[🇵🇰-Airforce] How A Pakistani Pilot “Shot Down” An Israeli Fighter Jet With Russian MiG-21 in 1974

G Pakistan Airforce
[🇵🇰-Airforce] How A Pakistani Pilot “Shot Down” An Israeli Fighter Jet With Russian MiG-21 in 1974
13
575
More threads by PakistanProud

Short Summary: 50 years ago today:

PakistanProud

Moderator
Jan 24, 2024
336
209
Origin

Residence

Axis Group

In the annals of military history, some stories stand out for their unexpected twists and turns. One such event occurred half a century ago, on April 26, 1974, when Flight Lieutenant Sattar Alvi, a Pakistani pilot, accomplished a rare feat by shooting down an Israeli fighter jet while flying a MiG aircraft for the Syrian Air Force.


The backdrop to this rare incident lies in the aftermath of the 1967 Arab-Israeli War. The swift and decisive victory of Israel in that conflict had reshaped the geopolitical dynamics of the region, leaving neighboring Arab states in a state of disarray and humiliation.

However, tensions persisted, and six years later, the region once again became a theater of conflict during the Yom Kippur War of 1973. Israel found itself in intense combat against a coalition of Arab states led by Egypt and Syria, with Pakistan unexpectedly joining the fray.

When hostilities erupted, several Pakistani Air Force pilots, including Sattar Alvi, volunteered to join the war despite Pakistan having no direct involvement in the conflict.


The country's leadership endorsed the decision to send Pakistani pilots to the Middle East, including Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, who wanted to maintain strong relations with Arab nations.

In an interview, Alvi recounted how the Pakistani Air Chief's conversation with President Hafez al-Assad of Syria paved the way for their participation in the war effort.

He said, "I took one of my salwar kameez and flying gear, and when we reached Peshawar, we found out that 14 more people had also volunteered. We were put on the Chief's Fokker ship, and after a while, the Chief also came. We had no idea where we were going."

The Pakistani pilots were asked to sign a document stating that during their time abroad, if any unforeseen incidents occurred, neither the Government of Pakistan nor the Pakistani Air Force would assume responsibility for them.


According to Sattar Alvi, the document outlined their departure from overseas leave and absolved the authorities of any liabilities in case of untoward events.

Subsequently, the pilots were transported to Karachi and then to Baghdad via a C-130 aircraft. From Baghdad, Sattar Alvi and his companions embarked on a journey by road, making their way to Jordan and ultimately to Damascus.


Of the 16 Pakistani pilots, eight were dispatched to Egypt, while the remaining eight were directed to stay in Syria. Sattar Alvi was among those instructed to remain in Syria.

Later, Alvi and his fellow pilots were relocated to the Damir air base, situated approximately 30 minutes from Damascus, where they were designated as the 67A unit.

[h2]Major Challenge Faced By Pakistani Pilots [/h2]By the time they arrived, Egypt and Israel had already reached a ceasefire agreement, leaving Syria alone engaged in active conflict with Israel. Even so, the Pakistani pilots began their operations in the designated country.

However, the transition was not without its challenges. As Sattar Alvi recounted, the language barrier was foremost among these.

The Russian-made MiG-21 aircraft they were tasked to fly featured inscriptions in Russian, while communications with radars and air traffic control were conducted exclusively in Arabic.

To surmount this obstacle, the pilots devised a practical solution. Alvi explained, "We wrote down the essentials needed to fly the plane and carried them on a piece of paper in our flying suits. This enabled us to grasp the Arabic language required within a week."

Assigned to the crucial role of air defense, the Pakistani pilots were entrusted with intercepting any Israeli aircraft breaching Syrian airspace. Despite the ceasefire between Egypt and Israel, the conflict persisted in the Golan Heights region.


1714321086400.jpeg




Alvi described the rigorous routine they adopted: preparing each morning before Sehri, the pre-dawn meal during Ramadan, and awaiting potential assignments at the airport. This routine persisted for an arduous seven months.

Throughout their deployment, the Pakistani pilots faced numerous sorties, often encountering Israeli planes. Even after these encounters, Alvi noted that no direct engagements ensued between the two forces.

The Pakistani pilots had decided that whether they succeeded in shooting down an Israeli plane or not, their top priority was to ensure that no Pakistani pilot would be captured by the Israelis. This decision formed the basis of their air strategy.

[H2]How Pakistani Pilot Downed An Israeli Jet[/H2]
On April 26, 1974, Alvi, who was serving as Flight Lieutenant, piloted a SAF MiG-21F-13 (Serial No. 1863) while on secondment to the No. 67A Squadron, Syrian Air Force (SAF), stationed at Dumayr Air Base, Syria.

Mirage 2000
Image for Representation: Mirage 2000
Eight Pakistani pilots, including Sattar Alvi, formed the Shahbaz 8 formation during a tense aerial encounter over Lebanon. Alvi recalled how the formation commander, moments before losing communication, directed them to turn towards the reported arrival direction of Israeli aircraft.

