Saif
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2024
- Messages
- 22,306
- Likes
- 9,875
- Nation

- Axis Group

How Islamic are Islamic banks?
Although around one-fourth of the country's banking activities are now considered Shariah-based, some quarters have already raised a few troubling questions. The main questions they ask is: to what extent do Islamic banks follow Shariah principles (Islamic law)? Several Islamic scholars have also e
How Islamic are Islamic banks?
Although around one-fourth of the country's banking activities are now considered Shariah-based, some quarters have already raised a few troubling questions. The main questions they ask is: to what extent do Islamic banks follow Shariah principles (Islamic law)? Several Islamic scholars have also expressed reservations about the current state of Islamic banking. Some believe most Islamic banks are not yet fully Shariah-compliant. A few even have harsher assessment; none of the Islamic banks is at all Islamic.
Currently, 10 full-fledged Islamic banks operate in the country, and 17 conventional banks have 53 Islamic bank branches. Another 23 conventional banks have 23 Islamic banking windows. Thus, among 63 scheduled banks, 50 have Islamic banking operations, either fully or partially. Bangladesh Bank statistics also showed that at the end of the last fiscal year (FY26), the Islamic banking sector accounted for 22.53 per cent of the total banking industry's deposits and 29.19 per cent of the industry's total advances or investments.
Besides Islamic banks, Islamic financing activities by Non-Bank Financial Companies (NBFCs) are rising modestly. Currently, 35 NBFCs operate, of which two are full-fledged Islamic. In addition, one conventional NBFC provides Islamic financial services through seven Islamic branches, while seven conventional NBFCs provide Islamic financial services through 69 Islamic windows. A bank or NBFC with an Islamic window provides limited Islamic financial services through a dedicated desk or counter at a branch. A bank or NBFC with an Islamic branch indicates that the dedicated branch provides Shariah-compliant services.
Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), the inter-governmental platform of the Muslim majority countries, defined the Islamic bank as "a financial institution whose status, rules and procedures expressly state its commitment to the principle of Islamic Shariah and to the banning of the receipt and payment of interest on any of its operations." The core guiding principles that govern Islamic banking are 'mutual risk and profit sharing' between parties, the 'assurance of fairness for all ', and that 'transactions are based on an underlying business activity or asset.' Because Islamic law strictly prohibits interest (riba), gambling (maisir), and speculative trading (gharar), the Islamic banking and financing framework does not allow any commercial activity linked to interest or gambling. Instead, it encourages activities that cultivate entrepreneurship, trade and commerce and bring social development or benefit.
Thus, the main challenge for an Islamic bank or financial company is to ensure that it has no exposure to interest-based activities, the core driver of conventional banking worldwide. Riba is the Arabic term for interest charged on loans and covers all interest, not just excessive interest (usury). Islamic law forbids a Muslim from paying and accepting interest at a predetermined rate. So, when conventional banks offer interest on deposits and charge interest on loans, it breaches Islamic Shariah. Islamic banks offer Shariah-compliant alternatives by providing profit-and-loss sharing tools.
Many Muslims in Bangladesh do not want to receive interest on their deposits. So, they prefer Islamic banks that offer no predetermined profit. In practice, Islamic banks set a provisional profit rate, subject to revision and adjustment at year-end. Some argue that the pre-determined profit is also interest in disguise, since there is no way to escape it. Why would depositors park their money if they get nothing in return? And without collecting deposits, how will an Islamic bank finance or invest in industries and commercial activities? Banking governance guide
Unlike conventional banks, Islamic banks do not disburse loans or advances; instead, they finance business and trade through investment. This is because traditional banks charge and earn interest on loans or advances without being directly involved in commercial activities. For Islamic banks, this means becoming business partners or investors to earn profits and share them with the partners. To facilitate investment, Islamic banks and financial companies have developed and practised several modes. These are: partnership, ownership-sharing, sale-based, lease-based, and loan-based investments. Under partnership, one partner (the bank) invests in the business, and the other partner (the client) manages it. Finally, they both share the business profits in a predetermined ratio. In case of losses, the bank bears them alone. This kind of partnership is known as Mudarabah. Another type of partnership is Musharaka, where both the bank and the client contribute capital, and the client also provides entrepreneurial skills through labour and management. Profits are shared according to agreed ratios, and losses are borne in proportion to capital contributions. These two types of investments are considered more Shariah-compliant than others.
