[🇧🇩] Monitoring Bangladesh's Economy

Quick Reply ✓ Posted!
Quick Reply ✓ Posted!
[🇧🇩] Monitoring Bangladesh's Economy
1K
55K
More threads by Saif

G Bangladesh Defense

On new export earnings target
The first quarter of the current fiscal year is marked by a notable economic slowdown in the country. And, the reasons are obvious....
Asjadul Kibria
Published :
Sep 21, 2024 22:46
Updated :
Sep 21, 2024 22:46

1726966188542.webp


After a predictable setback in the country's export earnings in the last fiscal year, the interim government has set a fresh target for the current fiscal year (FY25). The new total export target is set at US$57.50 billion, a figure that carries significant weight as it is 13.30 per cent higher than the actual receipt of FY24. Of this, $50 billion is targeted as earnings from exports of goods and the rest from services.

It is to be noted that the country fetched $44.48 billion in exports of goods in the last fiscal year, which was 4.34 per cent lower than the earnings of exports in FY23. Again, the actual receipt in the previous fiscal year missed the original target of $62 billion by 39 per cent. Overambitious targets, coupled with the manipulation of data to artificially inflate the export earnings by the ousted autocratic government, result in a big gap between the targeted and actual figure. The manipulation of data on export earnings also provided a distorted scenario of the country's external trade and overall balance of payments (BoP).

After adjusting the export data, initially provided by the Export Promotion Bureau (EPB), which counted export earnings in some cases inflating the figure, it was found that there was an overestimation of around $9 billion in FY23. This underscores the crucial need for accurate and honest reporting, as the EPB data put the export earnings at $55 billion in FY23, which came down to $46.50 billion after the adjustment. Thus, there was an overestimation of around 16 per cent of the export receipt.

However, the new export target is fixed taking into consideration the adjusted figure of the export earnings. So, the figure was low compared to the indicative target set by the Hasina regime. The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) in May last approved the draft of the Export Policy 2024-2027, eyeing a $110 billion export target in FY27 based on an inflated figure.

A valid question in this connection is how feasible the new merchandise export target of $50 billion, set by the interim government in the second week of this month, is. This piece will try to find the answer, taking both external and internal factors into consideration.

To understand the external factor, a quick look at the current trend of global trade is necessary. Around three months ago, UN Trade and Development (UNCTAD) released its global trade update, which showed that the current international trade trends have turned positive. This positive trend, with trade in goods increasing by around one per cent quarter over quarter (QoQ) in the first quarter of 2024, and services trade growing at approximately 1.5 per cent on the same count, brings a sense of optimism. The UNCTAD predicted a stronger positive trend for Q2 in 2024, projecting an approximate 2 per cent increase for the first half of 2024.

The UN body also estimated that the growth would add around US$250 billion to trade in goods and about US$100 billion to services trade in the first half of the current year compared to the second half of 2023. Moreover, if positive trends persist, global trade in 2024 could reach almost US$32 trillion, though it is unlikely to surpass its record level seen in 2022.

Now, in the first week of this month, the World Trade Organization (WTO) released the latest reading of its Goods Trade Barometer, which is a composite leading indicator for world trade. It revealed that global merchandise trade has been picking up in the third quarter of 2024 after demand for traded goods stalled in 2023 amid high inflation and rising interest rates. In other words, global trade in goods is on the rise in the current year, as predicted by UNCTAD earlier. The reading of the WTO trade barometer also showed the possibility of continuing the rising trend. Taking a cue from these projections, there is hope for Bangladesh, no doubt, as the last half of the current calendar year is also the first half of the current fiscal year.

Nevertheless, according to the WTO barometer, the outlook for trade remains highly uncertain due to four downside factors. These are: rising geopolitical tensions, ongoing regional conflicts, shifting monetary policy in advanced economies, and weakening export orders. All these may severely subdue Bangladesh's export potential in the first half of the current fiscal year.

The Russia-Ukraine war has been continuing for two and half years. Israel continues to pound the Gaza Strip to uproot Hamas militants for almost a year, killing more than 41,000 Palestinians. Though its goal is yet to be achieved, the Zionist state is now going to launch a big offensive in Lebanon to fight Hezbollah, meaning the Middle East will become more volatile. These two key regional conflicts have already disrupted the global supply chain, and continuing the conflicts at a bigger scale will make things worse soon.