As the situation unfolded, Alvi noticed a shining object descending towards the earth, which he identified as an Israeli Mirage warship. Separating from his formation, Alvi maneuvered to confront the approaching aircraft.

Engaging in a high-stakes aerial dance known as 'squires,' Alvi found himself in a precarious position as the Israeli Mirage closed in. With fuel running low and another Israeli fighter approaching, Alvi had to act swiftly.

Spotting an opportunity as the Israeli pilot attempted to evade, Alvi fired his Russian-made missile. A tense moment ensued as the missile failed to launch immediately, leaving Alvi grappling with uncertainty.

Finally, the missile launched, striking the Israeli Mirage and ending the brief skirmish. Alvi returned to base, narrowly avoiding disaster as his fuel gauge plummeted below zero.

After that, Alvi received the Syrian government's highest honor for his valorous action. On the other hand, the Israeli pilot, identified as Captain Lutz, was allegedly captured but succumbed to his injuries before Alvi could meet him.

Meanwhile, Alvi remained silent about the incident for years, even denying his involvement when questioned. The government of Pakistan eventually awarded him the Star of Courage.

The veracity of this account, however, remains shrouded in ambiguity. Despite assertions from Pakistani sources, no major contemporary reports corroborate the incident. Further, Israel's Ministry of Defense's record of casualties from the war makes no mention of a "Captain Lutz," casting doubt on the purported engagement.
 
"Despite claims from Pakistani sources, no major contemporary reports confirm the incident. Furthermore, the Israeli Ministry of Defense does not mention a 'Captain Lutz' in its list of war casualties, which casts doubt on the alleged involvement". Not many people will read these final sentences of this article.

Our pilots did not have time to defend Pakistan during the 1971 war when Indian MIG-21s destroyed our flying capability in the eastern theatre. Instead, our pilots were busy flying MIG-21s defending the Arab kings and dictators.
 
"Despite claims from Pakistani sources, no major contemporary reports confirm the incident. Furthermore, the Israeli Ministry of Defense does not mention a 'Captain Lutz' in its list of war casualties, which casts doubt on the alleged involvement". Not many people will read these final sentences of this article.

Our pilots did not have time to defend Pakistan during the 1971 war when Indian MIG-21s destroyed our flying capability in the eastern theatre. Instead, our pilots were busy flying MIG-21s defending the Arab kings and dictators.

Asking for confirmation of air-war casualties from Israel is like asking for confirmation of war crimes from them. We all know what the answer will be, foregone conclusion.

Eastern theater was undefended and destroyed by Indian AF quickly because the air-war assets were few and mostly outdated (a few Canadair Sabre fighters, and a sprinkling of doddering old Otters, helis and transports at the most) attacked by Indian modern SU-17s, Hunters and MiG-21s (probably MFs) most of which were a generation newer.

This was a sacrificial philosophy, as espoused and decided on by Yahya Khan et al. No valuable air-assets (certainly not contemporary modern ones) were posted in Dhaka (Dacca) airbase at the time (November/December 1971). Pakistani high command had decided to let Dhaka fall on the air-superiority side and not 'waste' valuable air assets in defending East Pakistan.

Still - Airforce people I talked to who watched the dogfights from the Dhaka rooftops confirmed that the Sabres fought well and defended the airport well, despite obvious shortcomings.
 
Last edited:
Yes, I've read about this in the past, nice 1.

There have also been accounts of U Spilots flying under guize in some of their wars. Very cloak and dagger secret stuff.

Francis Gary Powers - a CIA pilot who flew a U2 spy-plane from an airbase (PAF Camp Badaber) in Northern Pakistan to overfly recon flights in the old Soviet Union. Shot down over Chelyabinsk in Central Russia using SA-2 missiles (then brand new).



Powers wrote a memoir on the incident, that arguably - started the cold war (the Berlin wall was constructed the following year).

1739381492461.png


Spielberg directed this movie on Powers below. Should be available on Netflix.

1739380598972.png
1739380632740.png






 
There have been a few and a few of Bangladeshi origin during East Pakistan era @Sharma Ji @Bilal9 @Saif @Lulldapull
This is correct. Although this thread was about Flt. Lieutenant Sattar Alvi, there were quite a few other aces flying for Arab Air Forces which Pakistan Govt. deputed to Iraq and Jordan (in particular). Among them was an East Pakistani Ace (later who attained "Top Gun" from the USA) Ace Pilot Group Captain Saiful Azam, who was deputed to Jordan and Iraq and had quite a few confirmed Israeli kills.

Here in this clip below he is reflecting on his memories of his boss Air Commodore M M Alam of PAF (another Bengali speaker Ace pilot from East Pakistan). Group Captain Saiful Azam died on 14 June 2020 at Dhaka Combined Military Hospital and his boss Air Commodore Alam passed away earlier in Karachi in 2012. May Allah bless their souls and grant them His choicest spots in Jannat-Ul-Firdaus.