Other options include Ijara (lease financing), hire purchase, and Qard-e-Hasan (interest-free lending). In leasing or hire purchase, an Islamic bank purchases a specific asset and lets the client use it in exchange for rent for a set period. Once the rent is paid off, the client acquires the asset.
Finally, Bai-Salam is one of the most famous modes of Islamic financing, and Bai-Muajjal is another. The first is a contract in which the buyer pays in advance for goods to be delivered later. The latter is a credit sale. There is also Bai-Murabaha, a cost-plus sale in which the seller discloses the cost of a product and sells it to the buyer by adding an agreed profit margin.
In Bangladesh, Bai-Murabaha and Bai-Muajjal are two of the most commonly used investment modes of Islamic banks. Because the return on these two investment types is fixed or predetermined, Shariah compliance appears questionable. Nevertheless, more than two-thirds of the country's total Islamic bank investment is concentrated in Bai-Murabaha and Bai-Muajjal, or sale-based modes of investment. Bangladesh Bank, in a policy note titled 'An Analysis of Mode-wise Investment of Islamic Banks in Bangladesh', released last month, highlighted the issue. It argued that excessive concentration in sale-based investment modes by Islamic banks may replicate key features of conventional banking. The policy note also pointed out that the overwhelming dominance of sale-based modes reflects a lack of emphasis on profit-and-loss sharing (PLS) modes. Currently, partnership-based PLS accounts for less than 1 per cent of Islamic banks' total investments in the country. This is alarming for the future of the Islamic banking system, as PLS is considered more Shariah-compliant than other investment modes. PLS is based on a risk-sharing partnership in commercial activities and places more responsibility on banks as co-investors. In other words, banks must assess risk more cautiously before investing in a trade. This ultimately reduces overall investment risk, although it may also limit opportunities to invest more.
Moreover, Islamic banks must rigorously ensure the ethical aspects of any commercial activity to comply with Islamic law. If a proposed venture appears harmful to society or the environment, an Islamic bank may not invest in it. For instance, a brickfield pollutes the air, degrades soil, and sometimes causes deforestation. So, an Islamic bank should not invest in a brickfield project.
Nevertheless, the central bank's policy note sends a timely message to rigorously examine the overall status of Islamic banking in the country. Over the decades, many irregularities and unethical practices have occurred in the country's Islamic banking sector. Cronies of the Hasina regime systematically distorted the country's Islamic financing, making it highly questionable and unreliable. So, it is time to move ahead and correct the course of the Islamic banking sector.
Although around one-fourth of the country's banking activities are now considered Shariah-based, some quarters have already raised a few troubling questions. The main questions they ask is: to what extent do Islamic banks follow Shariah principles (Islamic law)? Several Islamic scholars have also expressed reservations about the current state of Islamic banking. Some believe most Islamic banks are not yet fully Shariah-compliant. A few even have harsher assessment; none of the Islamic banks is at all Islamic.
Currently, 10 full-fledged Islamic banks operate in the country, and 17 conventional banks have 53 Islamic bank branches. Another 23 conventional banks have 23 Islamic banking windows. Thus, among 63 scheduled banks, 50 have Islamic banking operations, either fully or partially. Bangladesh Bank statistics also showed that at the end of the last fiscal year (FY26), the Islamic banking sector accounted for 22.53 per cent of the total banking industry's deposits and 29.19 per cent of the industry's total advances or investments.
Besides Islamic banks, Islamic financing activities by Non-Bank Financial Companies (NBFCs) are rising modestly. Currently, 35 NBFCs operate, of which two are full-fledged Islamic. In addition, one conventional NBFC provides Islamic financial services through seven Islamic branches, while seven conventional NBFCs provide Islamic financial services through 69 Islamic windows. A bank or NBFC with an Islamic window provides limited Islamic financial services through a dedicated desk or counter at a branch. A bank or NBFC with an Islamic branch indicates that the dedicated branch provides Shariah-compliant services.
Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), the inter-governmental platform of the Muslim majority countries, defined the Islamic bank as "a financial institution whose status, rules and procedures expressly state its commitment to the principle of Islamic Shariah and to the banning of the receipt and payment of interest on any of its operations." The core guiding principles that govern Islamic banking are 'mutual risk and profit sharing' between parties, the 'assurance of fairness for all ', and that 'transactions are based on an underlying business activity or asset.' Because Islamic law strictly prohibits interest (riba), gambling (maisir), and speculative trading (gharar), the Islamic banking and financing framework does not allow any commercial activity linked to interest or gambling. Instead, it encourages activities that cultivate entrepreneurship, trade and commerce and bring social development or benefit.
