that Hasina had sought approval to come to India on a "short notice".

The Indian media had reported that upon crossing the India-Bangladesh border, Hasina's exit flight was escorted by two fighter jets. She is reportedly staying at a safehouse in New Delhi.

The International Crimes Tribunal has asked Interpol to issue a red notice for Hasina's arrest in connection with the deaths of hundreds of protesters during the mass uprising against her in July.

Meanwhile, speakers at the conference also spoke about Indo-Pacific security and prioritising sovereignty.

Responding to a question about how the Chinese-built submarine base in Cox's Bazar's Pekua impacts Indo-Pacific security, the Acting High Commissioner for Australia Nardia Simpson said, "The question isn't about who was involved but about whether [Bangladesh's] sovereignty was prioritised."

She went on to say that Bangladesh must act for itself and not be acted upon.

Simpson added that security for the Indo-Pacific means a position "where a larger country cannot dominate and where all countries' sovereignty is respected."

David Brewster, senior research fellow at the National Security College in Australia, said Bangladesh holds the unique position to stabilise the increasingly fractured relations concerning the Indo-Pacific. "It can check major powers to make sure no one dominates."

He added, "It has long puzzled me why Bangladesh has not been a larger player in the region. Bangladesh has vital interests, but in recent years it has not sought to shape the strategic interests concerning the region in line with its own policy."​
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Respond

Delhi wants stable ties with Dhaka: Indian envoy
Staff Correspondent 17 November, 2024, 21:50

1731891563080.webp

Pranay Verma | Collected photo

The Indian high commissioner to Bangladesh, Pranay Verma, on Sunday said that his country would continue to seek a stable, positive and constructive relationship with Bangladesh with the people of both countries being the main stakeholders.

He described the relations between the two countries as ‘people-centric’ based on mutual trust and respect.

‘India will continue to seek a stable, positive and constructive relationship with Bangladesh in which people of both countries are the main stakeholders,’ said the envoy while speaking on India-Bangladesh relations during the Bay of Bengal Conversation at a hotel in Dhaka.

Highlighting the importance of the relations between the two neighbouring countries, Pranay expressed India’s commitment to working together with the government and people of Bangladesh to fulfill shared aspirations for peace, security and development, and to ensure that the partnership continued to bring benefit to the common people on both sides.

He stressed that India took a long-term view of its relations with Bangladesh and believed that the peace, security, progress and prosperity of the two countries were interlinked.

The high commissioner underlined the continued progress in trade, transport and energy connectivity and people-to-people engagements as a reflection of multifaceted ties, in which the reality of interdependence and mutual benefit would keep reasserting itself, ‘regardless of political changes’.

He mentioned the launch of 40 MW power transmission from Nepal to Bangladesh through the Indian grid, and the augmentation of infrastructure at the Petrapole-Benapole Integrated Check Post, both within this month itself, as examples of continued progress in bilateral exchanges.

He also described India-Bangladesh cooperation as an anchor for regional integration envisaged under architectures such as BIMSTEC.

Pranay underlined the need for constructive and pragmatic engagement, admitting the fact that there were irritants among the two nations.

The three-day geopolitical conference organised by the Centre for Governance Studies, an independent think tank based in Dhaka, will conclude today.​
 
Analyze

Analyze Post

Add your ideas here:
Highlight Cite Respond

Members Online

No members online now.

Latest Posts

Back
 
G
O
 
H
O
M
E