1739384191900.png


Saiful Azam getting Sitara-I-Jurrat from Field Marshal Ayub Khan
1739384755482.png


1739383529398.png

MM Alam poses with his ride. Indian Flags as kill marks visible on the nose of the F-86 Sabre. Large flags mean confirmed kills while smaller ones refer to probable or damaged.

 
Asking for confirmation of air-war casualties from Israel is like asking for confirmation of war crimes from them. We all know what the answer will be, foregone conclusion.

Eastern theater was undefended and destroyed by Indian AF quickly because the air-war assets were few and mostly outdated (a few Canadair Sabre fighters, and a sprinkling of doddering old Otters, helis and transports at the most) attacked by Indian modern SU-17s, Hunters and MiG-21s (probably MFs) most of which were a generation newer.

This was a sacrificial philosophy, as espoused and decided on by Yahya Khan et al. No valuable air-assets (certainly not contemporary modern ones) were posted in Dhaka (Dacca) airbase at the time (November/December 1971). Pakistani high command had decided to let Dhaka fall on the air-superiority side and not 'waste' valuable air assets in defending East Pakistan.

Still - Airforce people I talked to who watched the dogfights from the Dhaka rooftops confirmed that the Sabres fought well and defended the airport well, despite obvious shortcomings.
We had a total of 14 F-86E sabres at Tezgaon when the war started on Dec 3rd.

When the war ended and Tezgaon got overrun, we still had 11 sabres.

Our pilots claimed 13 IAF planes shot down in air combat (9 admitted by the IAF) and another 12 claimed by airfield AAA.

The small force put up a valiant fight but the IAF was determined and pressed home its attacks and destroyed the runways at Tezgaon, followed by the taxiways.
 
We had a total of 14 F-86E sabres at Tezgaon when the war started on Dec 3rd.

When the war ended and Tezgaon got overrun, we still had 11 sabres.

Our pilots claimed 13 IAF planes shot down in air combat (9 admitted by the IAF) and another 12 claimed by airfield AAA.

The small force put up a valiant fight but the IAF was determined and pressed home its attacks and destroyed the runways at Tezgaon, followed by the taxiways.

Well done for the info Bhai.

If you don't mind me asking, what is your source? Official PAF records?

Some of the Canadair CF-86 Sabres are still preserved, some as gate guardians and the better ones in the very well appointed new Military Museum in Dhaka at the end of the Runway at Tejgaon.

1739399068892.png


1739401023252.png


1739401047332.png


@Saif bhai I'm sure you have seen one of these there - correct? If you've visited, that is.
 
Last edited:
Well done for the info Bhai.

If you don't mind me asking, what is your source? Official PAF records?

Some of the Canadair CF-86 Sabres are still preserved, some as gate guardians and the better ones in the very well appointed new Military Museum in Dhaka at the end of the Runway at Tejgaon.

View attachment 14325

View attachment 14326

View attachment 14327

@Saif bhai I'm sure you have seen one of these there - correct? If you've visited, that is.
PAF history by Air Cdr. Hussaini......

We machine gunned both the intakes and exhausts of our remaining sabres before we surrendered! including the cockpits, cut all the wiring and cabling so they couldn't be flown away to India.

Two sabres were shot down by Gnats around Boyra a month or so before the 71 war. PAF claiming a Gnat kill in the surprise attack.

Anyway, our AF held its head high and they performed a great job in 65 war too by attacking the IAF complex at Kalaikunda twice! destroying dozens of aircraft on the ground.
 
Here is Grp. Cpt. Saiful Azam with his Pakistani and US colleagues. Third from left.
View attachment 14324
Saif ul Azam was in fact the greatest fighter pilot of the PAF.

He shot down an IAF Gnat in 65, then he shot down an IDF Mirage IIICJ, a Vatour IIN and a Mystere IVA flying RJAF and Iraqi AF Hawker Hunters in 1967.

Probably the greatest PAF fighter pilot, before we let him go to Bangladesh to lead his new country as their ACM......
 
Francis Gary Powers - a CIA pilot who flew a U2 spy-plane from an airbase (PAF Camp Badaber) in Northern Pakistan to overfly recon flights in the old Soviet Union. Shot down over Chelyabinsk in Central Russia using SA-2 missiles (then brand new).



Powers wrote a memoir on the incident, that arguably - started the cold war (the Berlin wall was constructed the following year).

View attachment 14314

Spielberg directed this movie on Powers below. Should be available on Netflix.

View attachment 14312 View attachment 14313






Fascinating, will look it up, thanks.

But I was talking about mercenary pilots flying for another country than their own. PAF guys flew Egyptian planes vs the Israelis ? .. Americans and Chinese (iinw) have also flown their allies' planes in combat, Russians/Soviets too, but I can't recall where exactly.
 

Latest Tweets

Dogun18 Ghazi52 Dogun18 wrote on Ghazi52's profile.
Hello Mr. Legend!

Staff online

Members Online

Latest Posts

Back