Thus, the main challenge for an Islamic bank or financial company is to ensure that it has no exposure to interest-based activities, the core driver of conventional banking worldwide. Riba is the Arabic term for interest charged on loans and covers all interest, not just excessive interest (usury). Islamic law forbids a Muslim from paying and accepting interest at a predetermined rate. So, when conventional banks offer interest on deposits and charge interest on loans, it breaches Islamic Shariah. Islamic banks offer Shariah-compliant alternatives by providing profit-and-loss sharing tools.
Many Muslims in Bangladesh do not want to receive interest on their deposits. So, they prefer Islamic banks that offer no predetermined profit. In practice, Islamic banks set a provisional profit rate, subject to revision and adjustment at year-end. Some argue that the pre-determined profit is also interest in disguise, since there is no way to escape it. Why would depositors park their money if they get nothing in return? And without collecting deposits, how will an Islamic bank finance or invest in industries and commercial activities? Banking governance guide
Unlike conventional banks, Islamic banks do not disburse loans or advances; instead, they finance business and trade through investment. This is because traditional banks charge and earn interest on loans or advances without being directly involved in commercial activities. For Islamic banks, this means becoming business partners or investors to earn profits and share them with the partners. To facilitate investment, Islamic banks and financial companies have developed and practised several modes. These are: partnership, ownership-sharing, sale-based, lease-based, and loan-based investments. Under partnership, one partner (the bank) invests in the business, and the other partner (the client) manages it. Finally, they both share the business profits in a predetermined ratio. In case of losses, the bank bears them alone. This kind of partnership is known as Mudarabah. Another type of partnership is Musharaka, where both the bank and the client contribute capital, and the client also provides entrepreneurial skills through labour and management. Profits are shared according to agreed ratios, and losses are borne in proportion to capital contributions. These two types of investments are considered more Shariah-compliant than others.
Other options include Ijara (lease financing), hire purchase, and Qard-e-Hasan (interest-free lending). In leasing or hire purchase, an Islamic bank purchases a specific asset and lets the client use it in exchange for rent for a set period. Once the rent is paid off, the client acquires the asset.
Finally, Bai-Salam is one of the most famous modes of Islamic financing, and Bai-Muajjal is another. The first is a contract in which the buyer pays in advance for goods to be delivered later. The latter is a credit sale. There is also Bai-Murabaha, a cost-plus sale in which the seller discloses the cost of a product and sells it to the buyer by adding an agreed profit margin.
In Bangladesh, Bai-Murabaha and Bai-Muajjal are two of the most commonly used investment modes of Islamic banks. Because the return on these two investment types is fixed or predetermined, Shariah compliance appears questionable. Nevertheless, more than two-thirds of the country's total Islamic bank investment is concentrated in Bai-Murabaha and Bai-Muajjal, or sale-based modes of investment. Bangladesh Bank, in a policy note titled 'An Analysis of Mode-wise Investment of Islamic Banks in Bangladesh', released last month, highlighted the issue. It argued that excessive concentration in sale-based investment modes by Islamic banks may replicate key features of conventional banking. The policy note also pointed out that the overwhelming dominance of sale-based modes reflects a lack of emphasis on profit-and-loss sharing (PLS) modes. Currently, partnership-based PLS accounts for less than 1 per cent of Islamic banks' total investments in the country. This is alarming for the future of the Islamic banking system, as PLS is considered more Shariah-compliant than other investment modes. PLS is based on a risk-sharing partnership in commercial activities and places more responsibility on banks as co-investors. In other words, banks must assess risk more cautiously before investing in a trade. This ultimately reduces overall investment risk, although it may also limit opportunities to invest more.
Moreover, Islamic banks must rigorously ensure the ethical aspects of any commercial activity to comply with Islamic law. If a proposed venture appears harmful to society or the environment, an Islamic bank may not invest in it. For instance, a brickfield pollutes the air, degrades soil, and sometimes causes deforestation. So, an Islamic bank should not invest in a brickfield project.
Nevertheless, the central bank's policy note sends a timely message to rigorously examine the overall status of Islamic banking in the country. Over the decades, many irregularities and unethical practices have occurred in the country's Islamic banking sector. Cronies of the Hasina regime systematically distorted the country's Islamic financing, making it highly questionable and unreliable. So, it is time to move ahead and correct the course of the Islamic banking sector.