The looming presidential election in the United States (US) has become a matter of tension across the world, especially when Donald Trump is the candidate from the Republican camp. Winning Trump would mean escalating geopolitical tension and proliferating a trade war.

On the domestic front, the first quarter of the current fiscal year is marked by serious disruption of economic activities in the country for obvious reasons. The anti-discrimination movement launched by the students in July to reform the quota system in the public sector turned into a mass uprising against the Hasina regime. The movement forced Sheikh Hasina to step down and flee the country to take shelter in India.

Though an interim government under the leadership of Nobel Laureate Professor Muhammad Yunus has taken charge, the overall situation is still volatile. Several ready-made garments (RMG) and other factories were vandalised and faced labour unrest. Production has not fully resumed in all the industrial units. Imports are also slow, as many banks have been short of funds due to gross irregularities. Some big corporate entities, known for their strong affiliation with the ousted prime minister and mobilised big funds from the banks bypassing the rules, are in trouble now. So, the overall economic activities, including exports in the current fiscal year's first quarter, are undoubtedly dull. However, the situation is expected to start to recover in the second quarter, leading to a gradual rise in exports.

Thus, export earnings in the first half of the current fiscal year will grow moderately under the current trend in global and local factors. This will make achieving the target by the end of the fiscal year challenging.​
 

Can Bangladesh achieve SDGs by 2030?
Published :
Sep 23, 2024 22:05
Updated :
Sep 23, 2024 22:05

1727141433466.webp


On the other side of unremitting inflation, a product of no-holds-barred free market economy, is decline in purchasing power of people ---only more so of the low- and fixed-income groups. If shrinking purchasing power is not compensated by corresponding rise in income, the inevitable consequence is deepening poverty. At a time Bangladesh economy was about to witness a turnaround early in the post-Covid-19 period, the Russo-Ukraine war not only halted the process but also threw the prospect of an economic recovery into uncertainty. The main culprit was the sudden price hike of fuel oils for which Bangladesh has to overwhelmingly depend on import. The wind taken out of its sails, the country, like many others with little or no domestic energy sources, discovered itself in a critical situation. Under a system of kleptocracy of the lumpen moneyed and business class unduly served by their bureaucratic cohorts, outrageously unequal wealth distribution only pushed more people to get marginalised.

So when a public meeting held under the title "Eliminating Poverty and Inequality and Strengthening Social Security" on Saturday last comes up with the disclosure that poverty rate in the country has gone up to 20.5 per cent from 18.7 per cent over the past two years, there is nothing to be surprised. Add to this, the urban poverty that saw a rise from 14.7 per cent to 20.5 per cent. Read between the lines, this indicates that urban employment and income have either shrunk or remained static for the low-income people who can barely save for the rainy days. Even if income does not fall, families can suffer income erosion when prices of essentials skyrocket. This has been happening for the past two years or so and there is no sign yet market volatility will ease soon.

There are two aspects of this reverse journey on the road to economic progress for a significant portion of the population. One is the financial vulnerability of this segment of population to unrelenting inflation often driven by intriguing market players; the other is either such people's failure to raise their income from self-employment or from employers who employ them for a pittance. Exploitation of both opportunities and labour explains the atrocious inequality. Otherwise, the national wealth generated annually should not have widened the economic disparities so grossly. Bhutan is a good example of smaller GDP which has been judiciously used, particularly in ensuring rational distribution of its wealth, for alleviation of its poverty. When businesspeople can make rampant profit and the unduly privileged close to the kleptocratic circle can loot and launder billions of Taka, it tells a different story of deprivation on the one hand, and filthy affluence on the other.

Now the deliberation of the Saturday's public meeting aired concern about Bangladesh's attainment of the much hyped Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) by 2030. It is a genuine concern, no doubt but if the macroeconomic health and wealth creation are taken into account, the country should not miss the target. But if the microeconomic situation in relation to rising poverty comes into consideration, the path may be tortuous but the goals not quite unachievable. The key issue here is economic reform with special emphasis on ensuring greater share of created national wealth for the marginalised in order to ameliorate the lot of the poor during the next six years.​
 

A game changing model for boosting remittance

1727224766661.webp


Bangladesh has been experiencing a severe forex crisis for the past two years. Our two main sources of foreign currency are exports and remittances. While we have devoted significant attention to increasing exports, we have largely neglected the potential of remittances. In the past fiscal year, exports have been in the range of $47 billion.

If we consider a value addition of around 50 percent, the net forex earnings is around $23 billion. Meanwhile, judging the current trends, this year the remittances could be between $27 billion and $30 billion.

Workers, especially unskilled labourers abroad, often face cumbersome processes when using formal channels. This drives them to informal options like hundi, which are easier but deprive the country of vital foreign currency. To increase formal remittances, we must understand that, beyond financial needs, wage earners are driven by higher aspirations for esteem and respect.

So, to foster their loyalty and encourage remittance through formal channels, we must adopt a dual strategy addressing their immediate and long-term needs for dignity and recognition.

SHORT-TERM SOLUTIONS

Wage earners' elite club: The government can introduce a "Wage Earners Elite Club," offering tiered membership (platinum, gold, silver and bronze) based on remittance volumes. Benefits for club members could include VIP airport services, meaning that elite members would enjoy dedicated immigration counters and transportation. Additionally, platinum, gold, and silver members could be given access to exclusive lounges at airports, ensuring more comfortable travel.

Recognition and awards: High contributors would be publicly recognised, invited to national events and treated as Commercially Important Persons.

Free travel benefits: Platinum and gold cardholders would be eligible for free round-trip tickets, further incentivising formal remittance channels.

Annual membership upgrades: Elite club membership would be reassessed yearly, with additional perks for top remitters, such as upgraded travel benefits.

Also, the government should develop a remittance app to simplify the process of sending money. Features could include payment gateway integration, transparent currency conversion rates, strong security measures and real-time transaction tracking.

LONG-TERM SOLUTIONS

Sustaining esteem and incentivising remittances: To maintain long-term engagement, the government should offer healthcare and educational benefits. Doing so would allow wage earners and their families to receive healthcare coverage and priority access to schools, thereby improving their social safety net.

Dignity and respect: Embassies and airports must adopt a customer-service approach, ensuring wage earners are treated with the respect they deserve. Special training programmes for embassy staff could be implemented to this end.

Social safety net: Offering wage earners access to pension schemes, scholarships for their children and government-backed housing loans would create loyalty and trust, incentivising formal remittances.

By treating wage earners as valued contributors to the economy and recognising their need for dignity, respect, and belonging, the country can significantly boost remittance inflows. These measures will not only alleviate the foreign currency crisis but also improve the lives of those who sacrifice so much for their families and the nation.

The author is chairman of Unilever Consumer Care Ltd and chief adviser of the board at Crown Cement Group​
 

IMF mission inquires about slow growth of revenue receipts

1727396881323.webp


The fact-finding mission from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) inquired about the slow growth of direct tax collection under the National Board of Revenue (NBR).

A four-member delegation from the Washington-based lender, led by Mission Chief Chris Papageorgiou, raised the issue during their scheduled closed-doors meeting with NBR officials at the tax authority's headquarters in Agargaon.

"The delegation asked why we failed to meet the IMF's revenue collection target in the previous fiscal year and what measures to increase revenue collection have been taken for FY25 and FY26," a top NBR official who attended the meeting said on condition of anonymity.

"It's a form of taking accountability," he told The Daily Star yesterday.

"We explained our real situation to them and said what we have done in recent times, including measures to increase tax return submissions."

The IMF mission also underscored the need to increase the tax-GDP ratio, which is one of the lowest in the world, by a minimum of 0.5 percent in each of the coming years, the official said.

The IMF mission arrived in Dhaka on Monday as part of a weeklong visit to assess Bangladesh's potential financial needs after the country sought an additional $3 billion loan.

The multilateral lender emphasised revenue mobilisation, especially as Bangladesh witnessed an 11 percent drop in revenue collection in the first two months of this fiscal year.

The tax authority logged Tk 42,106 crore in revenue in the July-August period, which is Tk 15,000 crore short of the revenue collection target for the period.

The target for the entirety of FY25 has been set at Tk 480,000 crore.

The NBR official further said that the mission had enquired about the tax expenditures and various reform measures, including automation of the taxation system and processes.

"We have been asked to reduce tax exemptions in a rational way," the official added.

The IMF team also agreed to extend their assistance for automation.

On a positive note, the team expressed satisfaction over the state of indirect taxation.

Md Bodruzzaman Munshi, second secretary of VAT Act and Rule at the NBR, said: "The fact-finding mission was pleased with the value-added tax collection.

"Last fiscal year, we crossed the IMF's VAT collection target, gathering over Tk 150,700 crore."

He added that the delegation asked to submit both medium- and long-term revenue strategies by December this year as well as provide an update on the progress of the digital transformation process.

The IMF mission held four meetings with the NBR yesterday, including the three wings for income tax, value-added tax and customs.​
 

Interest payments surpass Tk 100,000cr for first time

1727482590811.webp


The government's interest payments against loans surged 24.5 percent in fiscal year 2023-24, exceeding the Tk 100,000 crore mark for the first time in history, thanks to higher borrowing costs for loans from both domestic and foreign sources.

According to the finance ministry's fiscal report released yesterday, over Tk 114,000 crore was spent on interest payments in FY24, representing more than one-sixth of the national budget.

While spending on subsidies decreased slightly, the government missed the revenue targets set by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for its ongoing $4.7 billion loan programme.

Initially, the government allocated Tk 94,376 crore for interest payments in FY24. However, this figure rose to over Tk 105,000 crore in the revised budget.

However, the actual figure even overshot the revised mark, indicating the government's dependence on borrowing to finance budget deficits.

Interest payments for foreign loans increased 60.53 percent to Tk 15,150 crore last year while rising 20.48 percent to Tk 99,606 crore for domestic loans.

In FY23, total interest payments amounted to Tk 92,110 crore.

A finance ministry official said the government's annual borrowing to finance budget deficits had led to a growing stock of outstanding loans.

As of March 2024, the government's total outstanding debt stood at Tk 1,697,415 crore, which is equivalent to 33.78 percent of the country's gross domestic product (GDP).

The Finance Division's Medium-Term Macroeconomic Policy Statement (MTMPS) said that interest payments would continue to rise gradually in the coming years.

The report mentioned that the proportion of external interest payments as a percentage of the national budget would rise to 2.6 percent in FY27 from 0.9 percent in FY22, reflecting the growing impact of external debt on the budget.

The report also said two major factors contributed to the increase in interest payments for foreign loans.

It further anticipated that reference rates in advanced economies, which serve as benchmarks for setting other interest rates, would remain elevated for some time.

Besides, Bangladesh's graduation from least developed country status in 2026 will gradually limit access to concessional loans from external sources, increasing borrowing pressure.

"This increase is attributed to a higher proportion of borrowing through floating and semi-concessional rates, which are more sensitive to market fluctuations compared to fixed-rate financing," said the report.

Moreover, the depreciation of the local currency taka against the US dollar has inflated the value of external debt when measured in terms of the local currency.

Regarding domestic borrowing, the banking sector has been the main source of funds. The Bangladesh Bank's recent policy rate increases have contributed to rising interest payments on domestic loans.

SUBSIDY EXPENDITURES DECLINE SLIGHTLY

The government has also been facing a new challenge due to significantly increased subsidy expenditures in recent years.

As such, the IMF has been pushing the government to reduce these expenditures by raising power and fertiliser prices.

In FY24, the government spent less on subsidies than allocated in the revised budget. In the revised budget, the total subsidy allocation was Tk 85,906 crore, but actual spending amounted to Tk 72,497 crore.

IMF TARGET MISSED AGAIN

After the IMF approved a $4.7 billion loan programme in January last year, the government struggled to meet the targets set for revenue and foreign currency reserves. In most cases, it has failed to achieve the targets.

As a result, the government had to seek a waiver for disbursal of three tranches of the loan so far.

For the fourth tranche, the IMF has set the target for tax revenue collection at around Tk 394,000 crore by June this year.

At the end of the last fiscal year, the government's tax revenue collection was Tk 369,000 crore, meaning it missed the target by Tk 25,240 crore.

BUDGET IMPLEMENTATION FALLS FLAT

Despite announcing large annual budgets, the government consistently fell short in implementation.

In the last fiscal year, the budget size was initially set at around Tk 761,000 crore before being revised to Tk 714,000 crore. However, total budget spending reached only Tk 602,000 crore.

The spending in the previous fiscal year was around Tk 574,000 crore.

Last year, the government allocated Tk 245,000 crore for the Annual Development Programme (ADP) in the revised budget but spent only Tk 188,000 crore.

In FY23, the ADP spending was Tk 192,000 crore.​
 

PKDefense Forums: Country-by-Country Military Discussions

Log In Register Forums
Back